[2016-04-09 01:37:09] -->| YOU (Lakituthequick) have joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:37:09] =-= Topic for #mwikiawards is ``"An Excellent Meeting" - Chef Excellence, 2015 || Awards are canceled, I have a hair appointment the day of the ceremony and I can't miss it, soz || 1st meeting hype || http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36197.0 Links || Number of meetings survived: 5'' [2016-04-09 01:37:09] =-= Topic for #mwikiawards was set by Gabumon!chatzilla@hmln-747-728-375-889.797.223.pools.vodafone-ip.de on zaterdag 2 april 2016 4:07:49 [2016-04-09 01:37:09] *ChanServ* [#mwikiawards] Chatroom rules: https://docs.google.com/View?id=drz9zgp_106rcrvqhhj [2016-04-09 01:37:09] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Lakituthequick by ChanServ [2016-04-09 01:44:12] -->| Anton{Politoed} (Mibbit@cwe-71-17-709-8.buffalo.res.rr.com) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:44:13] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Anton{Politoed} by ChanServ [2016-04-09 01:45:58] boyez [2016-04-09 01:54:16] 4~5 minutes [2016-04-09 01:54:40] -->| Freakworld (Freakworld@g52a78691.dyn.telefonica.de) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:54:40] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Freakworld by ChanServ [2016-04-09 01:54:52] -->| Glitchy (Mibbit@g88-78-237-623.home.cgocable.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:56:03] 9,1just in time [2016-04-09 01:56:10] 9,1my brain has recovered from being fried [2016-04-09 01:56:20] me and tb started laying groundwork for minecraft games last night [2016-04-09 01:56:32] let's dedicate the first five minutes to praising us for actually doing something [2016-04-09 01:56:51] ::clap [2016-04-09 01:57:16] z [2016-04-09 01:57:25] -->| Nabber__ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:57:27] 12yeah [2016-04-09 01:57:29] =-= Nabber__ is now known as Nabber [2016-04-09 01:57:33] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Nabber by ChanServ [2016-04-09 01:57:37] 12i'm gonna be a little late to this one [2016-04-09 01:57:40] -->| SonicMario (Mibbit@107.50.huy.xh) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 01:57:40] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o SonicMario by ChanServ [2016-04-09 01:57:47] 12maybe twenty or thirty minutes or so [2016-04-09 01:58:05] 9,1nabber why do you keep disconnecting [2016-04-09 02:00:03] . [2016-04-09 02:00:52] fyi my activity is going to be sporadic [2016-04-09 02:00:54] 4ok so hi [2016-04-09 02:01:03] im doing homework and studying simultaneously [2016-04-09 02:01:09] so i dont get bogged down on sunday [2016-04-09 02:01:20] 4here we are at another fabulous meeting [2016-04-09 02:01:26] im basically asleep [2016-04-09 02:01:29] 4our schedule for the night is: [2016-04-09 02:01:33] 4*F14 Worst Location (Edo’s idea) [2016-04-09 02:01:40] 4*F15 Most Disappointing Game (Accept new nominations) [2016-04-09 02:01:46] 4*Four new award ideas [2016-04-09 02:01:52] 4*Decide 5th new award idea [2016-04-09 02:02:00] 4*Begin User Awards [2016-04-09 02:02:16] 4so edo's not here right now and I haven't had time to read this thing [2016-04-09 02:02:17] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36644.0 [2016-04-09 02:02:27] 4and I'm not comfortable discussing something I have no clue about [2016-04-09 02:02:28] 4so [2016-04-09 02:02:32] 4we're skipping that until he shows up [2016-04-09 02:02:48] 4which leads us straight into F15 [2016-04-09 02:02:50] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36601.0 [2016-04-09 02:02:59] 4if you still need to vote now is your chance [2016-04-09 02:03:01] 4 22 are you here [2016-04-09 02:03:05] #ivoted [2016-04-09 02:03:11] i voted [2016-04-09 02:03:12] <_2257> 7yes [2016-04-09 02:03:14] will vote now [2016-04-09 02:03:15] it was 3 polls right [2016-04-09 02:03:16] i care [2016-04-09 02:03:19] just 3 [2016-04-09 02:03:20] 4 3 polls yes [2016-04-09 02:03:21] 9,1i voted [2016-04-09 02:03:23] ok i did all of them [2016-04-09 02:03:24] what was so disappointing abi [2016-04-09 02:03:27] 4might make a 4th one during te meeting [2016-04-09 02:03:28] 4the* [2016-04-09 02:03:31] *about dkrds [2016-04-09 02:03:32] yes pi sorry [2016-04-09 02:03:39] i don't know why my internet keeps disconnecting [2016-04-09 02:03:44] nyway fw i was gonna make this a post but i was out with relatives + took a nap [2016-04-09 02:03:59] 4I'll give a couple minutes to vote [2016-04-09 02:04:03] i suggested warioware for the thing because it's like the last good nominee we can get unless theres a bad subseriees that slipped under my nose [2016-04-09 02:04:06] diddy kong racing ds almost looked worse than the original [2016-04-09 02:04:15] and in some cases probably did [2016-04-09 02:04:23] any farther and we dig into "the new dkc is bad because they removed the kremlings even though theyre funcitonally good games" [2016-04-09 02:04:35] diddy kong racing ds almost looked worse than the original [2016-04-09 02:04:36] and in some cases probably did [2016-04-09 02:04:37] Very true. [2016-04-09 02:04:41] yeah [2016-04-09 02:04:51] ok i voted [2016-04-09 02:04:57] like mario 64 ds at least had a bit more polish to it [2016-04-09 02:05:00] i never played either so i cant tell [2016-04-09 02:05:21] also there was no conker or BAYANJOE [2016-04-09 02:05:30] 4gr8 I'm gonna lock the poll [2016-04-09 02:05:40] voted just in time [2016-04-09 02:05:40] nice [2016-04-09 02:05:59] 4ok we neeeeeeeed the top [2016-04-09 02:06:00] honestly im not sure we should include remakes in most disappointing game [2016-04-09 02:06:04] 4 10-13 [2016-04-09 02:06:12] anyways, smas wii was disappointing, because for whats its owrth it wasnt even the +smw version [2016-04-09 02:06:22] 4there's been a week to discuss this [2016-04-09 02:06:25] there was a +smw version? [2016-04-09 02:06:25] 4voting is closed [2016-04-09 02:06:35] 4whatever the results are are what we have [2016-04-09 02:06:40] i dont find it disappointing because they never advertised it as anything but vanilla smas on a wii disc [2016-04-09 02:06:40] <_2257> 71. Yoshi's Island DS [2016-04-09 02:06:42] <_2257> 7 13 (9.5%) [2016-04-09 02:06:44] <_2257> 72. Super Paper Mario [2016-04-09 02:06:46] <_2257> 7 12 (8.8%) [2016-04-09 02:06:49] <_2257> 72. Mario Party 9 [2016-04-09 02:06:51] <_2257> 7 12 (8.8%) [2016-04-09 02:06:53] <_2257> 72. Diddy Kong Racing DS [2016-04-09 02:06:54] <_2257> 7 12 (8.8%) [2016-04-09 02:06:56] <_2257> 75. Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash [2016-04-09 02:06:58] trifecta [2016-04-09 02:06:59] <_2257> 7 10 (7.3%) [2016-04-09 02:07:00] <_2257> 75. Super Mario All-Stars - 25th Anniversary Edition [2016-04-09 02:07:03] <_2257> 7 10 (7.3%) [2016-04-09 02:07:05] <_2257> 75. Super Mario 64 DS [2016-04-09 02:07:08] <_2257> 7 10 (7.3%) [2016-04-09 02:07:10] <_2257> 78. Super Mario 3D Land [2016-04-09 02:07:11] <_2257> 7 9 (6.6%) [2016-04-09 02:07:14] <_2257> 78. Mario Party: Island Tour [2016-04-09 02:07:16] <_2257> 7 9 (6.6%) [2016-04-09 02:07:17] <_2257> 710. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [2016-04-09 02:07:20] <_2257> 7 7 (5.1%) [2016-04-09 02:07:23] <_2257> 711. Mario Party 8 [2016-04-09 02:07:25] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 02:07:26] <_2257> 711. Super Mario Sunshine [2016-04-09 02:07:28] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 02:07:30] 9,1we did it [2016-04-09 02:07:31] <_2257> 713. NSMBU/NSLU [2016-04-09 02:07:34] <_2257> 7 5 (3.6%) [2016-04-09 02:07:35] <_2257> 713. Donkey Kong Country 3 [2016-04-09 02:07:37] <_2257> 7 5 (3.6%) [2016-04-09 02:07:39] <_2257> 7im glad smg2 got in [2016-04-09 02:07:40] im agreeing with turb on smas remake though [2016-04-09 02:07:42] <_2257> 7what an awful game [2016-04-09 02:07:44] <_2257> 7i was afraid it wouldnt make it [2016-04-09 02:07:46] what more did people expect [2016-04-09 02:07:48] 9,1I'm glad Sunshine got in [2016-04-09 02:07:55] anyway spm was in no way underwhleming to me so i couldnt [2016-04-09 02:08:06] its ok fw i didnt vote spm either [2016-04-09 02:08:07] w [2016-04-09 02:08:08] 4ok give me a moment to copy these down [2016-04-09 02:08:11] its a shame to see awful taste [2016-04-09 02:08:15] can we relaly put sunshine on a disappointing game award [2016-04-09 02:08:18] also dkc3 made it up there fuck that [2016-04-09 02:08:19] 9,1yes [2016-04-09 02:08:24] and mario sunshine [2016-04-09 02:08:29] [02:06] Freakworld anyways, smas wii was disappointing, because for whats its owrth it wasnt even the +smw version [2016-04-09 02:08:32] 9,1because it was disappointing to Super Mario 64 fans [2016-04-09 02:08:34] <_2257> 7well keep in mind [2016-04-09 02:08:36] 9,1such as me [2016-04-09 02:08:37] theres annoying things to sms but can you really call it disappointing [2016-04-09 02:08:39] <_2257> 7with the number of nominees [2016-04-09 02:08:44] tbh i didnt pay attention to advertising [2016-04-09 02:08:47] <_2257> 7only 3 things DIDNT get in [2016-04-09 02:09:12] <_2257> 7also there's a tie for 14th [2016-04-09 02:09:28] 9,1how [2016-04-09 02:09:43] 4 20:07 _2257 13. NSMBU/NSLU 20:07 _2257 5 (3.6%) 20:07 _2257 13. Donkey Kong Country 3 20:07 _2257 5 (3.6%) [2016-04-09 02:09:46] <_2257> 7i'm not sure what "how" is meant to mean in this context [2016-04-09 02:09:46] 4that's 1 too many [2016-04-09 02:09:48] 4we need to decide [2016-04-09 02:10:00] i vote for nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:10:08] ill wait until we have an official vote [2016-04-09 02:10:08] cant nsmbu/nslu be condensed into 1? [2016-04-09 02:10:12] it is gamefreak [2016-04-09 02:10:15] o [2016-04-09 02:10:19] lol [2016-04-09 02:10:32] tbh nsmbu wasnt even disappointing because i dont think anyone expected anything out of it so [2016-04-09 02:10:35] dkc3 [2016-04-09 02:10:39] fuck you freakworld [2016-04-09 02:10:45] 4ok but let me make it official [2016-04-09 02:10:56] 4Vote: Include which game into F15? (NSMBU / DKC3 / a) [2016-04-09 02:10:59] a [2016-04-09 02:11:00] NSMBU [2016-04-09 02:11:00] i vote nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:11:02] <_2257> 7n [2016-04-09 02:11:03] nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:11:03] dkc3 [2016-04-09 02:11:05] DKC3 [2016-04-09 02:11:08] N (smbu) [2016-04-09 02:11:10] 9,1a [2016-04-09 02:11:11] a [2016-04-09 02:11:12] <_2257> 7i guess [2016-04-09 02:11:13] a [2016-04-09 02:11:16] nsmbu is meh [2016-04-09 02:11:20] dkc3 is good [2016-04-09 02:11:23] nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:11:35] found nsmbu to be decent and haven't played dkc3 so [2016-04-09 02:11:36] <_2257> 7tbh i havent played nsmbu but i feel like abstaining at this point is fairly unhelpful [2016-04-09 02:11:57] 9,1i like both games [2016-04-09 02:11:57] i don't know where this thought that dkc3 is a bad game arose [2016-04-09 02:12:02] it's better than 1 to be honest [2016-04-09 02:12:08] people just butt angrey david wise didnt compose it [2016-04-09 02:12:11] probably the same place the idea that sms is a bad game arose [2016-04-09 02:12:15] but i guess i shouldnt clog the meeting with a dkc fanboy cage match [2016-04-09 02:12:18] -->| Nabber_ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:12:18] im ok with dkc3, never played nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:12:22] the same reason people hate spm [2016-04-09 02:12:25] 4 7-2-4 ?? [2016-04-09 02:12:28] its not like the original [2016-04-09 02:12:29] It's not bad game. It's disappointing. DKC3 can be considered a dissapointment to some who really liked DKC2 and such. [2016-04-09 02:12:29] ive never played dkc3 but i only know that i didnt feel like nsmbu got a lot of hate [2016-04-09 02:12:33] or first two games [2016-04-09 02:12:45] how different is it though [2016-04-09 02:12:49] i really dont get that argument [2016-04-09 02:12:51] NSMBU [2016-04-09 02:13:04] -->| Nabber__ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:13:09] yeah im changing to nsmbu [2016-04-09 02:13:19] only really big change is kiddy/diddy [2016-04-09 02:13:24] |<-- Nabber has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Killed (NickServ (GHOST command used by Nabber__))) [2016-04-09 02:13:28] =-= Nabber__ is now known as Nabber [2016-04-09 02:13:29] they played basically the same [2016-04-09 02:13:31] 4ok we have a clear enough winner so [2016-04-09 02:13:32] and to be honest i think kiddy controls better than diddy [2016-04-09 02:13:36] dixie still has her mechanics in [2016-04-09 02:13:37] 4NSMBU/NSLU will be added [2016-04-09 02:13:40] good [2016-04-09 02:13:40] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Nabber by ChanServ [2016-04-09 02:13:41] actually change to a for the re- [2016-04-09 02:13:42] greet [2016-04-09 02:13:44] okay [2016-04-09 02:13:54] yes [2016-04-09 02:14:04] 9,1nsmbu is the best nsmb game play it at least once ok [2016-04-09 02:14:13] 4full award is: [2016-04-09 02:14:13] nsmbds is better tbh [2016-04-09 02:14:13] the bigger disappointent was nsmbw for me anyways [2016-04-09 02:14:23] 4F15 Most Disappointing Game (New Super Mario Bros. 2, Paper Mario: Sticker Star, Yoshi’s New Island, Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games, Mario Party 10, Yoshi’s Island DS, Super Paper Mario, Mario Party 9, Diddy Kong Racing DS, Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash, Super Mario All-Stars - 25th Anniversary Edition, Super Mario 64 DS, Super Mario 3D Land [2016-04-09 02:14:24] 4Mario Party: Island Tour, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Mario Party 8, Super Mario Sunshine, NSMBU/NSLU) [2016-04-09 02:14:31] 9,1yay [2016-04-09 02:14:35] 9,1I'm glad Sunshine got in [2016-04-09 02:14:48] what do you have against sunshine :( [2016-04-09 02:14:52] >mario galaxy 2 >mario party 8 [2016-04-09 02:14:54] bh [2016-04-09 02:14:56] yeah sunshine's great [2016-04-09 02:14:56] *bah [2016-04-09 02:15:07] "i am a certified reformed troll" - pi [2016-04-09 02:15:15] i voted for sunshine because i know that created an uproar [2016-04-09 02:15:19] sunshine is better than 64 [2016-04-09 02:15:22] 4ok gr8 [2016-04-09 02:15:24] 4so moving on [2016-04-09 02:15:36] also corona mountain [2016-04-09 02:15:43] f u c k corona mountain [2016-04-09 02:15:44] 4Worst 3D Level [2016-04-09 02:15:46] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36573.0 [2016-04-09 02:15:47] see [2016-04-09 02:15:50] 4if you haven't voted, now is your time [2016-04-09 02:15:51] <_2257> 7mario galaxy 2 was absolute garbage and if you disagree you're inarguably wrong [2016-04-09 02:16:01] i hope toxic waterfall wins this [2016-04-09 02:16:02] voting now [2016-04-09 02:16:03] 9,1mario galaxy 2 was ok [2016-04-09 02:16:06] i couldnt vote on a lot of these lol [2016-04-09 02:16:10] <_2257> 7*absolute garbage [2016-04-09 02:16:15] 9,1was ok [2016-04-09 02:16:18] i liked all the mario 64 levels well enough and remembered basically no galaxies [2016-04-09 02:16:26] msg2 is literally the same game as the first one tho [2016-04-09 02:16:30] *smg [2016-04-09 02:16:34] mgs2 [2016-04-09 02:16:35] and thats why its bad [2016-04-09 02:16:41] it made no attemtp to branch out [2016-04-09 02:16:42] metal solid gear [2016-04-09 02:16:47] <_2257> 7its NOT the same as the first one, its significantly worse [2016-04-09 02:16:48] also for the record, mgs2 is a good game [2016-04-09 02:16:54] |<-- Nabber_ has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Ping timeout: 265 seconds) [2016-04-09 02:17:46] shut up gamepad [2016-04-09 02:17:51] trying to sell me shit [2016-04-09 02:17:59] 9,1you can disable that you know [2016-04-09 02:18:12] 4in addition, while we wait [2016-04-09 02:18:13] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36574.0 [2016-04-09 02:18:18] 4if you haven't voted in this one either now is your time [2016-04-09 02:18:33] can i abstain voting from the last one [2016-04-09 02:18:37] 4if it's locked halfway through you voting, sucks [2016-04-09 02:18:40] 4and sure [2016-04-09 02:18:44] 12HI [2016-04-09 02:18:46] i know no mario party minigame by its english name i think [2016-04-09 02:18:48] 4hi [2016-04-09 02:18:51] lol [2016-04-09 02:18:54] except for tug o war [2016-04-09 02:18:54] yo udont need to know the minigames just vote random ones [2016-04-09 02:18:55] i did [2016-04-09 02:18:58] ok actually voted in the mario party poll before [2016-04-09 02:19:00] i don't really feel like im qualified to vote for either of these [2016-04-09 02:19:02] i just took like 20 minutes out of my day to look them up on the wiki [2016-04-09 02:19:03] freakworld pick anything with bob-omb or cheep cheep in the name [2016-04-09 02:19:04] actually ill vote for that [2016-04-09 02:19:04] it's not hard [2016-04-09 02:19:06] those are the worst ones [2016-04-09 02:19:12] i guess you can't do it now because it's getting locked but [2016-04-09 02:19:13] i actually remembered a lot of these games [2016-04-09 02:19:15] without having to look them up [2016-04-09 02:19:16] sucks to be you [2016-04-09 02:19:18] 4yeah the wiki has them all by their english names [2016-04-09 02:19:19] i was impressed with myself [2016-04-09 02:19:24] 4again, there's been a few days to vote on these [2016-04-09 02:19:26] i remembered a couple 1-3 ones [2016-04-09 02:19:36] well 1-3 are all ive really played more than once [2016-04-09 02:19:39] there i voted for tug o war [2016-04-09 02:19:42] i only remembered the 1, 2, ds, and some of 8 ones [2016-04-09 02:19:44] so lol [2016-04-09 02:19:49] actually [2016-04-09 02:19:52] 4voting is locked on 3d level [2016-04-09 02:19:53] i remember the gamecube one being fun [2016-04-09 02:19:56] where you used the mic [2016-04-09 02:20:05] 4 22 can you plz post the top 15-18 [2016-04-09 02:20:09] 4a true hero [2016-04-09 02:20:13] i never had the mic [2016-04-09 02:20:22] 12both of my last minute noms made it into most disappointing game [2016-04-09 02:20:25] 12i'm so glad [2016-04-09 02:20:35] <_2257> 71. Corona Mountain (SMS) [2016-04-09 02:20:37] couldnt get myself to decide on a bad smg/smg2 level [2016-04-09 02:20:37] <_2257> 7 14 (7.6%) [2016-04-09 02:20:38] 12for the record i would have said nsmbu over dkc3 too [2016-04-09 02:20:40] <_2257> 72. The Toxic Waterfall (SMS) [2016-04-09 02:20:41] <_2257> 7 13 (7%) [2016-04-09 02:20:44] <_2257> 73. Pachinko/Pinball Secret (SMS) [2016-04-09 02:20:45] <_2257> 7 9 (4.9%) [2016-04-09 02:20:47] <_2257> 73. Stone Cyclone Galaxy (SMG2) [2016-04-09 02:20:48] 12i don't think either are that good choices for it, though [2016-04-09 02:20:50] <_2257> 7 9 (4.9%) [2016-04-09 02:20:52] <_2257> 75. Wing Mario over the Rainbow (SM64) [2016-04-09 02:20:52] 12oh well [2016-04-09 02:20:53] <_2257> 7 8 (4.3%) [2016-04-09 02:20:54] that sms 1, 2, 3 punch [2016-04-09 02:20:56] <_2257> 75. Sling Pod Galaxy (SMG) [2016-04-09 02:20:58] <_2257> 7 8 (4.3%) [2016-04-09 02:21:00] <_2257> 77. Rainbow Ride (SM64) [2016-04-09 02:21:02] <_2257> 7 7 (3.8%) [2016-04-09 02:21:04] <_2257> 77. Twisty Trials Galaxy (SMG2) [2016-04-09 02:21:05] <_2257> 7 7 (3.8%) [2016-04-09 02:21:07] <_2257> 77. Special 8-3 (SM3DL) [2016-04-09 02:21:09] <_2257> 7 7 (3.8%) [2016-04-09 02:21:12] <_2257> 710. Rolling Gizmo Galaxy (SMG) [2016-04-09 02:21:13] <_2257> 7 6 (3.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:15] <_2257> 710. Boss Blitz Galaxy (SMG2) [2016-04-09 02:21:17] corona mountain and the final boss fight are just stupid [2016-04-09 02:21:18] <_2257> 7 6 (3.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:21] <_2257> 712. Goldleaf Galaxy (SMG) [2016-04-09 02:21:23] <_2257> 7 5 (2.7%) [2016-04-09 02:21:25] <_2257> 712. Bubble Breeze Galaxy (SMG) [2016-04-09 02:21:26] <_2257> 7 5 (2.7%) [2016-04-09 02:21:28] these are all from the good 3d mario games [2016-04-09 02:21:29] <_2257> 712. World 1-1 (SM3DL) [2016-04-09 02:21:31] <_2257> 7 5 (2.7%) [2016-04-09 02:21:32] <_2257> 712. World 8-6 (SM3DL) [2016-04-09 02:21:35] <_2257> 7 5 (2.7%) [2016-04-09 02:21:36] 1-1 [2016-04-09 02:21:36] <_2257> 716. Sea Slide Galaxy (SMG) [2016-04-09 02:21:39] <_2257> 7 4 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:40] how could the first level be that bad [2016-04-09 02:21:40] <_2257> 716. Rainbow Run (SM3DW) [2016-04-09 02:21:42] sm3dl is so low [2016-04-09 02:21:42] <_2257> 7 4 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:44] wow [2016-04-09 02:21:44] <_2257> 716. Broken Blue Bully Belt (SM3DW) [2016-04-09 02:21:47] <_2257> 7 4 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:48] <_2257> 716. Fuzzy Time Mine (SM3DW) [2016-04-09 02:21:50] <_2257> 7 4 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 02:21:58] all the levels in that game are more or less bad when compared to sm3dw [2016-04-09 02:22:03] i guess even if an sm3dw level is bad theyre all so unmemorable nobody remembered to vote for them [2016-04-09 02:22:10] <_2257> 7glad twisty trials aka literal shit got in [2016-04-09 02:22:13] also that lol [2016-04-09 02:22:16] triggered [2016-04-09 02:22:16] i found nothing wrong with 1-1 3d land [2016-04-09 02:22:25] it was bland but it wasn't bad [2016-04-09 02:22:29] <_2257> 7sad that mario squared aka more literal shit did not get in [2016-04-09 02:22:33] i remembered the bad sm3dl levels better than the sm3dw levels [2016-04-09 02:22:43] 9,1My vote is for Sea Slide because it is an irredeemable fact that the level can cure the toughest cases of insomnia. [2016-04-09 02:23:01] i dont think we need to tiebreak do we? [2016-04-09 02:23:16] 12i don't remember any of those last four but [2016-04-09 02:23:17] wouldve voted for hazy maze cave but the scuttblugs told me not to [2016-04-09 02:23:20] 9,1we don't :( [2016-04-09 02:23:21] oh i noticed theres 4 #12s [2016-04-09 02:23:23] nbm [2016-04-09 02:23:25] *scuttlebugs [2016-04-09 02:23:27] ok gotta go eat now [2016-04-09 02:23:29] <_2257> 7hazy maze cave is great [2016-04-09 02:23:33] 9,1or maybe we do [2016-04-09 02:23:33] ill be back [2016-04-09 02:23:34] 4ok is this 1 too many [2016-04-09 02:23:34] i voted hazy maze [2016-04-09 02:23:36] did anyone else [2016-04-09 02:23:37] <_2257> 7freakworld confirmed to have not aste [2016-04-09 02:23:44] 9,1hazy maze is great [2016-04-09 02:23:46] 4yeah it's 1 too many [2016-04-09 02:23:56] 12i'm not sure if we need any of them honestly? do we really want 18, we have 15 [2016-04-09 02:23:59] hazy maze cave is my least favorite regular level in sm64 tbh [2016-04-09 02:24:05] its still not bad though [2016-04-09 02:24:10] drop fuzzy time, i guess [2016-04-09 02:24:25] 4we can easily stay at 15 [2016-04-09 02:24:30] i only voted for wing mario over the rainbow because thats just a bad concept [2016-04-09 02:24:30] 4and not even consider the 4 16th places [2016-04-09 02:24:39] that works too [2016-04-09 02:24:40] -->| Packy (BEEEEEEEEE@zwf-625-760-190-53.trans-video.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:24:41] 12i'll abstain from voting though if we do want to add some of them but i personally think we're fine [2016-04-09 02:24:54] Hi Packy [2016-04-09 02:24:59] Hi SM <3 [2016-04-09 02:25:16] 4honestly I'd be fine with just dropping that 16th place SMG one [2016-04-09 02:25:25] 4and let the SM3DW's in for variety [2016-04-09 02:25:37] 12actually i just looked and yeah [2016-04-09 02:25:44] 12there's no sm3dw levels in there as is [2016-04-09 02:25:57] 12so i'll switch to saying let those three in [2016-04-09 02:26:05] 4ok let's make that the vote [2016-04-09 02:26:27] 4Vote: Drop the 16th place SMG game in favor of the 3 SM3DW's? (y/n/a) [2016-04-09 02:26:28] 4y [2016-04-09 02:26:30] 12y [2016-04-09 02:26:31] y [2016-04-09 02:26:31] y [2016-04-09 02:26:32] 9,1n [2016-04-09 02:26:33] y [2016-04-09 02:26:33] y [2016-04-09 02:26:34] y [2016-04-09 02:26:37] y [2016-04-09 02:26:40] y [2016-04-09 02:26:44] 129-1-0 [2016-04-09 02:26:47] pi wants to see the world burn [2016-04-09 02:26:49] Wait [2016-04-09 02:27:01] <_2257> 7n [2016-04-09 02:27:02] oh these are levels [2016-04-09 02:27:03] 9,1Sea Slide is the most boring level in any Mario game. [2016-04-09 02:27:07] 129-2-0 [2016-04-09 02:27:10] I abstain [2016-04-09 02:27:14] copy pastable [2016-04-09 02:27:15] Corona Mountain (SMS), The Toxic Waterfall (SMS), Pachinko/Pinball Secret (SMS), Stone Cyclone Galaxy (SMG2), Wing Mario over the Rainbow (SM64), Sling Pod Galaxy (SMG), Rainbow Ride (SM64), Twisty Trials Galaxy (SMG2), Special 8-3 (SM3DL), Rolling Gizmo Galaxy (SMG), Boss Blitz Galaxy (SMG2), Goldleaf Galaxy (SMG), Bubble Breeze Galaxy (SMG), World 1-1 (SM3DL), World 8-6 (SM3DL), Rainbow... [2016-04-09 02:27:15] ...Run (SM3DW), Broken Blue Bully Belt (SM3DW), Fuzzy Time Mine (SM3DW) [2016-04-09 02:27:19] y [2016-04-09 02:27:35] oh THATS sea slide galaxy [2016-04-09 02:27:42] 12i don't remember any of these i just want to include some variety and there's enough smg levels [2016-04-09 02:27:47] 1210-2-1 [2016-04-09 02:27:47] the purple comet in that one is one of my favorites lol [2016-04-09 02:28:01] that purple coin mission sucks [2016-04-09 02:28:22] i feel like it requires some more effort than others and i like that [2016-04-09 02:28:36] same with the freezeflame galaxy one [2016-04-09 02:28:37] i kinda enjoy it [2016-04-09 02:28:41] it's nice going around finding all the things [2016-04-09 02:28:47] yea [2016-04-09 02:28:51] at least it's not as easy to fuck up as in freezeflame [2016-04-09 02:28:55] thats kinda what smg2 has been missing [2016-04-09 02:28:57] freezeflame is one of the worst [2016-04-09 02:29:00] 4so unless the dissenting opinions have a passionate response to sway the others I'm going to accept this as the final award selection [2016-04-09 02:29:08] only two worst p coin missions are toy time and dreadnought [2016-04-09 02:29:09] thats my favorite actually [2016-04-09 02:29:10] both awful [2016-04-09 02:29:32] 12freezeflame was the last star i got in smg actually [2016-04-09 02:29:35] toy time was the worst purple coin mission that was incedibly dumb [2016-04-09 02:29:35] 12i didn't like it at all [2016-04-09 02:29:58] <_2257> 7you knwo what was worse tahn luigi's purple coins? [2016-04-09 02:30:05] was toy time purple coins the one on the mario sprite [2016-04-09 02:30:06] the one in smg2? [2016-04-09 02:30:08] -->| Nabber_ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:30:10] yes [2016-04-09 02:30:12] <_2257> 7yes [2016-04-09 02:30:14] <_2257> 7the one in smg2 [2016-04-09 02:30:22] i liked that one [2016-04-09 02:30:24] 9,1Luigi's Purple Coins was a good mission [2016-04-09 02:30:24] 4ok I'm taking that as we can move on [2016-04-09 02:30:26] tbh i had less problems with that one [2016-04-09 02:30:27] <_2257> 7and yet somehow, that level didn't get in [2016-04-09 02:30:28] strangely [2016-04-09 02:30:32] it's tricky but difficult != bad [2016-04-09 02:30:40] im back [2016-04-09 02:30:45] <_2257> 7lpc is easy the second time around tbh [2016-04-09 02:30:47] -->| Kotori_Minami (Nyrie@xru-23-539-44-92.nc.res.rr.com) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:30:53] no uniju, fuck luigis purple coins [2016-04-09 02:30:55] <_2257> 7i got it in 1 try when i had to redo it with luigi [2016-04-09 02:30:55] 4Worst Direction of Series [2016-04-09 02:30:56] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36571.0 [2016-04-09 02:30:59] <_2257> 7and again in smg2 [2016-04-09 02:31:00] 4let's try to stay on track [2016-04-09 02:31:15] 4*Gutting of Mario Vs donkey kong series *Paper Mario's modern direction *Amiibo-centric/focused games *Mario Party's modern direction *Mario Tennis *New Super Mario Bros. series *Mario 3D games [2016-04-09 02:31:17] =-= Kotori_Minami is now known as Nyrie [2016-04-09 02:31:20] 4is the only list I have for it at the moment [2016-04-09 02:31:24] 4it could use some refining [2016-04-09 02:31:36] 9,1this is a minor thing but amiibo is never capitalised [2016-04-09 02:31:37] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Nyrie by ChanServ [2016-04-09 02:31:42] technically, amiibo-centric games doesn't count for a single series, but im still fine with it [2016-04-09 02:31:51] 9,1this is a thing that should be considered for the final poll only [2016-04-09 02:31:54] i think its fitting enough [2016-04-09 02:31:57] how about we just go with the series name [2016-04-09 02:31:58] 4it's the only list I have at the moment, formatting isn't a concern right now [2016-04-09 02:32:01] theres no other award it could really go on [2016-04-09 02:32:13] 9,1which I perfectly stated anyway s [2016-04-09 02:32:14] 9,1o [2016-04-09 02:32:30] 9,1in either case [2016-04-09 02:32:33] 9,1I'm fine with the list [2016-04-09 02:32:47] i would say add warioware on there [2016-04-09 02:32:50] but that's just me [2016-04-09 02:32:55] 9,1toss it on [2016-04-09 02:32:59] 9,1where's the harm [2016-04-09 02:33:11] [02:31] Freakworld how about we just go with the series name [2016-04-09 02:33:12] is game and wario warioware [2016-04-09 02:33:14] 4how will each of these nominees be worded [2016-04-09 02:33:16] yes [2016-04-09 02:33:17] i like the warioware series, but yeah toss it in [2016-04-09 02:33:21] 4there's no consistency at the moment [2016-04-09 02:33:21] glitchy: yes [2016-04-09 02:33:26] would the direction of the Yoshi's Island series fit? [2016-04-09 02:33:32] ok [2016-04-09 02:33:37] i guess packy [2016-04-09 02:33:38] i was considering that packy [2016-04-09 02:33:42] but yww came otu [2016-04-09 02:33:44] i guess it could work though [2016-04-09 02:33:45] i would add warioware then [2016-04-09 02:33:49] |<-- Nabber has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Ping timeout: 265 seconds) [2016-04-09 02:33:52] even though yww is like [2016-04-09 02:33:57] maybe the amiibo one could be like "amiibo-locked content" [2016-04-09 02:33:58] ヽ( ◕ヮ◕)ノ [2016-04-09 02:34:01] idk most people agree that thats good i guess but [2016-04-09 02:34:08] yni certainly wasnt so [2016-04-09 02:34:15] it probably qualifies [2016-04-09 02:34:22] i don't think it was supposed to be amiibo locked content in particular [2016-04-09 02:34:27] yeah that's why I was thought the Island series rather than Yoshi in general [2016-04-09 02:34:31] 4woolly world was fantastic and I'd consider that a good break in the shit cycle [2016-04-09 02:34:33] just the fact that they permeate every aspect of the game [2016-04-09 02:34:37] oh [2016-04-09 02:34:37] since Woolly World wasn't necessarily an Island game [2016-04-09 02:34:38] but idk [2016-04-09 02:34:41] it's semantics for the most part [2016-04-09 02:34:45] unless they're the same series for the most part [2016-04-09 02:34:46] i also thought yoshis story but okay [2016-04-09 02:34:46] also i understand that pacy [2016-04-09 02:34:57] we should vote on that and warioware [2016-04-09 02:35:27] id do both tbh just because theres no real reason not to include warioware imo [2016-04-09 02:35:30] 4no one seemed to oppose warioware so I think it's a safe inclusion [2016-04-09 02:35:38] 12i'm fine with both warioware and yoshi's island [2016-04-09 02:35:54] 12woolly world was great, but yids and ew island exists [2016-04-09 02:36:06] 12i meant new but ew island may actually be a good name for it lol [2016-04-09 02:36:10] 12i haven't actually played it though [2016-04-09 02:36:12] 4but we can decide on yoshi's island [2016-04-09 02:36:13] 4http://www.mariowiki.com/Yoshi_%28series%29 [2016-04-09 02:36:23] 4the series is simply referred to as Yoshi, including all of the game [2016-04-09 02:36:28] 4s [2016-04-09 02:36:30] maybe Yoshi (series) [2016-04-09 02:36:32] never played any warioware games so i can't really have an opinion [2016-04-09 02:36:32] then [2016-04-09 02:36:44] per gf i dont think it matters much [2016-04-09 02:36:51] people will understand [2016-04-09 02:36:58] 4it will have to be Yoshi (series) [2016-04-09 02:37:04] 4that's how the wiki views it [2016-04-09 02:37:04] yoshi (series) is probably fine [2016-04-09 02:37:05] warioware games are great the end [2016-04-09 02:37:09] 4we can't break it up [2016-04-09 02:37:14] that's fine with me [2016-04-09 02:37:16] per CountBonsula [2016-04-09 02:37:24] <_2257> 7i really dont' think there's anything official about the way the wiki views it [2016-04-09 02:37:34] if people think they're great they'll get less votes [2016-04-09 02:37:43] yeah but arent we affliated with the wiki [2016-04-09 02:37:45] <_2257> 7i dont really care though [2016-04-09 02:37:47] i dunno [2016-04-09 02:37:52] 4either way the gameplay is nearly identical [2016-04-09 02:38:03] 4so, let's decide on adding Yoshi [2016-04-09 02:38:03] <_2257> 7yoshi's island is obviously going to be a tiny player compared to things like papaer mario [2016-04-09 02:38:15] 12even if it's not official, it's the best way to cover everything [2016-04-09 02:38:29] 12so just "yoshi" would be the best way to add it [2016-04-09 02:38:37] 4Vote: Add "Yoshi (series)" into the nominee listing for Worst Direction of Series? (y/n/a) [2016-04-09 02:38:39] 9,1y [2016-04-09 02:38:41] y [2016-04-09 02:38:42] y [2016-04-09 02:38:42] y [2016-04-09 02:38:43] a [2016-04-09 02:38:44] a [2016-04-09 02:38:44] 12y [2016-04-09 02:38:47] 4n [2016-04-09 02:38:52] 125-1-2 [2016-04-09 02:38:56] a [2016-04-09 02:39:02] y [2016-04-09 02:39:08] y [2016-04-09 02:39:09] 126-1-3 [2016-04-09 02:39:15] <_2257> 7y [2016-04-09 02:39:17] 128-1-3 [2016-04-09 02:39:26] y [2016-04-09 02:39:34] anton why are you against it? just curious [2016-04-09 02:39:37] 128.5-1-3 [2016-04-09 02:39:41] Yes [2016-04-09 02:39:44] 4because woolly world is included and it was good [2016-04-09 02:39:47] 129.5-1-3 [2016-04-09 02:39:55] y [2016-04-09 02:39:56] 4just because DS and New Island were bad in the middle, does that make the entire series direction bad [2016-04-09 02:40:01] a [2016-04-09 02:40:01] not necessarily [2016-04-09 02:40:06] Oh wait, is Wolly World in the mix? [2016-04-09 02:40:06] i jsut want to add it to test the waters [2016-04-09 02:40:12] *Woolly [2016-04-09 02:40:13] no but thats what people will think [2016-04-09 02:40:14] yeah [2016-04-09 02:40:14] idk i'm kind of on the fence with it [2016-04-09 02:40:15] if it gets like 2 votes, we nuke it off of the award next year [2016-04-09 02:40:15] 4I'm including it because the wiki includes it [2016-04-09 02:40:21] Change to abstain [2016-04-09 02:40:24] 4if someone else decides it's not, I guess that's on them [2016-04-09 02:40:36] i don't think the direction as Yoshi (series) makes the direction bad as much as it would be if it were Yoshi's Island (series) [2016-04-09 02:40:40] If Woolly World is the new direction of the series, I think it's good. [2016-04-09 02:40:42] so change me to A [2016-04-09 02:40:45] yeah i dunno yww is good but just because the direction changed to be good recently doesnt really undo the direction having been really bad for a long time i dont think [2016-04-09 02:40:52] per uniju [2016-04-09 02:40:54] per uniju [2016-04-09 02:40:55] 128.5-1-5 [2016-04-09 02:40:57] 12per uniju [2016-04-09 02:40:58] If it turns out to the exception, and they continue to shove out more Island games... [2016-04-09 02:41:16] or yoshis story 2 [2016-04-09 02:41:20] <_2257> 7i'm just voting yes because of what turb said [2016-04-09 02:41:21] minus the good music [2016-04-09 02:41:28] 4I'm going to keep my N but either way it looks like it's added and if the voters decide yww is included then it will be reflected in results [2016-04-09 02:41:31] and poochy [2016-04-09 02:41:37] <_2257> 7the worst thing that'll happen is itll get 2 votes [2016-04-09 02:41:48] 4yeah [2016-04-09 02:41:57] personally i feel that [2016-04-09 02:42:04] there's nothing particularly bad about the series that they've been doing [2016-04-09 02:42:09] the worst thing thatll happen is mario kart becomes a write in and gets more votes [2016-04-09 02:42:09] they just made bad games [2016-04-09 02:42:15] if that happens ill quit [2016-04-09 02:42:30] 4are there any other series to add [2016-04-09 02:42:31] nabber thats like part of the award though [2016-04-09 02:42:42] not off the top of my head [2016-04-09 02:42:48] i feel like the other series have been getting worse because of bad decision making [2016-04-09 02:42:56] 4*Gutting of Mario Vs donkey kong series *Paper Mario's modern direction *Amiibo-centric/focused games *Mario Party's modern direction *Mario Tennis *New Super Mario Bros. series *Mario 3D games *Warioware *Yoshi (series) [2016-04-09 02:42:57] dkc is good and i feel like we've covered every applicable mario sports game [2016-04-09 02:42:57] <_2257> 7...isnt making bad games a bad direction for the series? [2016-04-09 02:42:58] 4this isn't final wording [2016-04-09 02:43:24] whereas with the yoshi series it's that the games themselves have fluctuated in quality [2016-04-09 02:43:32] 9,1actually [2016-04-09 02:43:34] 9,1add dkc [2016-04-09 02:43:35] i do see where nabber's coming from although i disagree [2016-04-09 02:43:43] why dkc? [2016-04-09 02:43:45] 9,1there are people that hate the absence of Kremlings [2016-04-09 02:43:45] mario kart is one of the few examples inside mario where the series keeps improving with every new installment imo [2016-04-09 02:43:51] those people are trolls [2016-04-09 02:43:52] like, there's a difference between a game that's poorly put together and a game that's fundamentally bad [2016-04-09 02:43:55] yes, and i made a point earlier that that was a god-awful argument [2016-04-09 02:43:56] except mario kart wii that had some weird decisions [2016-04-09 02:43:59] the games themselves are solid [2016-04-09 02:44:01] dkc is perfectly fine [2016-04-09 02:44:10] tropical freeze and dkcr are amazing games [2016-04-09 02:44:12] yeah uniju you worded it better [2016-04-09 02:44:23] dkcr and dkcr2 are not a bad direction people who say so have no taste [2016-04-09 02:44:25] the series direction is great recently [2016-04-09 02:44:29] if people feel that strongly about it they can write them in anyway [2016-04-09 02:44:39] we shouldn't add them just because people are salty that kremlings aren't in it [2016-04-09 02:44:41] 12i'm against dkc [2016-04-09 02:44:46] <_2257> 7you know *i* hate the absence of kremlings but i dont think it actually makes the games bad [2016-04-09 02:44:53] 12dkcr and tf are really pretty well liked [2016-04-09 02:44:57] 4any other suggestions [2016-04-09 02:44:58] because it doesnt [2016-04-09 02:45:07] retro did a really good job [2016-04-09 02:45:09] 12i thought both were great even though i miss the kremlings [2016-04-09 02:45:14] i can't think of anything else [2016-04-09 02:45:16] 9,1there are hardcore DKC players who won't touch them because Kremlings aren't present [2016-04-09 02:45:25] well, to be fair, it's worst *direction* of the series [2016-04-09 02:45:26] those people live sad existences [2016-04-09 02:45:30] that's too bad for them then [2016-04-09 02:45:31] [08:44:26] mcd if people feel that strongly about it they can write them in anyway [2016-04-09 02:45:31] not *worst modern games* of the series [2016-04-09 02:45:32] but that doesn't affect the quality of the games [2016-04-09 02:45:36] well those people can enjoy glitches 64 [2016-04-09 02:45:41] they're missing out on good games [2016-04-09 02:45:50] which people who don't cut themselves out agree is fantastic [2016-04-09 02:45:52] [08:45:13] Chiaki_Nanami there are hardcore DKC players who won't touch them because Kremlings aren't present [2016-04-09 02:45:54] i don't have any other sugegstions [2016-04-09 02:46:06] 4ok so let's focus on the nominees we have now and figure out a proper wording [2016-04-09 02:46:09] i feel like if the only thing thats left to discuss is this dkc thing we can probably move on [2016-04-09 02:46:09] 4*Gutting of Mario Vs donkey kong series *Paper Mario's modern direction *Amiibo-centric/focused games *Mario Party's modern direction *Mario Tennis *New Super Mario Bros. series *Mario 3D games *Warioware *Yoshi (series) [2016-04-09 02:46:10] yeah [2016-04-09 02:46:11] i dont either [2016-04-09 02:46:12] this is like the people who hate the new m&l games because fawful isn't in it [2016-04-09 02:46:21] tbh the direction donkey kong went into after rare was bad imo [2016-04-09 02:46:37] 4do we need to include "modern direction" [2016-04-09 02:46:42] 4or is that already implied [2016-04-09 02:46:43] -->| NSY (Mibbit@5.80.ns.zq) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:46:50] use series names for everything except mario 3D games and Amiibo games imo [2016-04-09 02:46:51] i feel some might need further explanation [2016-04-09 02:46:52] 12would it be ok if we just cut of the "gutting of"/"modern direction" [2016-04-09 02:46:52] i.e. warioware [2016-04-09 02:46:53] and no it's implied i think [2016-04-09 02:46:54] but idk it probably doesnt qualify [2016-04-09 02:46:59] is it? [2016-04-09 02:47:00] 9,1gutting [2016-04-09 02:47:01] does warioware actually need more explanation [2016-04-09 02:47:02] maybe just say "Paper Mario losing classic RPG style gameplay" [2016-04-09 02:47:08] 9,1hang on, looking up what gutting means [2016-04-09 02:47:09] hey [2016-04-09 02:47:10] what even is 'gutting' [2016-04-09 02:47:10] Just having "Paper Mario" on there seems weird [2016-04-09 02:47:17] i wouldn't have known it was talking about game and wario unless i was at the meeting [2016-04-09 02:47:18] per turb on naming [2016-04-09 02:47:19] well the title is "worst direction of series" [2016-04-09 02:47:20] gutting is a great term [2016-04-09 02:47:21] "Paper Mario treating gamers like idiots" [2016-04-09 02:47:30] i feel like people should be able to connect the dots there [2016-04-09 02:47:35] taking all the innards out [2016-04-09 02:47:39] "Paper Mario's Plot" [2016-04-09 02:47:43] "paper mario trolling its fans" [2016-04-09 02:47:47] 12i think it's fine if we just list the series name other than in the amiibo one, myself [2016-04-09 02:47:49] if they cant look at the award title and make logical conclusions then idk [2016-04-09 02:47:50] also the word "series" is within parantheses on Yoshi but not the others [2016-04-09 02:47:57] ltq it'll get changed later [2016-04-09 02:48:06] 4that's what we're figuring out now [2016-04-09 02:48:15] 4and I agree with turb [2016-04-09 02:48:22] how about Current Paper Mario? [2016-04-09 02:48:22] 9,1hang on I'm still trying to figure out what the fuck 'gutting' means [2016-04-09 02:48:34] removing the innards [2016-04-09 02:48:39] 9,1innards [2016-04-09 02:48:43] <_2257> 7guts [2016-04-09 02:48:45] <_2257> 7organs [2016-04-09 02:48:47] 9,1okay [2016-04-09 02:48:48] <_2257> 7its a metaphor [2016-04-09 02:48:51] 9,1thanks [2016-04-09 02:48:51] it basically means removing the stuff that made the series good [2016-04-09 02:48:54] and leaving a corpse [2016-04-09 02:48:56] 9,1remove it [2016-04-09 02:49:07] yeah i didnt have any better way to word it at the time [2016-04-09 02:49:15] 9,1If people like /me/ can't understand it, remove it [2016-04-09 02:49:16] now that i think about it that's not a great metaphor since when you gut an animal youre taking out the less desirable parts [2016-04-09 02:49:17] gutting was the first thing that came to mind [2016-04-09 02:49:25] 9,1I'm essentially fluent in the language but I didn't know that [2016-04-09 02:49:26] 4pidgey I think it's more of a language barrier [2016-04-09 02:49:29] What if we did series name followed by a parentheses of the particular game considered to be the start or most infamous part of of the direction AKA Paper Mario (Sticker Star) [2016-04-09 02:49:31] 4it's a very common phrase in english [2016-04-09 02:49:32] anton [2016-04-09 02:49:37] current topic? [2016-04-09 02:49:38] 4either way I want it removed too so lol [2016-04-09 02:49:39] gutting is a common term here, yes [2016-04-09 02:49:48] 9,1I've never heard it ever lol [2016-04-09 02:49:54] Ex: *Paper Mario series (Sticker Star) [2016-04-09 02:49:57] i mean "worst direction of series" implies that they did something to fuck up the direction [2016-04-09 02:50:00] Maybe "Extreme Loss of quality in Mario vs. Donkey Kong games" [2016-04-09 02:50:01] 4NSY: we're working on refining the nominees for Worst Direction of Series [2016-04-09 02:50:03] and yeah thats why i said in my post when i made it that itll need to be changed [2016-04-09 02:50:04] 4I'm about to post a list again [2016-04-09 02:50:11] 9,1why not just [2016-04-09 02:50:12] okay [2016-04-09 02:50:15] it really is a common phrase [2016-04-09 02:50:21] most people can figure out that pm/ttyd are not what's being referenced there [2016-04-09 02:50:21] 9,1cut everything extraneous [2016-04-09 02:50:24] it's sticker star and color splash [2016-04-09 02:50:26] 9,1and just say 'paper mario' [2016-04-09 02:50:28] the wording isn't great but "a swedish person doesnt understand this english phrase" isn't the reason [2016-04-09 02:50:29] bastardization of the mvdk series [2016-04-09 02:50:50] 9,1no, just say the series name [2016-04-09 02:50:52] 9,1nothing else [2016-04-09 02:50:59] that wouldn't work for amiibo games, mario 3d games, but if leaving them as they are then per pi [2016-04-09 02:51:00] i think the parentheses name is like the only compromise i would be willing to come to but i honestly dont think we need it [2016-04-09 02:51:01] is hotel mario a bad directi- *shot* [2016-04-09 02:51:02] 4*Mario vs Donkey Kong (series) *Paper Mario *amiibo-centric/focused games *Mario Party *Mario Tennis *New Super Mario Bros. (series) *Mario 3D games *Warioware *Yoshi (series) [2016-04-09 02:51:10] 12yes that [2016-04-09 02:51:13] go with that [2016-04-09 02:51:14] y [2016-04-09 02:51:16] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o NSY by ChanServ [2016-04-09 02:51:19] 4series in () is to indicate that it's the series and not the individual game by the same name [2016-04-09 02:51:31] 4does warioware need that too, idk [2016-04-09 02:51:32] y [2016-04-09 02:51:33] wouldn't paper mario need it too, then [2016-04-09 02:51:38] you could put that on mario party, mario tennis and paper mario [2016-04-09 02:51:39] yes [2016-04-09 02:51:41] 12wouldn't ALL of those need it [2016-04-09 02:51:44] 9,1and mario party [2016-04-09 02:51:47] 12except 3d and amiibo [2016-04-09 02:51:48] warioware has no game by the title of just "warioware" [2016-04-09 02:51:50] we could just remove it tbj [2016-04-09 02:51:51] but you can add it if you want [2016-04-09 02:51:51] <_2257> 7wario ware never had agame just called wario ware iirc [2016-04-09 02:51:53] 9,1it's a series we are talking about [2016-04-09 02:51:54] *tbh [2016-04-09 02:51:55] 4ok [2016-04-09 02:51:57] 9,1remove (series) [2016-04-09 02:52:06] 12either just add series to all or none [2016-04-09 02:52:09] the first one is called WarioWare Inc. i guess [2016-04-09 02:52:09] 12i think i prefer none [2016-04-09 02:52:10] per turb [2016-04-09 02:52:16] "worst direction of series" already dentoes we're talking about the series itself [2016-04-09 02:52:20] <_2257> 7doesnt the award name make it obvious theyre series....es though [2016-04-09 02:52:22] 12series is literally in the award title [2016-04-09 02:52:25] the first one is warioware mega microgames [2016-04-09 02:52:26] yeah what 22 said [2016-04-09 02:52:34] 4*Mario vs Donkey Kong *Paper Mario *amiibo-centric/focused games *Mario Party *Mario Tennis *New Super Mario Bros. *Mario 3D games *Warioware *Yoshi [2016-04-09 02:52:38] go with that [2016-04-09 02:52:39] 12yes [2016-04-09 02:52:47] that's good [2016-04-09 02:52:47] <_2257> 7good [2016-04-09 02:52:51] aaaaaa sorry sorry [2016-04-09 02:52:51] sure [2016-04-09 02:52:52] is good [2016-04-09 02:52:53] y [2016-04-09 02:52:54] that's fine [2016-04-09 02:52:54] dinner occupied my time [2016-04-09 02:52:57] hi [2016-04-09 02:52:58] that's good with m [2016-04-09 02:52:59] me* [2016-04-09 02:53:01] the thing is we had a discussion like this for that trans issues nominee on whatever award number it is [2016-04-09 02:53:09] and we concluded we need the voters to make decisions on their own [2016-04-09 02:53:15] by looking at the title and context clues [2016-04-09 02:53:18] i believe in them [2016-04-09 02:53:20] anyhw, that looks good to me [2016-04-09 02:53:25] were rewording that though at least arent we [2016-04-09 02:53:31] but turb ralph told us they have the attention spans of squirrels [2016-04-09 02:53:32] rewording what [2016-04-09 02:53:38] because it currently sounds like were advocating transphobia [2016-04-09 02:53:38] if you mean the trans issues thing it was already reworded [2016-04-09 02:53:44] ok [2016-04-09 02:53:44] i agree with the list [2016-04-09 02:53:53] i remembered we talked about it [2016-04-09 02:53:59] <_2257> 7tbh i'm sure some of the voters will fuck up no matter what we say [2016-04-09 02:54:04] yeah that [2016-04-09 02:54:05] tbh id be surprised if the voters couldnt be arsed to figure shit out [2016-04-09 02:54:12] but who cares about them honestly [2016-04-09 02:54:12] i wouldnt be surprised [2016-04-09 02:54:15] i mean [2016-04-09 02:54:18] <_2257> 7theres like hundreds of them each time [2016-04-09 02:54:20] these are the same peopel who don't read the dossier and just click buttons [2016-04-09 02:54:23] i remember talking about it [2016-04-09 02:54:35] and write in stuff that's already on the award [2016-04-09 02:54:48] 4next up then [2016-04-09 02:55:02] 4Worst Mario Part Minigame [2016-04-09 02:55:04] WarioWare has both W [2016-04-09 02:55:04] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36574.0 [2016-04-09 02:55:08] s capitalized [2016-04-09 02:55:12] 4if you /still/ haven't voted you have 30 seconds to do so [2016-04-09 02:55:15] 4and ok [2016-04-09 02:55:46] i barely play mario party [2016-04-09 02:55:52] 9,1i voted [2016-04-09 02:55:54] <_2257> 7how do things end up with zero votes [2016-04-09 02:55:57] just vote for what you recognize for the sake of it [2016-04-09 02:55:58] 4it looks like there's a lot with 2-3 votes [2016-04-09 02:55:59] i did that [2016-04-09 02:56:00] <_2257> 7do people not vote for their own nominees [2016-04-09 02:56:12] i managed to fill out like 15 choices [2016-04-09 02:56:18] 12i wasn;t able to have to time to vote [2016-04-09 02:56:26] 4there's 12 with 4+ votes [2016-04-09 02:56:26] -->| Nabber__ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:56:30] okay maybe i should just quit since my internet clearly hates me [2016-04-09 02:56:33] <_2257> 7i just voted for everythnig with control stick spinning [2016-04-09 02:56:41] i wonder if theres anyone who has memorized every single mario party minigame [2016-04-09 02:56:49] 4 5 more with 3+ [2016-04-09 02:56:50] probably 3d player [2016-04-09 02:56:52] there probably is [2016-04-09 02:56:56] <_2257> 7and also bash n cash because it totally fucks over the single player for no reason whatsoever?? [2016-04-09 02:57:00] 4we can fit in everything at 3+ [2016-04-09 02:57:02] <_2257> 7i always thought that was moronic [2016-04-09 02:57:05] 4is there anyone else still currently voting [2016-04-09 02:57:18] the only one i recognize by name that ive disliked is tug o war [2016-04-09 02:57:23] mario party minigame? [2016-04-09 02:57:25] so thats the only one i voted for [2016-04-09 02:57:26] if so, i voted [2016-04-09 02:57:32] 12does flip the chimp have 3+ votes [2016-04-09 02:57:33] just voted [2016-04-09 02:57:36] yes [2016-04-09 02:57:37] 9,1i've memorised every mp minigame up until 7 [2016-04-09 02:57:39] it has 8 [2016-04-09 02:57:40] 12good [2016-04-09 02:57:42] 12GOOD [2016-04-09 02:57:51] what the fuck pi srsly [2016-04-09 02:57:54] 9,1yes [2016-04-09 02:57:55] why [2016-04-09 02:57:58] i can't remember what that minigame was but i do remember it was the absolute worst [2016-04-09 02:57:59] i did not vote [2016-04-09 02:57:59] ever [2016-04-09 02:58:02] 9,1because mario party is a great series [2016-04-09 02:58:04] 4voting is locked [2016-04-09 02:58:07] 9,1up until 8 [2016-04-09 02:58:09] *****Was [2016-04-09 02:58:12] 4whoever didn't vote, you don't have a say, sucks [2016-04-09 02:58:13] i have almost no experience with the entire series so i couldn't make a fair decision, soz [2016-04-09 02:58:15] flip the chimp is shit [2016-04-09 02:58:23] |<-- Nabber_ has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Read error: Operation timed out) [2016-04-09 02:58:29] 4 22 can you ~please~ grab the top 15-18 [2016-04-09 02:58:34] <_2257> 7oh [2016-04-09 02:58:35] 8 is still good it was when hudson dropped it turned to the worst [2016-04-09 02:58:37] <_2257> 7sorry, was i late [2016-04-09 02:58:42] 4there should be 15 voters [2016-04-09 02:59:15] -->| Nabber_ (Nabber@fgkp-98-194-78-07.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 02:59:18] <_2257> 71. Tug o' War [2016-04-09 02:59:19] i rather enjoyed areas of 8 [2016-04-09 02:59:20] <_2257> 7 9 (6.6%) [2016-04-09 02:59:21] okay fuck it i don't want to disrupt this anymore [2016-04-09 02:59:22] <_2257> 72. Bash n' Cash [2016-04-09 02:59:23] i guess i'll leave now [2016-04-09 02:59:25] <_2257> 7 8 (5.8%) [2016-04-09 02:59:27] <_2257> 72. Flip the Chimp [2016-04-09 02:59:29] <_2257> 7 8 (5.8%) [2016-04-09 02:59:29] |<-- Nabber_ has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Read error: Connection reset by peer) [2016-04-09 02:59:30] bye [2016-04-09 02:59:31] <_2257> 74. Crane Game [2016-04-09 02:59:31] 8 had good boards [2016-04-09 02:59:33] <_2257> 7 7 (5.1%) [2016-04-09 02:59:35] <_2257> 75. Day at the Races [2016-04-09 02:59:37] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 02:59:39] <_2257> 75. Bowser's Big Blast [2016-04-09 02:59:41] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 02:59:43] <_2257> 75. MPIQ [2016-04-09 02:59:45] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 02:59:46] 8 wasn't ba [2016-04-09 02:59:47] <_2257> 78. The Beat Goes On [2016-04-09 02:59:49] *bad [2016-04-09 02:59:49] <_2257> 7 5 (3.6%) [2016-04-09 02:59:49] wtf day at the races was great ;-; [2016-04-09 02:59:51] <_2257> 78. Game Guy Room [2016-04-09 02:59:51] the koopa town one = best board in mp [2016-04-09 02:59:52] <_2257> 7 5 (3.6%) [2016-04-09 02:59:55] <_2257> 710. Pipe Maze [2016-04-09 02:59:56] <_2257> 7 4 (2.9%) [2016-04-09 02:59:59] <_2257> 710. Right Oar Left [2016-04-09 02:59:59] per packy [2016-04-09 03:00:00] it wasn't the best but it's okay [2016-04-09 03:00:01] <_2257> 7 4 (2.9%) [2016-04-09 03:00:03] <_2257> 710. Hot Rope Jump [2016-04-09 03:00:04] omg so was pipe maze [2016-04-09 03:00:05] <_2257> 7 4 (2.9%) [2016-04-09 03:00:07] <_2257> 710. Cheep Cheep Chance [2016-04-09 03:00:09] <_2257> 7 4 (2.9%) [2016-04-09 03:00:11] <_2257> 714. Piranha's Pursuit [2016-04-09 03:00:13] <_2257> 7 3 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 03:00:15] <_2257> 714. Skateboard Scamper [2016-04-09 03:00:17] <_2257> 7 3 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 03:00:19] <_2257> 714. Cast Aways [2016-04-09 03:00:21] <_2257> 7 3 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 03:00:23] <_2257> 714. Bob-omb Combo [2016-04-09 03:00:25] <_2257> 7 3 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 03:00:27] <_2257> 714. Cheep Cheep Check [2016-04-09 03:00:28] 9,1the majority of these are from 1-3 [2016-04-09 03:00:29] <_2257> 7 3 (2.2%) [2016-04-09 03:00:30] that mario party 1-3 slaughter [2016-04-09 03:00:31] <_2257> 7really, you liked pipe maz? [2016-04-09 03:00:34] <_2257> 7it was like basically just luck wasnt it [2016-04-09 03:00:43] i remember game guy from mp3 [2016-04-09 03:00:46] 9,1which is because those are the games everyone played [2016-04-09 03:00:49] wait [2016-04-09 03:00:49] that game was kinda meh [2016-04-09 03:00:51] unless you were theh one controlling it yeah [2016-04-09 03:00:51] oh shit nvm [2016-04-09 03:00:58] I had to look it up [2016-04-09 03:00:58] if you could figure out spider puzzles in .000001 seconds it wasnt luck [2016-04-09 03:00:59] those three are considered the three good games as well [2016-04-09 03:01:02] it's not the pipe maze I was thinking of lol [2016-04-09 03:01:18] I was thinking of that pipe maze minigame from I think MP7 [2016-04-09 03:01:24] which is luck anyways but it's pretty fun [2016-04-09 03:01:31] <_2257> 7is it actually called pipe maze? [2016-04-09 03:01:36] think so [2016-04-09 03:01:39] <_2257> 7oh [2016-04-09 03:01:41] oh [2016-04-09 03:01:42] mp7 [2016-04-09 03:01:44] idk [2016-04-09 03:01:51] 4wow is that exactly 18 [2016-04-09 03:01:52] 4we did it [2016-04-09 03:01:53] yeah idk what the one in MP7 is called [2016-04-09 03:01:53] in that case probably not [2016-04-09 03:01:54] o3o [2016-04-09 03:02:07] i had to look up the one from the original n64 version and i didnt see an (MP7) page [2016-04-09 03:02:09] but w/e [2016-04-09 03:02:14] <_2257> 7ok [2016-04-09 03:02:17] 9,1that minigame was graet [2016-04-09 03:02:19] 9,1*great [2016-04-09 03:02:25] 9,1warp pipe dreams [2016-04-09 03:02:49] |<-- Nabber__ has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Ping timeout: 265 seconds) [2016-04-09 03:02:52] best minigame is still the motorcycle gp from mp8 [2016-04-09 03:02:56] warp pipe dreams was so fun [2016-04-09 03:03:05] thats like what mario kart couldve been in terms of characters [2016-04-09 03:03:14] 4so that leaves us with: [2016-04-09 03:03:21] my favourite in the series is still camera shy [2016-04-09 03:03:21] 4*Edo's thing for Location [2016-04-09 03:03:23] idk it was fun [2016-04-09 03:03:26] 4*5th new award idea [2016-04-09 03:03:39] 4oh wait no [2016-04-09 03:03:40] 4 2d level [2016-04-09 03:03:46] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36572.0 [2016-04-09 03:03:48] the one with 3v1 where you had to look the other direction in mp2 was gr8 as well [2016-04-09 03:03:49] 4this one will be fun [2016-04-09 03:03:53] 4I'm creating the poll right now [2016-04-09 03:03:59] 4you all have like 10 minutes to fill it out [2016-04-09 03:04:06] 4if you don't do it, you don't get a vote [2016-04-09 03:04:07] poll hype\ [2016-04-09 03:04:14] 4unless you shit your pants on the forum afterwards but, details [2016-04-09 03:04:34] 4if you have any more suggestions for nominees [2016-04-09 03:04:37] 4you had a week to do it [2016-04-09 03:04:39] 4so, sucks [2016-04-09 03:04:49] 4poll is up [2016-04-09 03:05:01] 4my clock reads 9:04 now, I'll be generous and say 9:15 [2016-04-09 03:05:09] 4is when it will close [2016-04-09 03:05:25] 4I know you guys can do it [2016-04-09 03:05:27] so did anyone find out which lost levels level had the bullshit spring [2016-04-09 03:05:28] 4you've trained hard for this [2016-04-09 03:05:35] 4click options at the speed of light [2016-04-09 03:05:45] 4no one told me any specific lost levels so none were added [2016-04-09 03:05:49] 4I can't add an entire thing in bulk [2016-04-09 03:05:52] #ivoted [2016-04-09 03:05:54] i was the first what do i win [2016-04-09 03:05:55] ok [2016-04-09 03:05:55] done [2016-04-09 03:05:55] i voted [2016-04-09 03:05:57] me too [2016-04-09 03:06:03] anton i can't access the poll : - ( [2016-04-09 03:06:04] i was 3rd [2016-04-09 03:06:05] forever alone [2016-04-09 03:06:13] 9,1#ivoted [2016-04-09 03:06:21] shit [2016-04-09 03:06:26] added two more suggests [2016-04-09 03:06:29] too late [2016-04-09 03:06:36] wow endless world of yoshis is unpopular lol [2016-04-09 03:06:38] am i seriosuly the only one who voted doodle woods [2016-04-09 03:06:40] what the fuck you guys [2016-04-09 03:06:55] all levels in wl4 are great imo [2016-04-09 03:06:59] false [2016-04-09 03:07:02] no exceptions [2016-04-09 03:07:06] topaz passage [2016-04-09 03:07:18] voted [2016-04-09 03:07:23] also uh [2016-04-09 03:07:28] the big board [2016-04-09 03:07:37] i dont remember the very long cave for some reason [2016-04-09 03:07:55] 4if you don't remember any levels, you have [2016-04-09 03:07:56] 4 8 minutes [2016-04-09 03:07:57] <_2257> 7glitchy it was 7-3 if we're thinking of the same thing [2016-04-09 03:08:00] 4to look it up on the wiki [2016-04-09 03:08:03] OH GOD THATS 6-5 [2016-04-09 03:08:09] fuck i shouldve voted for it [2016-04-09 03:08:10] yep [2016-04-09 03:08:13] 4 7 minutes [2016-04-09 03:08:14] that fucking cave [2016-04-09 03:08:16] 4you can change your vote [2016-04-09 03:08:17] oh well itll get in anyways [2016-04-09 03:08:21] okay [2016-04-09 03:08:28] it was the only one that i couldn't 100 point until next year of the regular levels [2016-04-09 03:08:31] *last year [2016-04-09 03:08:33] you guys should have been prepared for this just by virtue of having played mario games before [2016-04-09 03:08:34] i dont have that option anton [2016-04-09 03:08:35] *two years ago [2016-04-09 03:08:51] i'm thinking of this spring that took you back to the first level [2016-04-09 03:08:51] oh wait i reloaded its there now [2016-04-09 03:08:53] sorry [2016-04-09 03:08:58] #ivoted [2016-04-09 03:09:04] then again the level polls both got nothing but dkc and wl4 so i cant blame you for not being familar with this shit [2016-04-09 03:09:07] whatd i miss [2016-04-09 03:09:07] <_2257> 7oh [2016-04-09 03:09:09] voted [2016-04-09 03:09:10] world 4-2 from smb2 is there twice [2016-04-09 03:09:11] <_2257> 7wasnt it like 3-1 [2016-04-09 03:09:14] tb http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36572.0 [2016-04-09 03:09:20] though i'm not sure if I ever made it as far as world 7 [2016-04-09 03:09:26] it might have been 3-1 [2016-04-09 03:09:32] oh................................. [2016-04-09 03:09:39] <_2257> 7yeah no the bullshit spring in 7-3 is [2016-04-09 03:09:46] <_2257> 7it bounces you up way high in the air [2016-04-09 03:09:48] <_2257> 7off the screen [2016-04-09 03:10:01] <_2257> 7so you have to try and land while having no idea where you actually are [2016-04-09 03:10:03] 8 castle [2016-04-09 03:10:07] is bowsers castle right [2016-04-09 03:10:08] 4NSY: I removed the one with the least votes [2016-04-09 03:10:09] in smb3 [2016-04-09 03:10:10] 4thx [2016-04-09 03:10:11] <_2257> 7and the ground is just a few tiny platforms [2016-04-09 03:10:16] <_2257> 7above a bottomless pit [2016-04-09 03:10:21] everything uniju suggested isnt that bad tbh so i abstained voting from these and only voted for levels i consider worse [2016-04-09 03:10:24] than those [2016-04-09 03:10:29] shit [2016-04-09 03:10:30] 12well i remember none of these and don't have the time or good internet to look them up in 5 minutes [2016-04-09 03:10:33] are we acting on these right away [2016-04-09 03:10:34] 12good luck! [2016-04-09 03:10:37] i need to look up these levels again [2016-04-09 03:10:54] pls [2016-04-09 03:11:09] 12you don't have dial-up [2016-04-09 03:11:12] 12you can do it tb [2016-04-09 03:11:13] if it helps [2016-04-09 03:11:15] 12i have faith in you [2016-04-09 03:11:21] which 4-2 smb2 do i vote for [2016-04-09 03:11:22] just vote for all of my suggestions [2016-04-09 03:11:23] the very long cave is the one from the final world of yoshi's island that autoscrolls underground [2016-04-09 03:11:26] it's shit [2016-04-09 03:11:27] also the special levels in smw werent that bad tbh [2016-04-09 03:11:28] refresh tb [2016-04-09 03:11:31] i havent finished yoshis island [2016-04-09 03:11:32] they were challenging [2016-04-09 03:11:40] theres nothing new [2016-04-09 03:11:44] finish it tb [2016-04-09 03:11:46] finish it [2016-04-09 03:11:52] im TRTYING but i just lost all my votes from refreshing [2016-04-09 03:12:07] <_2257> 7tubular ws annoying as fuck [2016-04-09 03:12:14] <_2257> 7the others were all ok [2016-04-09 03:12:16] no one answered me on 8-castle smb3 being bowsers castle [2016-04-09 03:12:19] or the fortress [2016-04-09 03:12:20] <_2257> 7but tubular was just bullshit [2016-04-09 03:12:25] yeah i remember tubular [2016-04-09 03:12:38] i dont think its badly designed its just well annoying yeah [2016-04-09 03:12:54] oh tubular [2016-04-09 03:12:55] i remember this [2016-04-09 03:12:59] endless world of yoshis on the other hand for example is just random bullshit no skill involved [2016-04-09 03:13:06] i dont remember tubular because i never got that far [2016-04-09 03:13:08] rip [2016-04-09 03:13:09] the latter parts were good [2016-04-09 03:13:10] i ended up beating it without the p balloon [2016-04-09 03:13:11] but [2016-04-09 03:13:13] that spike drop path [2016-04-09 03:13:19] maybe if you didn't have to go down it four times [2016-04-09 03:13:25] thats true blocky but fuck the castle [2016-04-09 03:13:30] exactly [2016-04-09 03:13:31] yeah the fucking spike drop [2016-04-09 03:13:45] like if it was one and done that would just be challenging [2016-04-09 03:13:46] oh [2016-04-09 03:13:48] but it's way too much [2016-04-09 03:13:54] the end is nice in that it basically goes through the tutorial level again [2016-04-09 03:13:54] ok i might remember tubular being a fuck [2016-04-09 03:14:24] but overall its just a poorly designed level in an otherwise great game [2016-04-09 03:14:26] i am now going to pull up that smb3 emulator [2016-04-09 03:14:33] <_2257> 7the spike drop isnt so bad once you realise the trick [2016-04-09 03:14:45] <_2257> 7the exact center is clear all the way down [2016-04-09 03:15:02] it takes you too long to figure out though [2016-04-09 03:15:21] also theres not enough votes for minecart madness imo [2016-04-09 03:15:36] <_2257> 7minecart madness was less anoying than mine cart carnage [2016-04-09 03:15:40] 4ok plz finish up if you haven't [2016-04-09 03:15:40] holy shit [2016-04-09 03:15:42] the minecart is complete bogus [2016-04-09 03:15:43] what is 3-3 smb3 [2016-04-09 03:15:50] my emulator is having a stroke when i play this [2016-04-09 03:15:50] <_2257> 7big bertha [2016-04-09 03:16:02] 4I'll let tb finish because I'm a good friend [2016-04-09 03:16:03] tbf 2257 i submitted that because i think it stands for dkc minecart controls in general [2016-04-09 03:16:03] a flippy thing keeps generating on top of me [2016-04-09 03:16:04] 9,1the big fish [2016-04-09 03:16:07] i keep getting pushed back [2016-04-09 03:16:14] i dont think thats supposed to happen [2016-04-09 03:16:22] 9,1tb it's the big fish [2016-04-09 03:16:23] 9,1that eats you [2016-04-09 03:16:26] <_2257> 7yeah but it was so much more annoying in carnage because you couldnt get out of the minecart at all [2016-04-09 03:16:28] i know i just played it [2016-04-09 03:16:30] <_2257> 7it was just the whole level [2016-04-09 03:16:32] im saying my emulator is doing weird shit [2016-04-09 03:16:56] minecart madness at least has pretty sweet music [2016-04-09 03:17:04] i guess i could agree but more people will remember this one, so ill probably reach my goal of the mnecart getting defiled this way [2016-04-09 03:17:21] 3-5 isnt bad [2016-04-09 03:17:55] god DAMN [2016-04-09 03:17:58] what code is causing this [2016-04-09 03:18:54] <_2257> 7remember when the dkcr devs thought everyone loved the minecart and included it like 15 times [2016-04-09 03:19:02] 9,1i love it [2016-04-09 03:19:08] <_2257> 7but with less functional controls than it had on the snes [2016-04-09 03:19:10] <_2257> 7i do [2016-04-09 03:19:13] yeah but that minecart actually responds [2016-04-09 03:19:18] lol [2016-04-09 03:19:20] LOL [2016-04-09 03:19:21] 9,1what [2016-04-09 03:19:22] L O L [2016-04-09 03:19:27] but ohkos [2016-04-09 03:19:27] 9,1you can duck [2016-04-09 03:19:28] hey i cant vote down 7-8 [2016-04-09 03:19:33] this one has the hidden hammer suit room [2016-04-09 03:19:33] <_2257> 7yeah no the minecart in dkcr is garbage [2016-04-09 03:19:38] 9,1stop [2016-04-09 03:19:40] <_2257> 7sorry for your loss [2016-04-09 03:19:41] 4you have a max vote of 15 selections [2016-04-09 03:19:46] i voted 4 [2016-04-09 03:19:47] 4if that's what you mean [2016-04-09 03:19:48] im in [2016-04-09 03:19:52] no i mean [2016-04-09 03:19:55] i dont want to vote down 7-8 [2016-04-09 03:19:56] okay arguably ive only played a level with the mincart once and i had no problems there so [2016-04-09 03:19:59] 4oh [2016-04-09 03:20:03] thanks anton you saved me [2016-04-09 03:20:09] while minecart madness took me way too many times [2016-04-09 03:20:15] <_2257> 7"i havent played the game but i have strong opinions" ~ freakworld [2016-04-09 03:20:15] *tries [2016-04-09 03:20:18] 4tb did it [2016-04-09 03:20:21] 4poll is locked [2016-04-09 03:20:34] 4 22 plz giv top 15-18 results [2016-04-09 03:20:39] 4record speed voting [2016-04-09 03:20:52] yeah 2257 im copying francis from spm [2016-04-09 03:20:54] <_2257> 71. The Very Long Cave (YI) [2016-04-09 03:20:56] <_2257> 7 13 (9.6%) [2016-04-09 03:20:59] <_2257> 72. Tubular (SMW) [2016-04-09 03:21:01] <_2257> 7 11 (8.1%) [2016-04-09 03:21:03] <_2257> 73. World 8-3 (SMB) [2016-04-09 03:21:05] <_2257> 7 9 (6.7%) [2016-04-09 03:21:07] <_2257> 73. 6-Secret (YI) [2016-04-09 03:21:09] <_2257> 7 9 (6.7%) [2016-04-09 03:21:11] <_2257> 75. World 9-7 (NSMBW) [2016-04-09 03:21:13] <_2257> 7 8 (5.9%) [2016-04-09 03:21:14] yea top 3 [2016-04-09 03:21:15] <_2257> 76. Lakitu's Wall (YI) [2016-04-09 03:21:17] <_2257> 7 7 (5.2%) [2016-04-09 03:21:19] <_2257> 76. Minecart Madness (DKC) [2016-04-09 03:21:21] <_2257> 7 7 (5.2%) [2016-04-09 03:21:24] <_2257> 78. World 8-Castle (SMB3) [2016-04-09 03:21:26] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 03:21:28] <_2257> 78. Stampede Sprint (DKC3) [2016-04-09 03:21:30] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 03:21:32] <_2257> 78. World 8-1 (SMB) [2016-04-09 03:21:34] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 03:21:36] <_2257> 78. World 4-2 (SMB2) [2016-04-09 03:21:37] i hope at least big board makes it up there [2016-04-09 03:21:38] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 03:21:40] <_2257> 78. World 7-8 SMB3 [2016-04-09 03:21:42] <_2257> 7 6 (4.4%) [2016-04-09 03:21:44] <_2257> 713. The Big Board (WL4) [2016-04-09 03:21:47] <_2257> 7 5 (3.7%) [2016-04-09 03:21:49] <_2257> 714. World 9-8 (NSMBU) [2016-04-09 03:21:49] you did it [2016-04-09 03:21:50] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:21:53] <_2257> 714. Doodle Woods (WL4) [2016-04-09 03:21:55] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:21:56] <_2257> 714. World 4-4 SMB [2016-04-09 03:21:59] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:22:01] <_2257> 714. World 7-4 SMB [2016-04-09 03:22:03] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:22:05] <_2257> 714. World 3-5 SMB3 [2016-04-09 03:22:05] 9,14-4 was gr8 [2016-04-09 03:22:07] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:22:08] 9,1:( [2016-04-09 03:22:09] <_2257> 714. World 6-4 SMB3 [2016-04-09 03:22:12] <_2257> 7 4 (3%) [2016-04-09 03:22:14] <_2257> 7world 8-3 is like one of the only smb levels i liked [2016-04-09 03:22:16] <_2257> 7what was bad abotu it [2016-04-09 03:22:18] is 4-4 the multipath one [2016-04-09 03:22:19] does that mean all of the wl4 levels i suggested besides pinball zone got in [2016-04-09 03:22:21] feelsgoodman [2016-04-09 03:22:26] the hammer bros. [2016-04-09 03:22:27] all of them [2016-04-09 03:22:29] 4hold on [2016-04-09 03:22:31] 4is this too many [2016-04-09 03:22:34] 4final showdown [2016-04-09 03:22:35] i shouldve suggestedfiery cavern [2016-04-09 03:22:37] maybe next time [2016-04-09 03:22:37] hammer bros [2016-04-09 03:22:39] <_2257> 7yeah theresa 6 way tie [2016-04-09 03:22:40] 19 i think [2016-04-09 03:22:40] <_2257> 7for last [2016-04-09 03:22:41] and no easy way to get past them [2016-04-09 03:22:44] bump doodle woods in [2016-04-09 03:22:45] 8-3 was that one with the annoying hammer bros [2016-04-09 03:22:46] <_2257> 7or 14th ayway [2016-04-09 03:22:47] unless you just so happen to still somehow have a fire flower [2016-04-09 03:22:47] fuck that level [2016-04-09 03:23:01] the hammers in smb are op [2016-04-09 03:23:07] world 8 is overall terrible tbh [2016-04-09 03:23:08] rip sea turtle rocks [2016-04-09 03:23:20] <_2257> 7sea turtle rocks was legitimately bad [2016-04-09 03:23:26] that level was extremely lazily designed [2016-04-09 03:23:37] 4we only need to get rid of 1 [2016-04-09 03:23:39] i liked the castle wall background but other than that [2016-04-09 03:23:53] world 8 in smb1 is nintendo trying to make the game "hard" [2016-04-09 03:23:58] get rid of one of the smb levels then [2016-04-09 03:24:13] nsy have you played smb2 japan [2016-04-09 03:24:15] 4World 9-8 (NSMBU), Doodle Woods (WL4), World 4-4 (SMB), World 7-4 (SMB), World 3-5 (SMB3), World 6-4 (SMB3) [2016-04-09 03:24:24] world 8 in smb1 was just created to fuck over speedrunners [2016-04-09 03:24:37] if you play it normally its pretty easy tbh [2016-04-09 03:24:48] you can even farm lives in 8-2 [2016-04-09 03:24:51] 4so how should we decide this [2016-04-09 03:24:52] yes [2016-04-09 03:24:59] toadbert [2016-04-09 03:25:00] 4should I reset the poll with just these options [2016-04-09 03:25:03] so i cant say i know what any of those are off the top of my head besides doodle woods [2016-04-09 03:25:05] remove 4-4 from smb1 imo [2016-04-09 03:25:07] yes [2016-04-09 03:25:09] i love voting on polls [2016-04-09 03:25:13] 4or is there already a universal consensus [2016-04-09 03:25:15] i wonder if world 8 was nintendo hard at the time [2016-04-09 03:25:16] wolrd 4-4 and 7-4 are very similar [2016-04-09 03:25:24] or they just got lazy and put the difficulty to the next game [2016-04-09 03:25:26] is it going to be a vote where the least amount of votes gets booted off [2016-04-09 03:25:27] drop 4-4 i guess [2016-04-09 03:25:30] one fo the smb levels [2016-04-09 03:25:31] drop 4-4 [2016-04-09 03:25:32] i would keep 7-4 because it repeats the shitty idea [2016-04-09 03:25:40] <_2257> 7i woudl drop 3-5 [2016-04-09 03:25:43] rather than at least introduce it [2016-04-09 03:25:45] drop 4-4 [2016-04-09 03:25:52] what did people hate baout the smb3 levels [2016-04-09 03:25:56] they didnt seem disgusting to me [2016-04-09 03:26:05] 8-castle is dumb [2016-04-09 03:26:08] <_2257> 76-4 was a load of icy platforms over the void iirc [2016-04-09 03:26:16] <_2257> 7that's annoying [2016-04-09 03:26:19] i would just say reset the poll [2016-04-09 03:26:21] yeah but theyre 2x2 from what i saw [2016-04-09 03:26:27] with only those options [2016-04-09 03:26:34] i guess go with that [2016-04-09 03:26:34] 4I'm resetting the poll [2016-04-09 03:26:39] the rest of world 8 was original and the best levels in the game but the castle was just stupid [2016-04-09 03:26:40] but if doodle woods doesnt get on this award ill cry [2016-04-09 03:26:48] me too [2016-04-09 03:26:53] so do we vote for the one to remove? [2016-04-09 03:26:58] y [2016-04-09 03:27:17] i assumed it was one with the least votes gets axed [2016-04-09 03:27:18] 4yes [2016-04-09 03:27:19] but idk [2016-04-09 03:27:21] o [2016-04-09 03:28:13] . [2016-04-09 03:28:26] i fucked up okay [2016-04-09 03:28:30] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36572.0 [2016-04-09 03:28:31] 4vote [2016-04-09 03:28:32] dont judge me fw [2016-04-09 03:28:43] im juding you [2016-04-09 03:28:49] i dont care [2016-04-09 03:28:50] voted [2016-04-09 03:28:58] if thats whats been implied to you its fine [2016-04-09 03:28:59] voted [2016-04-09 03:29:04] <_2257> 7i assumed what turb did too but the fact that you only get 1 vote clarifies thinggs [2016-04-09 03:29:10] done [2016-04-09 03:29:47] voted [2016-04-09 03:30:01] voeted [2016-04-09 03:30:31] 9,1#ivoted [2016-04-09 03:30:49] 4with the amount of voters we have available here, 4-4 is at a strong enough lead to be dropped from the nominee list [2016-04-09 03:30:58] 9,1yay [2016-04-09 03:31:03] 9,1it's one of my favourite smb1 levels [2016-04-09 03:31:08] 4voting is locked [2016-04-09 03:31:11] 9,1has always been one [2016-04-09 03:31:15] 9,1since i was like [2016-04-09 03:31:17] 9,15 [2016-04-09 03:31:24] <_2257> 7was 3-5 really that bad [2016-04-09 03:31:29] The Very Long Cave (YI), Tubular (SMW), World 8-3 (SMB), 6-Secret (YI), World 9-7 (NSMBW), Lakitu's Wall (YI), Minecart Madness (DKC), World 8-Castle (SMB3), Stampede Sprint (DKC3), World 8-1 (SMB), World 4-2 (SMB2), World 7-8 (SMB3), The Big Board (WL4), World 9-8 (NSMBU), Doodle Woods (WL4), World 7-4 (SMB), World 3-5 (SMB3), World 6-4 (SMB3) [2016-04-09 03:31:36] i dnot think so [2016-04-09 03:32:41] to be fair i voted for 3-5's removal after looking at the level again [2016-04-09 03:32:47] also im gonna go get a drink [2016-04-09 03:33:23] 4so we still need to discuss the 5th new award idea [2016-04-09 03:33:27] 4and figure out what it will be [2016-04-09 03:33:29] be careful turb [2016-04-09 03:33:37] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36603.0 [2016-04-09 03:33:51] i would vote for worst roster [2016-04-09 03:33:59] 4I want to start User awards tonight in some fashion so we will stop discussing Fail in like 10 minutes [2016-04-09 03:34:16] i have no idea which one to take tbh [2016-04-09 03:34:17] a [2016-04-09 03:34:30] worst roster is the best one honestly [2016-04-09 03:34:34] (ive read through that earlier today) [2016-04-09 03:34:41] im alive [2016-04-09 03:34:46] I would go with worst roster [2016-04-09 03:34:46] wb [2016-04-09 03:34:50] also yeah im good with worst roster tbh [2016-04-09 03:34:50] 4this ties in to http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36644.0 [2016-04-09 03:35:08] im still iffy on the idea but i think its the strongest one we have [2016-04-09 03:35:09] is it worst roster in general? [2016-04-09 03:35:12] or worst addition? [2016-04-09 03:35:12] 4Edo had a suggestion to take all of the RPG levels that are getting shot out of awards we're restructuring and removing [2016-04-09 03:35:18] if it's in general it's good [2016-04-09 03:35:20] 4and creating a Worst RPG Level award [2016-04-09 03:35:27] 4to finish the level triad [2016-04-09 03:35:30] id prefer that [2016-04-09 03:35:33] worst rpg level [2016-04-09 03:35:45] what would be defined as rpg level [2016-04-09 03:35:47] that sounds like a good idea [2016-04-09 03:35:47] i'd be fine with it [2016-04-09 03:35:54] would it be like worst chapter? [2016-04-09 03:35:57] 12i think i like worst rpg level more too [2016-04-09 03:35:58] worst rpg area might be a better wording [2016-04-09 03:35:59] it looks like he wanted to do that next year though [2016-04-09 03:36:00] anything in smrpg, paper mario, or mario and luigi games [2016-04-09 03:36:02] but [2016-04-09 03:36:02] 4it could be I guess [2016-04-09 03:36:03] worst RPG area [2016-04-09 03:36:04] worst chapter, and also stuff from m&l games [2016-04-09 03:36:08] if we can do it this year i think that's ok [2016-04-09 03:36:11] like shroob castle or whatever [2016-04-09 03:36:13] its pretty self explanatory [2016-04-09 03:36:22] 12worst roster was the best suggestion in the thread i think but i was still kind of ehh on it [2016-04-09 03:36:24] that's my suggestion [2016-04-09 03:36:31] i still like worst roster though [2016-04-09 03:36:35] since we want to start user [2016-04-09 03:36:38] also per blocky [2016-04-09 03:36:40] worst rpg level sounds better actually [2016-04-09 03:36:41] maybe make this a forum vote/dicussion? [2016-04-09 03:36:50] but worst roster is ok [2016-04-09 03:36:54] "do we do worst roster addition or rpg level" [2016-04-09 03:36:58] 4we should decide the direction we're gonna take now [2016-04-09 03:37:02] ok [2016-04-09 03:37:05] 4so we have time to figure out nominees for whichever one we go with [2016-04-09 03:37:07] yeah but that sounds too similar to worst location, and all of the "levels" in m&l are more areas [2016-04-09 03:37:11] i like both ideas [2016-04-09 03:37:14] 4if we gotta tweak the name of either one afterwards that's fine [2016-04-09 03:37:18] 4so long as we have the general idea [2016-04-09 03:37:20] but slightly prefer the rpg one [2016-04-09 03:37:21] i'm ambivalent entirey [2016-04-09 03:37:57] idc much but rpg level sounds like a good idea [2016-04-09 03:38:05] 4ok so let's have a vote [2016-04-09 03:38:06] 9,1what is an 'rpg level' [2016-04-09 03:38:10] roster does too but idk if it wouldnt just come down to [2016-04-09 03:38:14] which game is worse [2016-04-09 03:38:17] 9,1no [2016-04-09 03:38:23] rpg area [2016-04-09 03:38:23] 4we'll figure out a precise name later so long as we have a general idea [2016-04-09 03:38:26] 4level, area, etc. [2016-04-09 03:38:38] things like thwomp volcano and flopside and the like [2016-04-09 03:38:41] i assume [2016-04-09 03:38:49] yes [2016-04-09 03:38:51] 4as with roster addition, which had disagreement on its meaning [2016-04-09 03:38:52] thats what im assuming [2016-04-09 03:38:54] but you're in those areas multiple time [2016-04-09 03:38:57] 4we're just voting for which direction to take [2016-04-09 03:39:03] 4so, with that: [2016-04-09 03:39:06] mk the thing about worst location is [2016-04-09 03:39:10] it's getting revamped into worst setting [2016-04-09 03:39:23] and including stuff like the entire main area of the game [2016-04-09 03:39:29] like subcon, northern kremisphere, etc [2016-04-09 03:39:41] 4Vote: Which new award concept should we work on? (Roster / RPG / a) [2016-04-09 03:39:43] so any similarities it has with the current award arent really a concern [2016-04-09 03:39:47] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:48] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:49] <_2257> 7rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:50] Roster [2016-04-09 03:39:51] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:51] Roster [2016-04-09 03:39:53] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:54] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:55] roster [2016-04-09 03:39:55] r;pg [2016-04-09 03:39:55] rpg [2016-04-09 03:39:57] 12a [2016-04-09 03:39:57] A [2016-04-09 03:40:00] *rpg [2016-04-09 03:40:17] 12after further thought i do not have a strong preference [2016-04-09 03:40:22] a [2016-04-09 03:40:30] rpg [2016-04-09 03:40:38] 123-9-2.5 [2016-04-09 03:40:43] 4rpg [2016-04-09 03:40:50] 123-10-2.5 [2016-04-09 03:40:52] rpg [2016-04-09 03:40:59] 123-11-2.5 [2016-04-09 03:41:59] 12i guess we have a winner [2016-04-09 03:42:03] 9,1rip [2016-04-09 03:42:08] 4unless there is any more discussion on this, we will go with the rpg concept [2016-04-09 03:42:14] 4I will create a thread to work it out after the meeting [2016-04-09 03:42:31] yay i can actually contribute to nominees on this award [2016-04-09 03:42:42] 4so as of this moment Fail Awards still need to complete the new F4 (the rpg concept) and edo's idea for F14 [2016-04-09 03:42:56] 4both things that can be fully discussed and worked out on the forum to be accepted in whole at the start of next meeting [2016-04-09 03:42:58] cool [2016-04-09 03:43:20] that sounds good [2016-04-09 03:43:35] 4with that we will begin User Awards [2016-04-09 03:43:35] ok [2016-04-09 03:43:41] :calp: [2016-04-09 03:43:45] *clap [2016-04-09 03:43:45] 4https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sfP1dSVCv-70pmkc8Vp8Oe0XM7D-rMk4HdmRnOHX-W0/edit -- detailed results from last year [2016-04-09 03:43:47] grea8 [2016-04-09 03:43:56] do we have a worst user award [2016-04-09 03:44:01] plzplzplzplz [2016-04-09 03:44:08] 12i nominate freakworld [2016-04-09 03:44:10] 4we had a sub-committee work out some of the ideas already and I'll get to those in a moment [2016-04-09 03:44:17] tbh id nominate myself [2016-04-09 03:44:21] anyways [2016-04-09 03:44:23] so [2016-04-09 03:44:27] 4tonight I just intend on introducing the big picture as well as large ideas [2016-04-09 03:44:30] 4just one moment [2016-04-09 03:44:43] *drumroll* [2016-04-09 03:44:44] are we still using the quick topic after this [2016-04-09 03:44:50] or is this what its been building to [2016-04-09 03:46:01] 4we can, idk lol [2016-04-09 03:46:06] 4probably move most of it public [2016-04-09 03:46:20] "idk lol" -anton, 2016 [2016-04-09 03:46:37] 4ok so there were 2 big ideas that we had discussed [2016-04-09 03:46:51] but what about all the shittalking we did about everyone' [2016-04-09 03:47:17] 4one being U1, the other being the removal of U9 Favorite Community Game to replace it with a wiki contributor based award [2016-04-09 03:47:31] 4Favorite Community Game has been a very weak and ill-defined award [2016-04-09 03:47:35] 4and tbh was kinda just filler [2016-04-09 03:47:44] wasn't it like a 4 way tie lol [2016-04-09 03:47:47] tbh thats kind of right [2016-04-09 03:47:59] 4 things got 12 votes [2016-04-09 03:48:01] yeah it's never held up as well [2016-04-09 03:48:05] the definition was pretty vague as well [2016-04-09 03:48:07] because mafia is the true winner [2016-04-09 03:48:12] all years every years [2016-04-09 03:48:13] 4this wiki contributor award will be outsourced to the wiki administrators to define and create nominees for [2016-04-09 03:48:23] 4I've already discussed this with turb [2016-04-09 03:48:37] yeah [2016-04-09 03:48:43] 4this was initially walkazo's idea, and unfortunately she will be unable to see it through to its end [2016-04-09 03:49:03] 4but I believe there was enough discussion generated about it privately to lead to a clear definition [2016-04-09 03:49:03] :( [2016-04-09 03:49:05] :( [2016-04-09 03:49:06] 9,1:( [2016-04-09 03:49:20] quick question [2016-04-09 03:49:23] 4one goal we had was to keep it contemporary, and as a way to honor prolific wiki editors [2016-04-09 03:49:26] 4ok [2016-04-09 03:49:28] 12:( [2016-04-09 03:49:33] unless you want to save them until the end or something [2016-04-09 03:49:38] 9,1I still haven't processed Walkazo's death [2016-04-09 03:49:44] 4you can say it [2016-04-09 03:50:12] will the contributor award be, like, open to anyone or specifically to non-admins [2016-04-09 03:50:17] 4anyone [2016-04-09 03:50:24] ah ok [2016-04-09 03:50:27] porple for best contributor [2016-04-09 03:50:29] 4I greatly prefer that it is open to everyone [2016-04-09 03:50:44] 4it's not set in stone but that's what my strong urging is towards the wiki admins when they discuss it [2016-04-09 03:50:57] i dont see any reason why it shouldnt be open to everyone yeah [2016-04-09 03:51:11] theres wiki editors that arent admins and have still contributed a lot [2016-04-09 03:51:17] i support open to everyone [2016-04-09 03:51:23] who could that be *shifty* [2016-04-09 03:51:24] per everyone [2016-04-09 03:51:29] mcd you're a patroller [2016-04-09 03:51:31] go [2016-04-09 03:51:31] the idea of admins nominating other admins seems a bit weird to me but eh [2016-04-09 03:51:32] 4the reason it's being outsourced to the wiki admins is because they're the group of people who will be able to make the best nominations with ample reasoning [2016-04-09 03:51:41] 4do you guys feel a week will be enough time [2016-04-09 03:51:47] 9,12 weeks [2016-04-09 03:51:51] 2 weeks would be the most [2016-04-09 03:51:58] 12open to everyone [2016-04-09 03:52:05] 4 2 weeks sounds, fine [2016-04-09 03:52:07] 9,1the wiki board can be really dead [2016-04-09 03:52:12] for the record i think open to everyone is better but i was just wondering [2016-04-09 03:52:14] 4we can have a progress report by the next meeting [2016-04-09 03:52:25] 4if there's any questions or concerns that need to be made and worked out [2016-04-09 03:52:27] 4that sounds gr8 [2016-04-09 03:52:37] 4I'll schedule it that way [2016-04-09 03:52:42] 9,1also i support open to everybody [2016-04-09 03:52:54] 4I think edo was going to post the proposal in the wiki admin board himself once it got time [2016-04-09 03:52:58] i would want it to be open to anyone [2016-04-09 03:53:05] 4so if you guys just want to wait until that happens that'll be gr8 [2016-04-09 03:53:12] 4I'm not expecting it'll be too long [2016-04-09 03:53:23] 4it'll just be the ~official~ proposal [2016-04-09 03:54:02] [02:51] turb mcd you're a patroller [2016-04-09 03:54:12] oh wait i thought you said "are admins" [2016-04-09 03:54:14] 4the next big idea [2016-04-09 03:54:18] welp [2016-04-09 03:54:19] o [2016-04-09 03:54:21] it's ok [2016-04-09 03:54:30] *drumrollintensifies* [2016-04-09 03:54:35] 4is regarding U1 [2016-04-09 03:54:43] 4this will be a more somber topic, so [2016-04-09 03:54:56] 4with Walkazo's passing we were unsure exactly how to handle it [2016-04-09 03:55:06] 4I felt that listing her as "Retired" is just not wording that I [2016-04-09 03:55:08] 4really like [2016-04-09 03:55:18] 4but failing to include her at all would be wrong [2016-04-09 03:55:32] 4what we opted to do was to just avoid the problem entirely to create something better [2016-04-09 03:55:42] 4we will be dropping U1 Favorite Retired User for this year [2016-04-09 03:55:50] okay [2016-04-09 03:55:53] ok [2016-04-09 03:55:56] 4to create a space for a dedication to Walkazo [2016-04-09 03:56:02] OK [2016-04-09 03:56:02] good [2016-04-09 03:56:04] 4dippy has already approached us to write something for it [2016-04-09 03:56:10] that sounds like a good idea [2016-04-09 03:56:18] im happy with that [2016-04-09 03:56:19] 4I will not be holding it down to the usual 5-minute presentation slot [2016-04-09 03:56:19] thats absolutely fine [2016-04-09 03:56:30] 4dippy will have as much time as she needs and the ceremony schedule will adapt around it [2016-04-09 03:56:43] im fine with that [2016-04-09 03:56:49] works for me [2016-04-09 03:56:50] 9,1I'm fine with that, too [2016-04-09 03:56:58] 4other people are welcome to do whatever they feel that they would like to do [2016-04-09 03:57:02] that's perfectly fine [2016-04-09 03:57:25] that sounds like that could take a while [2016-04-09 03:57:36] 4bonesy had an idea to create a separate thread to post everyone's dedications throughout the ceremony, with dippy's being the one posted in the official thread to open the ceremony [2016-04-09 03:57:42] well [2016-04-09 03:57:47] i guess a half hour or something isnt a huge deal [2016-04-09 03:57:50] 4as of this moment, I don't really know what it will be [2016-04-09 03:57:54] 4I'm guessing 30 minutes yeah [2016-04-09 03:58:05] 4but it's not like we had ample time to prepare for this [2016-04-09 03:58:09] i feel that this is a good idea [2016-04-09 03:58:10] i like bonesy's idea [2016-04-09 03:58:17] per [2016-04-09 03:58:19] I agree with the whole idea [2016-04-09 03:58:21] it makes it feel less lumped together [2016-04-09 03:58:28] per all [2016-04-09 03:58:40] per bonsey's idea [2016-04-09 03:58:44] 4gr8 [2016-04-09 03:58:46] 4he'll be so happy [2016-04-09 03:58:47] bonesy's idea is good [2016-04-09 03:58:52] 9,1I [2016-04-09 03:58:55] 12i agree with bonesy's idea [2016-04-09 03:58:58] 9,1there are a number of issues with this [2016-04-09 03:59:04] 4I do know that the shroom had /something/ [2016-04-09 03:59:05] oh boy [2016-04-09 03:59:09] 9,1can we make sure the mods are on the topic like a hawk [2016-04-09 03:59:14] well, duh [2016-04-09 03:59:17] they already are during the ceremony [2016-04-09 03:59:19] ill contact them [2016-04-09 03:59:20] of course we'll be doing our jobs [2016-04-09 03:59:22] there's no reason why this would be any different [2016-04-09 03:59:25] 9,1thank [2016-04-09 03:59:27] in fact i'm a little insulted [2016-04-09 03:59:36] perch u suck [2016-04-09 03:59:40] no u [2016-04-09 03:59:42] ayy lmao [2016-04-09 03:59:47] >:# [2016-04-09 03:59:48] 4pidgey will this plan for U1 interfere with anything that the Shroom has planned [2016-04-09 03:59:49] 4because [2016-04-09 03:59:51] 9,1no [2016-04-09 03:59:54] <_2257> 7pdigey just wants you to be liek a hawk because he's a bird supreamacist [2016-04-09 03:59:57] 9,1we scrapped it entirely [2016-04-09 03:59:59] 9,1because [2016-04-09 04:00:02] 4lumped into this would be a swapping of positions for the User and Shroom ceremonies [2016-04-09 04:00:10] 4traditionally Shroom goes first, followed by UP [2016-04-09 04:00:11] 9,1we felt it was better to have one big thing as opposed to two smaller things [2016-04-09 04:00:25] 4in order to allow the U1 to be the opener, User Awards would be going first [2016-04-09 04:00:36] 4I don't see this being an issue at all but [2016-04-09 04:00:41] that sounds fair as well [2016-04-09 04:00:42] 9,1it's not [2016-04-09 04:00:45] 4I feel like it should still be stated before I just go and do it lol [2016-04-09 04:00:51] i have 0 problems [2016-04-09 04:00:53] anyhow, pi [2016-04-09 04:00:57] besides moderation [2016-04-09 04:00:59] what else is up [2016-04-09 04:01:15] 9,1that's the only real issue I had, really [2016-04-09 04:01:15] 4since it's 10pm I'll close this up with another general thing [2016-04-09 04:01:18] oh ok [2016-04-09 04:01:19] 9,1about the topic things [2016-04-09 04:01:20] 9,1anyway [2016-04-09 04:01:27] 10pm? [2016-04-09 04:01:33] est [2016-04-09 04:01:34] 9,1I'll just confirm that yes, I agree with moving UP before 'Shroom. [2016-04-09 04:01:35] oh wait timezones [2016-04-09 04:01:37] 4the rest of the User awards are the nitty-gritty additions/removals [2016-04-09 04:01:40] I was going to ask a question, but it seems we're out of time. [2016-04-09 04:01:57] 4with U7 Favorite Community Event being another award considered for removal, but there are currently no new ideas [2016-04-09 04:02:08] ok [2016-04-09 04:02:16] 4so if anyone has something that they think could replace it, please suggest it on the forum, otherwise we will go ahead with basic additions/removals [2016-04-09 04:02:19] 4and smb you can ask [2016-04-09 04:03:35] I don't know which other awards Walkazo might be nominated for, but this was a concern I had in 'Shroom Awards discussions [2016-04-09 04:04:02] i think i was the only one to bring that up on the quicktopic [2016-04-09 04:04:15] and we just kinda figured we'd leave her in everything else [2016-04-09 04:04:19] 4undoubtedly she will be in the Wiki contributor award, as well as U10 community achievement and Favorite Artist and others [2016-04-09 04:04:19] And in case there were any User Awards she is potentially eligible to be nominated for, I want to bring it up so that it can be discussed in a general sense [2016-04-09 04:04:31] 9,1oh right [2016-04-09 04:04:37] 9,1politicising about a deceased user [2016-04-09 04:04:38] Okay, so the position is that she will still be nominated? [2016-04-09 04:04:39] she's probably going to dominate all those awards [2016-04-09 04:04:53] but you can't remove her from them [2016-04-09 04:04:56] am i allowed to bring up shroom awards discussion in here [2016-04-09 04:04:59] 4she will remain a nominee in those awards as for this year at least [2016-04-09 04:05:13] or shroom staff discussion [2016-04-09 04:05:19] 4any removals will be case-by-case next year, as for how user awards go [2016-04-09 04:05:21] i feel like thats suitable [2016-04-09 04:05:48] 4but tbh idk how the shroom is/will be handling it [2016-04-09 04:05:52] 4it's a very tough subject [2016-04-09 04:06:07] Well, obviously I'm leaving that up to Pi and the 'Shroom Staff to decide [2016-04-09 04:06:09] 4I am open for whatever you guys feel is appropriate [2016-04-09 04:06:18] 9,1the thing is [2016-04-09 04:06:54] 9,1we had this discussion about favourite Walkazo written section [2016-04-09 04:06:58] if favorite retired user is getting removed in favor of the dedication, should walkazo be on retired writer [2016-04-09 04:07:01] 9,1but SMB was against that idea IIRC [2016-04-09 04:07:02] or did we scrap that [2016-04-09 04:07:07] 9,1correct me if I'm wrong here, SMB [2016-04-09 04:07:14] like, should we still go with adding her [2016-04-09 04:07:18] because i remember that was discussed [2016-04-09 04:07:20] and it feels iffy [2016-04-09 04:07:25] maybe it's just me [2016-04-09 04:07:40] No, what I was worried about specifically was if including her, as a deceased user, as an option on a publicly voted poll is appropriate. [2016-04-09 04:07:58] 4turb: it was much easier to decide as it was U1 for User Awards, but in the shroom that award is S4 and a more minor award relatively [2016-04-09 04:08:03] 4i.e it's not S1 or S10 [2016-04-09 04:08:12] should we move discussion about this to other places/another meeting or [2016-04-09 04:08:14] 9,1right [2016-04-09 04:08:14] alright [2016-04-09 04:08:21] well i'm not suggesting it gets removed [2016-04-09 04:08:22] 4so the issue that I evaded is something I assume they'll have to actually address [2016-04-09 04:08:26] i'm just wonderinf it it's appropriate [2016-04-09 04:08:31] i guess it'll be brought up in the next meeting [2016-04-09 04:08:38] 9,1we're still not entirely sure about what to do with Shroom awards but [2016-04-09 04:08:44] 9,1I think we'll have a meeting this Sunday [2016-04-09 04:08:44] |<-- Glitchy has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [2016-04-09 04:08:46] 9,1to finish it up [2016-04-09 04:08:48] 9,1so [2016-04-09 04:09:01] 4ok [2016-04-09 04:09:41] -->| glitchy (Mibbit@g88-78-237-623.home.cgocable.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-09 04:09:42] 4so again as we wrap up: [2016-04-09 04:09:43] did we survive [2016-04-09 04:09:56] 4*F4 will need to be completed, discussion will be created in a new topic soon [2016-04-09 04:09:57] 9,1I'll report to you what we've decided on after the meeting is over [2016-04-09 04:10:08] 4*F14 will need to be worked out, discussion will continue on the forum [2016-04-09 04:10:39] goodnight [2016-04-09 04:10:40] 4*User Awards information will be dispersed in the User Awards General Discussion topic as the week goes on with next meeting hopefully being a quick and easy vote-to-approve fest [2016-04-09 04:10:56] 4anyone in the User Awards Sub-Committee plz continue posting in the qt [2016-04-09 04:11:03] |<-- glitchy has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Client Quit) [2016-04-09 04:11:15] 4beyond that I believe that's it for tonight!! [2016-04-09 04:11:18] 4thank you all for coming~ [2016-04-09 04:11:20] gg [2016-04-09 04:11:23] WE DID IT [2016-04-09 04:11:26] * Packy spits confetti [2016-04-09 04:11:28] meeting hype