[2016-04-16 01:56:08] -->| YOU (Lakituthequick) have joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 01:56:09] =-= Topic for #mwikiawards is ``"An Excellent Meeting" - Chef Excellence, 2015 || Awards are canceled, I have a hair appointment the day of the ceremony and I can't miss it, soz || 1st meeting hype || http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36197.0 Links || Number of meetings survived: 6'' [2016-04-16 01:56:09] =-= Topic for #mwikiawards was set by Tailmon!Smasher@kjhe939v.ipt.aol.com on zaterdag 9 april 2016 4:33:19 [2016-04-16 01:56:09] *ChanServ* [#mwikiawards] Chatroom rules: https://docs.google.com/View?id=drz9zgp_106rcrvqhhj [2016-04-16 01:56:09] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Lakituthequick by ChanServ [2016-04-16 01:56:56] -->| Freakworld (Freakworld@j2j66xg3t.dyn.telefonica.de) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 01:56:56] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Freakworld by ChanServ [2016-04-16 01:57:47] * Anton{Politoed} 4rolls around [2016-04-16 01:58:13] 9,1can Politoed even learn rollout [2016-04-16 01:58:19] why am i awake again [2016-04-16 01:58:28] 9,1because meetings [2016-04-16 01:58:42] what am i meeting? [2016-04-16 01:59:05] 4your fate [2016-04-16 01:59:34] i knew it this is some of that sort of shit ive read about in a bad book [2016-04-16 01:59:39] isnt it [2016-04-16 01:59:49] ok well i finished eating [2016-04-16 01:59:53] i wont be gone due to supper for once [2016-04-16 01:59:55] 4just in time [2016-04-16 02:00:05] 9,1hyp [2016-04-16 02:00:13] its about time [2016-04-16 02:00:14] 4hypnotoad [2016-04-16 02:00:38] 4ok so hey guys here we are at meeting no. 798 [2016-04-16 02:00:54] 4where today we can a concise schedule that's PACKED full of exciting things [2016-04-16 02:00:57] 4here it is: [2016-04-16 02:01:01] casualties: 5 [2016-04-16 02:01:07] 4*F14 Worst Location [2016-04-16 02:01:09] 4*F4 Worst RPG Area [2016-04-16 02:01:18] 4*User Awards [2016-04-16 02:01:22] 4*Begin Shroom Awards [2016-04-16 02:01:35] much ambitious [2016-04-16 02:01:41] 4and with that I give the floor to edo who will do either F4 or F14 whichever one he feels like doing first [2016-04-16 02:02:02] 3lets start with F14 because that will be the quickest one [2016-04-16 02:02:04] ok [2016-04-16 02:02:13] 3so [2016-04-16 02:02:42] 3over the last week we have been rebranding F14: Worst Location into a Worst Setting award [2016-04-16 02:02:56] 3shifting from individual areas and worlds to the settings of whole games [2016-04-16 02:03:10] 3the details can be found here: [2016-04-16 02:03:13] 3http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36644.0 [2016-04-16 02:03:38] 3we've been collecting nominees for this award over the last few days [2016-04-16 02:03:51] 3and it looks like we have a finalized list [2016-04-16 02:04:11] 3Subcon (Super Mario Bros. 2) [2016-04-16 02:04:13] 3Starship Mario + galaxies (Super Mario Galaxy 2) [2016-04-16 02:04:14] 3Mushroom Kingdom (Super Mario 3D Land) [2016-04-16 02:04:16] 3Sprixie Kingdom (Super Mario 3D World) [2016-04-16 02:04:18] 3Flip-/Flopside + dimensions (Super Paper Mario) [2016-04-16 02:04:19] 3Mushroom Kingdom (Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time) [2016-04-16 02:04:21] 3Pi'illo Island (Mario & Luigi: Dream Team) [2016-04-16 02:04:22] 3Party Cube (Mario Party 4) [2016-04-16 02:04:24] 3Star Carnival (Mario Party 8) [2016-04-16 02:04:26] 3Shroom City (Mario Party Advance) [2016-04-16 02:04:27] 3Party Islands (Mario Party: Island Tour) [2016-04-16 02:04:29] 3The Fun Fair + surrounding areas (Mario Pinball Land) [2016-04-16 02:04:30] 3Egg Island (Yoshi's New Island) [2016-04-16 02:04:32] 3Transformed Wario Castle (Wario World) [2016-04-16 02:04:33] 3DK Island/Crocodile Isle (Donkey Kong 64) [2016-04-16 02:04:37] 3http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36644.msg1831033#msg1831033 <-- here it is in presumably cleaner form [2016-04-16 02:04:53] 3so I guess all that is left to do for this award now is give it the committees blessing [2016-04-16 02:05:04] :thumbsup: [2016-04-16 02:05:06] 9,1y [2016-04-16 02:05:08] y [2016-04-16 02:05:09] i approve [2016-04-16 02:05:10] id be fine with doing this as it stands [2016-04-16 02:05:13] e [2016-04-16 02:05:17] yep [2016-04-16 02:05:29] 4coolio by me [2016-04-16 02:05:33] y [2016-04-16 02:05:47] 3joy [2016-04-16 02:05:53] 9 yes [2016-04-16 02:05:53] 👍 [2016-04-16 02:05:57] <_2257> 7y [2016-04-16 02:05:59] 11 [2016-04-16 02:06:03] or like [2016-04-16 02:06:09] 10 and an e [2016-04-16 02:06:37] 3e is for ecstatic [2016-04-16 02:06:41] 3anyway [2016-04-16 02:06:50] 3if there are no objections or anything, we can move on [2016-04-16 02:07:43] 3As you know because ive been bothering you per PM, we've also been collecting and deciding nominees for the new F4: Worst RPG area [2016-04-16 02:07:59] 3http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36649.0 <-- here [2016-04-16 02:08:24] 3I've done a tally and it looks like we have 17 solid nominees [2016-04-16 02:08:28] i forgot to vote [2016-04-16 02:08:32] dis@ster [2016-04-16 02:08:45] 3as well as a five way tie for the 18th spot [2016-04-16 02:08:57] >everything from pmss has less votes than merlees mansion [2016-04-16 02:09:04] u wot m8 [2016-04-16 02:09:06] 3the 17 that are in can be seen here http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36649.msg1831569#msg1831569 [2016-04-16 02:09:28] 3regarding the 18th spot, theres something I would like to say [2016-04-16 02:09:48] 3there is a tie between these options: [2016-04-16 02:09:52] 3Forever Forest (PM) [2016-04-16 02:09:53] 3Flip-/Flopside (SPM) [2016-04-16 02:09:55] 3Gritzy Desert (M&L:PiT) [2016-04-16 02:09:57] 3Energy Hold (M&L:BIS) [2016-04-16 02:09:58] 3Dreamy Mount Pajama (M&L:DT) [2016-04-16 02:10:15] oh god i forgot to vote too im sorry [2016-04-16 02:10:15] 3I would like us to pick one of them, BUT [2016-04-16 02:10:37] 3personally [2016-04-16 02:10:40] this tie is the direct result of me and turb not voting. let this be a lesson to me and turb [2016-04-16 02:11:06] 9,1#iVoted [2016-04-16 02:11:16] i didnt vote either [2016-04-16 02:11:29] 3I would like to give priority to Dreamy Mount Pajama and Energy hold, because BIS and DT are not yet represented in this award [2016-04-16 02:11:44] 3if that makes sense [2016-04-16 02:11:49] 4sounds good to me [2016-04-16 02:11:49] at least spm, ss and pmss have an equal number of entries [2016-04-16 02:11:54] perfect [2016-04-16 02:11:55] yeah [2016-04-16 02:11:57] 9,1good [2016-04-16 02:11:58] a [2016-04-16 02:11:59] better vote in November then [2016-04-16 02:12:08] i agree with needing representation but im not familiar with either game so i cant give any input on which one should be in [2016-04-16 02:12:11] okay nsy [2016-04-16 02:12:28] wasnt energy hold the fat thing [2016-04-16 02:12:32] i think if i had to pick one it'd be dt [2016-04-16 02:12:37] but i assume theres going to be an official vote later [2016-04-16 02:12:39] 3the fat thing sounds like flab zone [2016-04-16 02:12:41] 9,1dream team bros. for me [2016-04-16 02:12:50] which one was the energy hold then [2016-04-16 02:12:53] 3I THINK energy hold was the one with the carrot minigame? [2016-04-16 02:12:57] im too lazy to google [2016-04-16 02:12:59] http://www.mariowiki.com/Energy_Hold [2016-04-16 02:13:07] no its the one inside the yikk tower [2016-04-16 02:13:22] 9,1can i paste the entire article into chat [2016-04-16 02:13:24] i'm fine with making it between those two [2016-04-16 02:13:25] 3nvm [2016-04-16 02:13:52] oh that one [2016-04-16 02:14:02] i dont remember that being particularly bad [2016-04-16 02:14:06] 3is there any need for discussion regarding this [2016-04-16 02:14:22] my preference considering ive played both games would go to energy hold as that was by far the more tedious stage [2016-04-16 02:14:26] yeah i dont think either of those areas is particularly bad [2016-04-16 02:14:35] 12well, i wasn't working as long as i thought i would be [2016-04-16 02:14:41] because mount pajama is actually like [2016-04-16 02:14:41] 12give me a little bit' [2016-04-16 02:14:44] all i know is that all of the dreamy areas were slogs [2016-04-16 02:14:46] the least shitty area in dt [2016-04-16 02:14:48] probably [2016-04-16 02:14:59] 9,1i want to go for the dream team area [2016-04-16 02:15:00] yeah, that area is actually pretty okay [2016-04-16 02:15:01] in bis [2016-04-16 02:15:02] ive only played bis so idk [2016-04-16 02:15:03] 4if there were worse areas there was plenty of time to suggest it [2016-04-16 02:15:07] i enjoyed it more than others [2016-04-16 02:15:08] 3ok so [2016-04-16 02:15:16] i mean id go for the dt one too in the end but [2016-04-16 02:15:17] 3id like to make this official [2016-04-16 02:15:18] 4these are the options we hve now [2016-04-16 02:15:33] its not a good choice for dt probably [2016-04-16 02:15:53] imo [2016-04-16 02:16:02] if people think theres worse areas they can write them in [2016-04-16 02:16:08] imo [2016-04-16 02:16:09] the only real bad area in dream team is Pi'illo Castle [2016-04-16 02:16:13] man, that sounds sarcastic [2016-04-16 02:16:15] 3Which area should be the 18th nominee of Worst RPG area? (Dreamy Mount Pajama/Energy Hold/a) [2016-04-16 02:16:16] i didnt mean it to be though [2016-04-16 02:16:19] a [2016-04-16 02:16:20] yet no one else agrees [2016-04-16 02:16:20] dreamy mount pajama [2016-04-16 02:16:24] dmp [2016-04-16 02:16:27] a [2016-04-16 02:16:28] eh [2016-04-16 02:16:30] eh [2016-04-16 02:16:32] 4dreamy mount pajama [2016-04-16 02:16:33] pajama [2016-04-16 02:16:35] <_2257> 7a [2016-04-16 02:16:48] honestly the worst area in dt imo is neo bowser castle but that only got one other vote [2016-04-16 02:16:49] 9,1dreamy mount pajama [2016-04-16 02:16:50] so [2016-04-16 02:16:52] >eh [2016-04-16 02:16:52] how convenient [2016-04-16 02:17:17] like neo bowser castle just goes on for 3 times as long as it had to [2016-04-16 02:17:17] 5-2-3 [2016-04-16 02:18:09] a [2016-04-16 02:18:11] energy hold, because i only played BiS and i sort of remember that place going on forever [2016-04-16 02:18:15] 5-2-6 [2016-04-16 02:18:21] *5-2-4 [2016-04-16 02:18:31] 5-3-4 [2016-04-16 02:18:41] every area in dt goes on for too long though [2016-04-16 02:18:50] its part of the general issue of the game [2016-04-16 02:18:51] im talking about bis [2016-04-16 02:18:52] per freak [2016-04-16 02:18:54] -->| N64dude (Mibbit@wpo34204-crmc6-7-1-zaqb0.26-6.cable.virginm.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:19:04] the game takes more than 40 hours to beat [2016-04-16 02:19:08] i can't judge dt because i didn't play it [2016-04-16 02:19:14] 3are we going to get more than 12 votes [2016-04-16 02:19:20] while it could easily be done in 25 [2016-04-16 02:19:23] 12hi [2016-04-16 02:19:26] yes [2016-04-16 02:19:29] 12what's the vote [2016-04-16 02:19:34] 12oh [2016-04-16 02:19:35] 5-3-4 [2016-04-16 02:19:35] 12a [2016-04-16 02:19:42] Gabumon Which area should be the 18th nominee of Worst RPG area? (Dreamy Mount Pajama/Energy Hold/a) [2016-04-16 02:19:45] 5-3-5 [2016-04-16 02:20:01] 12i've never played dream team and don't remember energy hold [2016-04-16 02:20:34] 3actually, mark me down for dmp too [2016-04-16 02:20:37] we could just not have a 18th nominee if this isnt clear enough maybe [2016-04-16 02:20:43] idk [2016-04-16 02:20:44] 6-3-5 [2016-04-16 02:20:58] 3idk freakworld [2016-04-16 02:21:12] 18 sounds like an even number though [2016-04-16 02:21:14] 4if this vote were on a huge decision then I'd say it's too close [2016-04-16 02:21:14] 3if we can have representation of one more game, i would like to take that opportunity [2016-04-16 02:21:22] 4but this is just a final nominee [2016-04-16 02:21:25] 4simple majority works [2016-04-16 02:21:29] per edo [2016-04-16 02:21:35] 3ok, then lets go with dmp [2016-04-16 02:21:51] i dont care much i just ultimately think that dt should get representated over bis in terms of abysmal locations [2016-04-16 02:21:59] 12i should be able to tally from this point [2016-04-16 02:22:06] okay [2016-04-16 02:22:08] * Tailmon 12pushes nsy into a dumpster [2016-04-16 02:22:18] INTO THE TRASH [2016-04-16 02:22:20] sorry [2016-04-16 02:22:41] 3that makes this the final list of nominees for this award: http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36649.msg1831569#msg1831569 [2016-04-16 02:22:51] * NSY moves out of dumpster [2016-04-16 02:22:54] 4we did it [2016-04-16 02:22:59] 3ok [2016-04-16 02:23:05] 3I think that concludes fail [2016-04-16 02:23:06] wonderful [2016-04-16 02:23:16] 9,1user awards hype [2016-04-16 02:23:26] * NSY destroys tailmon [2016-04-16 02:23:31] 12what are the user awards [2016-04-16 02:23:32] time to abstain [2016-04-16 02:23:34] * Tailmon 12breaks [2016-04-16 02:23:41] 4any other concerns regarding Mario and Fail awards can be brought up during the full review in like [2016-04-16 02:23:42] same as up [2016-04-16 02:23:44] 4 2 weeks from now [2016-04-16 02:23:48] just rebraned [2016-04-16 02:24:01] *rebranded [2016-04-16 02:24:06] 4and if edo's cool I'm gonna take back over to start User Awards [2016-04-16 02:24:07] 12i know what they actually are [2016-04-16 02:24:16] 3sure [2016-04-16 02:24:19] 4gr8 [2016-04-16 02:24:31] 4so last meeting we touched on some of the larger topic regarding User Awards [2016-04-16 02:24:33] ok im here sorry for being late [2016-04-16 02:24:47] 4and between then and now the sub-committee worked out most of the final bits and pieces, but there's still some things to mull over [2016-04-16 02:24:57] 4but hopefully a good majority gets finalized this meeting [2016-04-16 02:25:16] 4one thing to not that I would appreciate though is that if in User Awards, as well as Shroom Awards coming up after [2016-04-16 02:25:21] 4if you are unfamiliar with the material [2016-04-16 02:25:23] 4just don't participate [2016-04-16 02:25:34] 4instead of flooding conversation with "abstain" and "I don't know" [2016-04-16 02:25:39] way ahead of you [2016-04-16 02:25:42] 4thx [2016-04-16 02:25:44] 4:) [2016-04-16 02:25:49] works for me [2016-04-16 02:26:01] 4that being said [2016-04-16 02:26:02] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36563.msg1830747#msg1830747 [2016-04-16 02:26:07] 4here is the mostly-complete list [2016-04-16 02:26:08] 12abstain [2016-04-16 02:26:14] 4we will be going through every single award [2016-04-16 02:26:26] a [2016-04-16 02:26:31] 4I will introduce each one, say what needs to be done, or not be done, and then whatever needs to be talked about after is good to go [2016-04-16 02:26:32] 4so [2016-04-16 02:26:43] 4U1 Favorite Retired User [2016-04-16 02:26:50] 4body of text explains most of it but just copy/pasting [2016-04-16 02:27:06] 4To be removed in place of a dedication to Walkazo, written and curated by Crocodile Dippy. The User Awards will flip-flop positions with Shroom Awards for this year for the purpose of having this dedication be the entire event opener. Dippy will remain in contact with us for any ideas she may have regarding this including anyone else directly involved as [2016-04-16 02:27:07] 4well as how much time she'll need for it. [2016-04-16 02:27:12] 4There will be a separate thread created for everyone else who would like to say or do something more, such as post artwork they've created in honor. We will need to publicize this as a thing so it will generate content for itself in a properly timed manner. [2016-04-16 02:27:47] 4with this decision made, the fine detailing of this award will then be left up to Dippy as well as Edo, 22, and I to create that separate thread when the time comes [2016-04-16 02:27:54] 12still sounds fine [2016-04-16 02:27:58] -->| Tucayo (Mibbit@187.137.rq.kkg) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:28:00] 9,1I still support this [2016-04-16 02:28:01] 4hi [2016-04-16 02:28:02] y [2016-04-16 02:28:05] HI! [2016-04-16 02:28:07] yep [2016-04-16 02:28:08] what do we support [2016-04-16 02:28:09] looks fine [2016-04-16 02:28:11] i think this is universally acclaimed [2016-04-16 02:28:15] 12removing you [2016-04-16 02:28:27] I oppose [2016-04-16 02:28:29] 4I'll pastebin really quick [2016-04-16 02:28:36] 12replacing retired user with a dedication to walkazo for this year [2016-04-16 02:28:50] 4http://pastebin.com/Bu571AGc [2016-04-16 02:28:53] oh yes, I support [2016-04-16 02:28:58] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36563.msg1830747#msg1830747 [2016-04-16 02:29:03] else pi would win again [2016-04-16 02:29:07] -->| Mariofan169 (Mibbit@798-861-844-90.lightspeed.iplsin.sbcglobal.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:29:17] 4up next then is [2016-04-16 02:29:19] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Mariofan169 by ChanServ [2016-04-16 02:29:24] 4U2 Favorite Written Fiction [2016-04-16 02:29:32] 4 -Additions: *The Haunted Hotel *The Super Shroomy Stories [2016-04-16 02:29:36] 4are there any concerns regarding those [2016-04-16 02:29:39] 9,1no [2016-04-16 02:29:43] 3nope [2016-04-16 02:29:46] no [2016-04-16 02:29:46] no [2016-04-16 02:29:49] 4pretty much all user content can be found on either UP or the Fan Creations board [2016-04-16 02:29:50] no [2016-04-16 02:29:54] 4in case you have any questions about what they are [2016-04-16 02:30:01] thankfully [2016-04-16 02:30:20] 4there's a few to talk about though [2016-04-16 02:30:25] 4 -Unsure: *The Bad Guy Loses *Scottish Mario [2016-04-16 02:30:33] 4The Bad Guy Loses apparently has not been updated in a while [2016-04-16 02:30:40] 3define a while [2016-04-16 02:30:45] 4and Scottish Mario seems to only have 1 chapter [2016-04-16 02:30:48] 2-3 months [2016-04-16 02:31:02] 3thats not that much time [2016-04-16 02:31:10] how many chapters does it have [2016-04-16 02:31:10] scottish mario has only one chapter and sifi seems unsure about continuing it at all [2016-04-16 02:31:10] 9,1Scottish Mario [2016-04-16 02:31:13] 9,1aka [2016-04-16 02:31:15] 3id say add it [2016-04-16 02:31:18] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=35371.0 [2016-04-16 02:31:20] so i'd agree with leaving it off [2016-04-16 02:31:45] 9,1The Thing That Had Rudnicki As Villain And Was Released When Rudnicki Had Graced The Forum With His Existence [2016-04-16 02:31:49] id say add bad guy loses and leave scottish mario off [2016-04-16 02:31:59] 9,1so [2016-04-16 02:32:04] 9,1leave them off [2016-04-16 02:32:18] 5 chapters is a decent amount of chapters, and 3 months isn't that much so i'm voting to add it [2016-04-16 02:32:32] bad guy loses was last updated 20th feb [2016-04-16 02:32:40] not really that long ago [2016-04-16 02:32:44] 4ok so it looks like we're doing that then [2016-04-16 02:32:50] 9,1oh [2016-04-16 02:32:53] 4Add bad guy, don't add scottish mario [2016-04-16 02:32:53] yeah the time isnt all that long [2016-04-16 02:32:56] 9,1I'm in support of bad guy [2016-04-16 02:32:58] (cur | prev) 01:32, 20 February 2016‎ LuigiNo.1 (Talk | contribs | block)‎ . . (3,580 bytes) (+3,580)‎ . . (Created page with "''The following text has been transcribed from a newspaper printed the day after Cirdec’s arrest.'' A legendary chess player, Sobrevolador, whose real name was Freakworld, ...") [2016-04-16 02:33:00] 9,1I made that unclear [2016-04-16 02:33:01] per anton [2016-04-16 02:33:02] 3yes [2016-04-16 02:33:04] so 2 months [2016-04-16 02:33:14] 12i haven't looked at either but from what it sounds like adding bad guy loses and leaving off scottish mario would be best [2016-04-16 02:33:15] woops nsy already said that sorry [2016-04-16 02:33:16] i made that post on the quicktopic just because the userpedia article seemed so much more quieter [2016-04-16 02:33:24] 4one moment while I update the Full List [2016-04-16 02:33:26] along with the forum topic [2016-04-16 02:34:16] 4here's this for reference btw https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sfP1dSVCv-70pmkc8Vp8Oe0XM7D-rMk4HdmRnOHX-W0/edit [2016-04-16 02:34:31] 4next up then is [2016-04-16 02:34:32] 4U3 Favorite Comic [2016-04-16 02:34:39] 4 -Additions: *The totally radically amazingly amazing adventures of anti-malware man & norton gordon‎ *MarioWiki Saga *Mario Boards Dinosaur Comics [2016-04-16 02:34:44] 4are there any concerns regarding the additions [2016-04-16 02:34:48] 9,1no [2016-04-16 02:34:51] nope [2016-04-16 02:34:52] no [2016-04-16 02:34:53] anti malwareman scares me [2016-04-16 02:34:59] no [2016-04-16 02:35:00] no [2016-04-16 02:35:05] 3no [2016-04-16 02:35:18] is that really the title yes [2016-04-16 02:35:25] heh [2016-04-16 02:35:27] yes that is the title yes [2016-04-16 02:35:51] 4gr8 [2016-04-16 02:35:55] 4 -Removals: *The Tonight Show *Wreck *Trolls' Island [2016-04-16 02:35:57] 4explaining each: [2016-04-16 02:36:02] 9,1The totally radically amazingly amazing adventures of anti-malware man & norton gordon is a really good comic [2016-04-16 02:36:05] 4The Tonight Show no longer exists [2016-04-16 02:36:07] 4the files are gone [2016-04-16 02:36:10] 4and no one has found them [2016-04-16 02:36:11] 4so [2016-04-16 02:36:12] rip [2016-04-16 02:36:13] 4____ [2016-04-16 02:36:14] oh............ [2016-04-16 02:36:22] 4tb OK'd Wreck being removed [2016-04-16 02:36:30] 4bonesy OK'd Trolls' Island being removed [2016-04-16 02:36:31] didn't neptune save every tsingle comic ever [2016-04-16 02:36:34] yeah, imageshack deleted the ENTIRE thing [2016-04-16 02:36:41] 4are there any reasons to disagree with them [2016-04-16 02:36:43] neurario was saving comics for a whil [2016-04-16 02:36:44] so unless it turns out someone has it [2016-04-16 02:36:45] e [2016-04-16 02:36:54] also if jorge paid for his imageshack account back he could recover it maybe [2016-04-16 02:36:57] im fine with the removals [2016-04-16 02:36:58] 4even though they have full authority to not have them included anyways [2016-04-16 02:36:58] unless he didnt upload with an account [2016-04-16 02:37:00] -->| DragonFreak (chatzilla@2602:306:ccde:vwgz:vmp:hpkl:ppmr:hwwo) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:37:01] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o DragonFreak by ChanServ [2016-04-16 02:37:14] i don't think he could [2016-04-16 02:37:14] requested + i really doubt anyone has tonight show if jorge himself doesnt [2016-04-16 02:37:16] im fine with this [2016-04-16 02:37:21] 3theres no point in disagreeing, lol [2016-04-16 02:37:24] as far as i can tell [2016-04-16 02:37:25] i remember sm was saving comics but i doubt he has it [2016-04-16 02:37:26] TI has been dead for like forever [2016-04-16 02:37:30] so yeah [2016-04-16 02:37:31] and its not worht the trouble anyway probably [2016-04-16 02:37:31] imageshack just wiped all free images [2016-04-16 02:37:35] (someone disagree with wreck) [2016-04-16 02:37:39] and i think they're unrecoverable [2016-04-16 02:37:44] no tb [2016-04-16 02:37:45] lolimageshack [2016-04-16 02:37:45] i disagree with wreck [2016-04-16 02:37:49] because /imageshack/ [2016-04-16 02:37:51] pretty sure imageshack said theyd bring things back if you paid for your account [2016-04-16 02:37:52] i'm still mad [2016-04-16 02:38:04] which is just laundering [2016-04-16 02:38:05] 4ok so the Removals are all good then [2016-04-16 02:38:10] okay but >paying imageshack after all the bullshit they did [2016-04-16 02:38:12] 4are there any other concerns regarding both U2 and U3? [2016-04-16 02:38:18] 12oh [2016-04-16 02:38:20] 12i actually [2016-04-16 02:38:24] none from me [2016-04-16 02:38:30] 12have part of the tonight show [2016-04-16 02:38:30] nope [2016-04-16 02:38:39] 12but not all of it and i also have dial-up [2016-04-16 02:38:51] 12so there's that [2016-04-16 02:39:00] 4if smasher can save The Tonight Show we'll reconsider it [2016-04-16 02:39:05] 4but until then it's ded [2016-04-16 02:39:14] thanks jorge [2016-04-16 02:39:16] 12i have 1-4 and 7 [2016-04-16 02:39:22] you really got us good [2016-04-16 02:39:40] 4next up then is [2016-04-16 02:39:42] 4U4 Favorite User Design [2016-04-16 02:39:42] |<-- mudkip has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Ping timeout: 248 seconds) [2016-04-16 02:39:50] 4 -Additions: *GBAToad [2016-04-16 02:39:54] 4he's a toad with a gba for a head [2016-04-16 02:39:55] 3agree [2016-04-16 02:39:57] 12i might be able to get internet that isn't shit before polls go up and if that happens i'll upload what i have to something [2016-04-16 02:40:01] yep [2016-04-16 02:40:05] i dont get the connection [2016-04-16 02:40:07] definitely agree [2016-04-16 02:40:13] 12that's a good design [2016-04-16 02:40:15] good to go [2016-04-16 02:40:22] 4he's been in enough user fics [2016-04-16 02:40:23] -->| mudkip (mudkip@24.219.lz.ii) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:40:31] agree w/ the addition [2016-04-16 02:40:35] 4notably dragon problem where his design is readily featured [2016-04-16 02:40:37] i agree wtih gbatoad too [2016-04-16 02:40:38] yep im good [2016-04-16 02:40:44] 9,1y [2016-04-16 02:40:59] 4gr8, then onto the unsure, who is conveniently here [2016-04-16 02:41:02] 4paging NEXandGBX [2016-04-16 02:41:05] 4 -Unsure: *NEXandGBX [2016-04-16 02:41:13] 3so ive thought about that [2016-04-16 02:41:15] 3and [2016-04-16 02:41:22] what is nex's design again? [2016-04-16 02:41:26] tbh nex is like 90% honoka [2016-04-16 02:41:36] 3I think the design is far enough removed from being a simple recolor to be viable [2016-04-16 02:41:36] http://wiki.userpedia.net/NEXandGBX [2016-04-16 02:41:46] 3like [2016-04-16 02:42:13] 3the hair (leaf?) style is different and things [2016-04-16 02:42:22] can i be in more user fics [2016-04-16 02:42:29] no [2016-04-16 02:42:30] 4yeah my concern with it was it being a recolor but like a lot of them are recolors, it's just to what extent are they made unique [2016-04-16 02:42:43] ive literally never seen that oc before i think unless it was in dragon problem because im afraid i might not have read the entirety of that [2016-04-16 02:42:47] 4if people feel that nex's design has successfully made that break then I'm coolio with it [2016-04-16 02:42:48] ...i never realized nex's design wasn't original until now [2016-04-16 02:42:56] yeah i didnt realize that for a long time [2016-04-16 02:43:01] in this case i cant be opposed to this because that looks original [2016-04-16 02:43:10] 4N64dude: you can be in my awards presentation [2016-04-16 02:43:18] th [2016-04-16 02:43:22] thx* [2016-04-16 02:43:46] nex is original enough for me [2016-04-16 02:43:54] 4no one's opposing and people seem convinced [2016-04-16 02:43:55] im fine with nex's addition [2016-04-16 02:43:59] 4so I'd consider that OK'd [2016-04-16 02:44:13] since it's me i'm not going to say anything on this [2016-04-16 02:44:17] im happy with nex [2016-04-16 02:44:20] 12i support nex's inclusion [2016-04-16 02:44:31] yes [2016-04-16 02:44:36] you could advertise yourself but [2016-04-16 02:44:45] but it seems not necessary to do that [2016-04-16 02:44:57] 4are there any other concerns, ideas, etc. about this award [2016-04-16 02:45:04] 4Favorite User Design [2016-04-16 02:45:13] none here [2016-04-16 02:45:17] looks good to me [2016-04-16 02:45:19] 4actually I just remembered one [2016-04-16 02:45:29] 4I'm not sure if mason sticks to the Puddin thing anymore [2016-04-16 02:45:31] 4paging mason [2016-04-16 02:45:40] i think he does???? [2016-04-16 02:45:46] its just purple now or something [2016-04-16 02:45:47] 9,1mason is not in this chatroom [2016-04-16 02:45:50] uh [2016-04-16 02:45:51] 4I'll just ask him later if he still wants to be on it because ultimately it's his decision [2016-04-16 02:45:55] i thought it was either the toucan or the purple magikoopa [2016-04-16 02:45:56] what design is actually [2016-04-16 02:46:00] considered to be the one on this award [2016-04-16 02:46:04] 4yeah it was the magikoopa thing [2016-04-16 02:46:11] 4but he's taken on that blue toucan thing [2016-04-16 02:46:12] how many designs does mason have [2016-04-16 02:46:21] 4so yeah I guess I'll just ask him [2016-04-16 02:46:29] he still uses the magikoopa just in a different colour, he also has a toucan design(in his avatar i believe) but it's not in much since there are no sprites of it [2016-04-16 02:46:34] 4and if there's some radical thing I gotta bring back up in a meeting then I'll do that [2016-04-16 02:47:01] 4gr8, so, moving on then [2016-04-16 02:47:12] 4U5 Favorite Artist [2016-04-16 02:47:15] 4 -Additions: *The Pyro Guy *Niiue *Stargatedalek [2016-04-16 02:47:17] |<-- Mariofan169 has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [2016-04-16 02:47:25] why arent we adding Meta_Knight [2016-04-16 02:47:27] 4TPG has been making comics and been shitting out a bunch of drawings and 3d things in several threads [2016-04-16 02:47:28] 9,1stargatedalek [2016-04-16 02:47:36] 4Niiue has been doing a lot of sprite work [2016-04-16 02:47:41] okay lets discuss my question later [2016-04-16 02:47:48] alright [2016-04-16 02:47:53] 4Stargatedalek has been doing, uhhh [2016-04-16 02:47:53] we have a response to meta knight [2016-04-16 02:47:55] i need to go do some things before places close [2016-04-16 02:47:56] 4I'll just get a link [2016-04-16 02:48:00] 4good luck [2016-04-16 02:48:00] and i don't know if i'll be back [2016-04-16 02:48:05] im fine with all 3 of those [2016-04-16 02:48:09] so i may be leaving the meeting for good [2016-04-16 02:48:13] later, peeps [2016-04-16 02:48:15] ive actually thought about this beforehand [2016-04-16 02:48:16] good luck [2016-04-16 02:48:18] bye [2016-04-16 02:48:21] b-bye [2016-04-16 02:48:23] thx [2016-04-16 02:48:26] be courageous [2016-04-16 02:48:30] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36469.0 [2016-04-16 02:48:44] 4she also has a drawing thread too [2016-04-16 02:48:51] she does? [2016-04-16 02:49:02] the birds were all i could find [2016-04-16 02:49:09] 4yeah like maybe 10 topics down from that one [2016-04-16 02:49:10] yeah [2016-04-16 02:49:14] i remember seeing it [2016-04-16 02:49:14] with the dinosaur skeletons right [2016-04-16 02:49:19] 4yeah [2016-04-16 02:49:22] 9,1y [2016-04-16 02:49:25] pretty near [2016-04-16 02:49:27] 4are there any concerns about these additions [2016-04-16 02:49:28] *neat [2016-04-16 02:49:30] 9,1no [2016-04-16 02:49:31] no [2016-04-16 02:49:32] they good [2016-04-16 02:49:33] why cant i find it in her list of started topics [2016-04-16 02:49:33] from what ive seen it more than deserves a nomination here [2016-04-16 02:49:44] additions are good [2016-04-16 02:49:49] okay, whats the stance on meta knight [2016-04-16 02:49:54] oh heres [2016-04-16 02:49:54] 4gr8 so those 3 are for sure added [2016-04-16 02:49:55] pokemon stuff [2016-04-16 02:50:03] 4 -Unsure: *MeritC *Starship Mario [2016-04-16 02:50:10] 4and I'll add mk to that since fw is asking [2016-04-16 02:50:12] 4so, in order: [2016-04-16 02:50:49] (here's star's drawings thread btw: http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=21984.0 ) [2016-04-16 02:50:55] 4meritc has some music stuff so I asked stooben who's in the user sub-committee to check it out [2016-04-16 02:51:00] sorry i had to eat [2016-04-16 02:51:13] I personally think Merit's stuff is cool but I'm no musical expert [2016-04-16 02:51:19] 4"MeritC, I'll have to look into these SNES arrangements a bit more. My gut tells me from the first few listens that he's just transposing notes and running them through some VST, but I need to compare these works with the original tracks to pass solid judgment. I'll research ModPlug Tracker too. For now, I can at least say, they're unlike anything else in the [2016-04-16 02:51:21] per tucky [2016-04-16 02:51:21] 4community. I don't know if that's enough to warrant a nomination on its own." [2016-04-16 02:51:30] i have to do something, be back soon [2016-04-16 02:51:41] 4I'm deferring to stooben's reluctance [2016-04-16 02:51:50] 4which I guess still leaves me at "unsure" [2016-04-16 02:52:28] id lean more towards yes than no [2016-04-16 02:52:46] is there anyone else on that list because of music (predominantly)? [2016-04-16 02:52:48] honestly id lean more towards no just because of stoob's thoughts [2016-04-16 02:52:50] but idk [2016-04-16 02:52:56] 9,1turb's thoughts are mine [2016-04-16 02:52:57] oh boy i guess i caught up just in time, fwiw, i now feel that meritc's works are no simple copy/paste arrangement, and would be supportive of his nomination [2016-04-16 02:53:02] transposing notes isn't easy per se thpough [2016-04-16 02:53:04] 4gr8 [2016-04-16 02:53:05] oh ok [2016-04-16 02:53:08] gr8 add him then [2016-04-16 02:53:09] 4then there we go that changes my mind [2016-04-16 02:53:11] 9,1support [2016-04-16 02:53:38] tbh that alone would warrant a nomination imo because its an entirely different sector of art being representated [2016-04-16 02:53:42] 4so meritc is added then [2016-04-16 02:53:45] y [2016-04-16 02:53:55] 4starship mario then, there's no questioning the talent [2016-04-16 02:53:57] 4but the concern is [2016-04-16 02:54:00] 9,1idk about starship mario [2016-04-16 02:54:05] 9,1who?????? [2016-04-16 02:54:07] who is that [2016-04-16 02:54:08] 4I don't want another person popping in for a week just in time to be nominated [2016-04-16 02:54:13] 4and then never show face in the community again [2016-04-16 02:54:22] 4we got burned on that every year so far so now we're being cautious [2016-04-16 02:54:50] |<-- mudkip has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Remote host closed the connection) [2016-04-16 02:54:52] http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36516.0 [2016-04-16 02:54:56] -->| mudkip (mudkip@24.219.lz.ii) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 02:54:58] 9,1i don't want to add starship mario [2016-04-16 02:55:17] 3when has anybody seen starship mario the last time [2016-04-16 02:55:21] Last Active: [2016-04-16 02:55:21] Last Active: 12:08:45, Fri 8 April 2016 [2016-04-16 02:55:22] April 08, 2016, 03:08:45 AM [2016-04-16 02:55:26] the one day he was on [2016-04-16 02:55:28] i saw him on irc the other night but he didnt say anything [2016-04-16 02:55:31] per pi [2016-04-16 02:55:33] the stuff's cool [2016-04-16 02:55:35] hes been on chat? [2016-04-16 02:55:37] 4that's just the login date though [2016-04-16 02:55:38] what tf [2016-04-16 02:55:41] 4he hasn't posted since he joined [2016-04-16 02:55:44] yeah honestly it looks like they already left [2016-04-16 02:55:45] i didnt even know who this was even though the art is good [2016-04-16 02:55:48] last post was a month ago [2016-04-16 02:55:53] yeah [2016-04-16 02:55:54] but he's not an active contributor of art [2016-04-16 02:56:01] last post was on join date yes [2016-04-16 02:56:02] i dont really feel confident he's going to stick around in time for the polls [2016-04-16 02:56:02] 'well, i definitely like these pieces, but, if this is the only work he's done and he's only been around inactively for a month, then... i'd have to say no. [2016-04-16 02:56:06] 4my opinion is leave the award open to people who are active community members [2016-04-16 02:56:16] Per Anton [2016-04-16 02:56:19] 4there's still plenty of time for him to do such a thing but at this exact moment in time my vote would be to not include [2016-04-16 02:56:20] although if he sticks around or comes back or whatever, he should be a shoe-in next year [2016-04-16 02:56:28] yeah, may as well add da vinci otherwise [2016-04-16 02:56:40] did da vinci do mario fanart [2016-04-16 02:56:40] vincent van gore [2016-04-16 02:56:45] yeah per stoob [2016-04-16 02:56:45] al gore [2016-04-16 02:56:46] 12per anton [2016-04-16 02:56:49] lol [2016-04-16 02:56:50] yeah it's not really fair if a good artist who joined for no reason other than to show off their art and then left forever gets on [2016-04-16 02:57:03] what is this [2016-04-16 02:57:05] artsy wario [2016-04-16 02:57:05] the louvre????? [2016-04-16 02:57:07] y/y [2016-04-16 02:57:10] a [2016-04-16 02:57:11] Luigi's Mansion scared me as a young kid [2016-04-16 02:57:24] ok [2016-04-16 02:57:31] 9,1ok [2016-04-16 02:57:33] anyways im fine with starship mario out [2016-04-16 02:57:34] ok [2016-04-16 02:57:46] with leaving [2016-04-16 02:57:46] 4to respond to freakworld [2016-04-16 02:58:16] 4mk was suggested but we decided that to be included in this award we'd like to see more unique works first [2016-04-16 02:58:25] 4as with starship mario there's still plenty of time to do that [2016-04-16 02:58:33] uhhhhh okay [2016-04-16 02:58:44] 4but as of this exact moment in time that we're drafting nominees the sub-committee decided best to leave him off for now [2016-04-16 02:58:45] sounds good to me [2016-04-16 02:58:58] tbh m was who first jumped to mind as a new nomination for this [2016-04-16 02:59:59] 4as for the next part [2016-04-16 03:00:00] 4 -Removals: *Toto *Smiley [2016-04-16 03:00:10] 4reasons include not really being active at all anymore [2016-04-16 03:00:26] 4Crash was a consideration in this grouping as well but he remains active in the community [2016-04-16 03:00:29] 9,1the most recent thing Smiley did was contribute to the 'Shroom cursor [2016-04-16 03:00:38] smiley just came back not too long ago actually lol [2016-04-16 03:00:39] 4is that enough to stay [2016-04-16 03:00:47] but i dont think shes really drawn anything in a while [2016-04-16 03:01:11] 9,1I wouldn't say so [2016-04-16 03:01:19] i have a general question [2016-04-16 03:01:21] <_2257> 7i mean [2016-04-16 03:01:23] 3actually, as was pointed out somewhere, crash has been doing some stuff for the shroom [2016-04-16 03:01:31] if you make art still occasionally i'd say it works fine [2016-04-16 03:01:33] <_2257> 7if we're keeping crash for being active in the community but not art [2016-04-16 03:01:39] <_2257> 7we can't really remove smiley for the same thing [2016-04-16 03:01:41] 4crash has done some shroom banners [2016-04-16 03:01:42] <_2257> 7right [2016-04-16 03:01:48] idk [2016-04-16 03:01:50] smiley isn't REALLY active though [2016-04-16 03:01:52] 4I think the distinction was that like [2016-04-16 03:01:54] 4crash never left [2016-04-16 03:01:56] she's been on irc a little as of like a week ago [2016-04-16 03:01:56] 4smiley left [2016-04-16 03:02:00] <_2257> 7isnt she [2016-04-16 03:02:03] i guess the difference is that crash has been consistently active in the community and still does art [2016-04-16 03:02:06] <_2257> 7ok [2016-04-16 03:02:08] 4she only really comes to #mariowiki to say hi and nothing else [2016-04-16 03:02:29] 4it's my opinion to keep active members on the award [2016-04-16 03:02:48] honest question: who is castle toad? [2016-04-16 03:02:49] 4but that's my say, if others feel convinced otherwise then now's the time to voice that [2016-04-16 03:02:57] 4aldo [2016-04-16 03:03:06] ah [2016-04-16 03:03:09] is crash still active? [2016-04-16 03:03:14] i hardly see him anywhere but his channel [2016-04-16 03:03:21] 12crash is on like every day [2016-04-16 03:03:28] does he like [2016-04-16 03:03:29] post anywhere [2016-04-16 03:03:33] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:03:34] 12yes [2016-04-16 03:03:38] 9,1he's around [2016-04-16 03:03:42] he's yuki isn't he [2016-04-16 03:03:49] hinoka [2016-04-16 03:03:49] y [2016-04-16 03:03:50] i feel like i never see him post but [2016-04-16 03:03:59] i guess thats not a unique thing [2016-04-16 03:04:04] theres lots of people on the forums i never see [2016-04-16 03:04:09] -->| Tucayo_ (androirc@187.237.osw.sv) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 03:04:09] crash was active yesterday [2016-04-16 03:04:12] 4aldo and slno, while falling away from the community, in the user sub-committee people felt that they should stay because they both provided a ton of user artwork for people who didn't have them [2016-04-16 03:04:15] posted yesterday [2016-04-16 03:04:18] 4rather than only personal projects [2016-04-16 03:04:27] 4both aldo and slno did a lot of community work [2016-04-16 03:04:31] yeah i agree with that [2016-04-16 03:04:35] they should be kept [2016-04-16 03:04:41] Same [2016-04-16 03:04:55] good [2016-04-16 03:05:02] 12aldo made my main image that gets posted on the forum somewhere every four months [2016-04-16 03:05:05] 12so yeah [2016-04-16 03:05:21] <_2257> 7aldo made it canon that smasher wears a blindfold [2016-04-16 03:05:23] <_2257> 7amazing [2016-04-16 03:05:27] 4everyone's cool with toto/smiley then? [2016-04-16 03:05:31] yeah [2016-04-16 03:05:33] y [2016-04-16 03:05:36] ye [2016-04-16 03:05:41] 9,1with them being [2016-04-16 03:05:43] 9,1what [2016-04-16 03:05:45] 9,1removed? [2016-04-16 03:05:47] 4yes [2016-04-16 03:05:47] 12yeah [2016-04-16 03:05:49] 9,1ok [2016-04-16 03:05:50] Y [2016-04-16 03:05:51] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:05:52] y [2016-04-16 03:05:55] yep [2016-04-16 03:05:57] y [2016-04-16 03:06:00] 4ok that's decided then [2016-04-16 03:06:12] 4are there any other concerns, ideas, etc. for Favorite Artist? [2016-04-16 03:06:50] Nope [2016-04-16 03:06:57] 9,1no [2016-04-16 03:07:07] ne [2016-04-16 03:08:10] no [2016-04-16 03:08:21] uhhhhhhhhh [2016-04-16 03:08:32] am i gone [2016-04-16 03:08:36] 4hi [2016-04-16 03:08:37] or is everyone just quiet [2016-04-16 03:08:40] ok cool [2016-04-16 03:08:50] don't worry tb, we still love you [2016-04-16 03:08:56] everyone swalled a rock yes [2016-04-16 03:09:01] *swallowed [2016-04-16 03:09:04] thats great [2016-04-16 03:09:15] but what i mean is ive been lagging on the network like every meeting [2016-04-16 03:09:37] where it seems like no one is talking for half an hour and then all of a sudden chat fills up with a novel from everyone in the last half hour [2016-04-16 03:09:53] |<-- Tucayo has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Quit: http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client) [2016-04-16 03:09:54] 4ok next up then is [2016-04-16 03:09:56] 4U6 Favorite 2015 Awards Presentation [2016-04-16 03:10:08] y to that entire list [2016-04-16 03:10:15] 4http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=36563.msg1830747#msg1830747 [2016-04-16 03:10:17] 4full list is there [2016-04-16 03:10:21] 4all linked to accordingly [2016-04-16 03:10:26] 4it's a nice 18 nominees [2016-04-16 03:10:52] a few nominees have a space in the url though [2016-04-16 03:10:52] 9,1y to the entire list [2016-04-16 03:11:04] list is good [2016-04-16 03:11:13] thats probably my fault lol [2016-04-16 03:11:34] f14 and a4 [2016-04-16 03:11:35] 4are any of the links broken [2016-04-16 03:11:37] 4ok [2016-04-16 03:12:01] y to the list [2016-04-16 03:12:05] and yeah its just those two that are broken afaik [2016-04-16 03:12:20] 4should be fixed [2016-04-16 03:12:24] it's just a stray space, rest is okay [2016-04-16 03:12:30] 4QuickTopic doesn't allow more than 4 links for some fucking reason [2016-04-16 03:12:33] 4except when I post them [2016-04-16 03:12:41] 9,1you made the topic [2016-04-16 03:12:42] lol [2016-04-16 03:12:43] 9,1so [2016-04-16 03:12:44] 4so when they were suggested everyone else had to break the links [2016-04-16 03:12:45] yeah they work now [2016-04-16 03:12:56] 4and I thought I fixed them all but I guess not [2016-04-16 03:13:03] 4either way that's the grouping we came up with [2016-04-16 03:13:13] Y [2016-04-16 03:13:33] ok im back [2016-04-16 03:13:48] 12me too [2016-04-16 03:13:50] 4no one's opposing the list so [2016-04-16 03:13:52] 4gr8 [2016-04-16 03:14:15] 4to fully examine the list people might need more time so if someone decides to shit their pants about something we can always readdress it later [2016-04-16 03:14:39] 9,1or, in other words [2016-04-16 03:14:41] I'll just say this is an award I rally like [2016-04-16 03:14:44] 9,1don't play Don't Shit Your Pants [2016-04-16 03:14:45] Really* [2016-04-16 03:14:46] i trust the user awards comittee on this matter so7 [2016-04-16 03:14:50] 4:) [2016-04-16 03:14:53] that game is great though [2016-04-16 03:15:55] 4next up then [2016-04-16 03:15:56] 9,1do i live [2016-04-16 03:15:57] 4U7 Favorite Community Event [2016-04-16 03:15:58] 9,1i do [2016-04-16 03:16:00] 9,1gr8 [2016-04-16 03:16:09] 4basically just copy/pasting what I already said [2016-04-16 03:16:16] 4The opinions seems to be leaning towards scrapping this and replacing, but we currently do not have many ideas to spare. Stoob suggested a Favorite Community LPer or something (DF, Dippy, Freakworld, GBA, LN1, and NEX) but I'm personally unsure how strong that will be. If we end up keeping this award, Additions and Removals are relatively easy and can be [2016-04-16 03:16:19] 4done rather quickly [2016-04-16 03:16:47] 9,1freakworld is a top tier lp'er tbh [2016-04-16 03:16:51] i agree [2016-04-16 03:16:57] im uncertain on community lper [2016-04-16 03:16:57] 9,1make another lp of a bad game [2016-04-16 03:17:03] 12who is freakworld [2016-04-16 03:17:04] daily reminder that i have to update my leafgreen lp [2016-04-16 03:17:09] dw its happening soon [2016-04-16 03:17:26] doooo we have enough lper [2016-04-16 03:17:26] (free publicity) [2016-04-16 03:17:28] s [2016-04-16 03:17:32] i dont think its big enough within the community yet for an award [2016-04-16 03:17:33] if we do do communuty lper masons gotta be on there [2016-04-16 03:17:33] 9,1we do [2016-04-16 03:17:34] How being is lping in the forum? I've personally never been too invested in them (sorry) [2016-04-16 03:17:35] 12i'm not sure about this one either [2016-04-16 03:17:38] Per nsy [2016-04-16 03:17:41] 4the LP award has achieved minimum, yes [2016-04-16 03:17:42] we have the ones listed here [2016-04-16 03:17:45] and also mason i guess [2016-04-16 03:17:46] i dont relaly think it's a good award though because i dont know how many people actually watch eachother's lps [2016-04-16 03:17:47] i still feel like lper is stronger than community event [2016-04-16 03:17:48] that being said freakworld's lps are great [2016-04-16 03:17:52] 4but it's also the only idea we've had [2016-04-16 03:17:54] i feel lke there's more [2016-04-16 03:18:00] Per uniju [2016-04-16 03:18:02] 4it's definitely stronger than Community Event [2016-04-16 03:18:05] i know vommack did some like two summers ago [2016-04-16 03:18:09] 4but [2016-04-16 03:18:10] i guess lp award i'd /accept/ if there weren't any better ideas [2016-04-16 03:18:13] 4____ [2016-04-16 03:18:14] which is sooner than dippy's [2016-04-16 03:18:15] 9,1two summers ago is not good enough [2016-04-16 03:18:17] Is favorite thread a thing [2016-04-16 03:18:28] 9,1bad idea [2016-04-16 03:18:31] 9,1MJ is not open for guests [2016-04-16 03:18:34] 4I'm not sure how we'd even quantify that [2016-04-16 03:18:35] no favorite thread would escalate [2016-04-16 03:18:37] 4plus that [2016-04-16 03:18:38] 9,1and MJ has the good threads [2016-04-16 03:18:42] most of the lps i've seen here haven't really finished [2016-04-16 03:18:43] True [2016-04-16 03:18:45] 12make draw smasher the only nominee [2016-04-16 03:18:46] from what ive seen at least [2016-04-16 03:18:50] 12problem solved [2016-04-16 03:19:05] favourite sippin time [2016-04-16 03:19:12] 4so I guess a decision to be made here is [2016-04-16 03:19:21] 4confirming whether or not we're scrapping Favorite Community Event [2016-04-16 03:19:36] scrap [2016-04-16 03:19:37] 4if we do scrap it we'd need to create a new award [2016-04-16 03:19:53] I'd be fine if we got something more inclusive thsn lp, otherwise keep [2016-04-16 03:19:56] 4if we don't scrap it, we'd need to generate new nominees, which as I said is kinda simple enough [2016-04-16 03:20:04] until there's a decent new award i dont think we should scrap it [2016-04-16 03:20:10] 4if we do scrap it I'll give it another week to create a new idea [2016-04-16 03:20:14] scrapping community event would be a good idea but replacing it with favourite lper would only be an okay idea.i dont have any ideas for replacements myself though so vOv [2016-04-16 03:20:34] 9,1I don't feel like we should accept a mediocre award [2016-04-16 03:20:37] i think community event is better than lp'er tbh [2016-04-16 03:20:38] im kinda biased i hvae to admit [2016-04-16 03:20:39] 9,1so we should scrapt it [2016-04-16 03:20:40] 12it's the best award to scrap but i'm honestly not sure if lper is that good of a replacement [2016-04-16 03:20:42] im genuinely not sure what another replacement idea would be [2016-04-16 03:20:44] 9,1*scrap [2016-04-16 03:20:53] 9,1we have a week to do something [2016-04-16 03:20:56] oh the person i thought i was missing is banned now so nvm [2016-04-16 03:20:56] i think we can keep it at least for like another year [2016-04-16 03:20:56] 9,1we can figure it out [2016-04-16 03:21:08] 9,1no [2016-04-16 03:21:09] 4ok so what I'll do is [2016-04-16 03:21:10] if we cant find something in a week we should just keep it though [2016-04-16 03:21:13] 9,1this is the tenth ceremony [2016-04-16 03:21:13] 4after the meeting [2016-04-16 03:21:14] ftg for best lets player tbh [2016-04-16 03:21:17] 9,1we need this to be good [2016-04-16 03:21:21] 12if we can't give a good replacement within a week can we just re-add this [2016-04-16 03:21:23] 9,1I vote to scrap it [2016-04-16 03:21:24] 4make a thread to rough this award up [2016-04-16 03:21:26] also tb didnt you do lps? [2016-04-16 03:21:27] 12and scrap it for the time being [2016-04-16 03:21:35] yeah that's better [2016-04-16 03:21:36] well if oregon trail counts [2016-04-16 03:21:37] 4leave it completely undecided for the time being [2016-04-16 03:21:41] <_2257> 7i honestly think lper is better than community event just by virtue of the fact that the results will be something new [2016-04-16 03:21:43] me and tfp did a few streams [2016-04-16 03:21:43] 9,1oregon trail is not an LP [2016-04-16 03:21:45] bring back tbsy'd lets plays, with voice [2016-04-16 03:21:46] oregon is a comic so i dont think it counts [2016-04-16 03:21:48] and yeah per 22 [2016-04-16 03:21:55] 4by next meeting whatever we have will be what we have [2016-04-16 03:22:01] oh ok [2016-04-16 03:22:05] 9,1that sounds like a good idea [2016-04-16 03:22:08] oregon is KIND OF a lets play but really [2016-04-16 03:22:09] not really [2016-04-16 03:22:11] 4so yeah let's do that, I'll make that thread after the meeting [2016-04-16 03:22:13] how about favorite poll [2016-04-16 03:22:13] this would be the second award where id be nominated [2016-04-16 03:22:21] its based on a lot of stuff that actually happened when i played like 5 years ago [2016-04-16 03:22:23] from the poll committee [2016-04-16 03:22:24] the last time was new shroom write in like [2016-04-16 03:22:26] 2013 [2016-04-16 03:22:29] i got one vote [2016-04-16 03:22:31] or like 2 [2016-04-16 03:22:33] not the best idea but its omsehting [2016-04-16 03:22:34] those were myself [2016-04-16 03:22:37] i dont know wht to make of that award [2016-04-16 03:22:38] *something [2016-04-16 03:22:43] 4next then is [2016-04-16 03:22:44] it sounds worse than the ones we already have tbh [2016-04-16 03:22:45] 4U8 Favorite Mafia Game [2016-04-16 03:22:50] like.... voting on poll options [2016-04-16 03:22:51] what [2016-04-16 03:22:54] 9,1y to the entire list [2016-04-16 03:22:55] anyway u8 [2016-04-16 03:22:57] Y [2016-04-16 03:22:59] i approve [2016-04-16 03:22:59] 4the list I created is the list of games between last awards and now [2016-04-16 03:23:01] per pi [2016-04-16 03:23:02] y [2016-04-16 03:23:07] y [2016-04-16 03:23:10] those are all my favourite mafia games [2016-04-16 03:23:12] y [2016-04-16 03:23:18] y [2016-04-16 03:23:18] 4there was an idea that if this list wasn't strong enough to use a compilation of the last couple years but [2016-04-16 03:23:26] 4if this is fine I would certainly prefer to make it a yearly thing [2016-04-16 03:23:34] 12i'm still not convinced the list is strong enough for an award, to be honest [2016-04-16 03:23:42] this is what the list shouldve been in the first place probably yeah [2016-04-16 03:23:45] 4last year was just a complete listing because it was the first time the award had been mde [2016-04-16 03:23:51] 4made* [2016-04-16 03:23:53] 12but if i'm outvoted, oh well [2016-04-16 03:23:54] add the rest of my mafias if you need more nominees [2016-04-16 03:23:57] even the shit ones [2016-04-16 03:24:00] daily reminder that i have to start nexandgbxandmafia [2016-04-16 03:24:00] a who plays mafia lol [2016-04-16 03:24:10] 4worst case this idea sucks and we change it next year [2016-04-16 03:24:23] daily reminder i have to do a mafia again after the love live mafia debacle [2016-04-16 03:24:23] Can favorite fad be a thing again or does it suck [2016-04-16 03:24:29] 9,1it [2016-04-16 03:24:30] 9,1sucks [2016-04-16 03:24:31] 12it still sucks [2016-04-16 03:24:33] 9,1soz [2016-04-16 03:24:44] have there even been any notable fads lately [2016-04-16 03:24:46] That's ok lol just brainstorming [2016-04-16 03:24:47] 9,1it sucked [years] ago, it sucks today [2016-04-16 03:24:50] favourite non-user [2016-04-16 03:24:53] 4by that mafia game list [2016-04-16 03:24:55] 4 -Games still running but expected to be finished or nearly complete by the time voting happens: [2016-04-16 03:24:58] fads are dead since 2014 [2016-04-16 03:24:58] dry bones jr deserves the recognition he deserves [2016-04-16 03:25:04] or whenever the last fad list was [2016-04-16 03:25:09] 3im gonna commit seppuku with a salami if favorite fad becomes a thing [2016-04-16 03:25:10] 4we'll just automatically accept any of those games that completes before the polls go up [2016-04-16 03:25:10] the problem is something of these awards are only interesting first time round [2016-04-16 03:25:11] 12i still don't know who the fuck dry bones jr is [2016-04-16 03:25:17] lmao edo [2016-04-16 03:25:20] then they die off very quickly [2016-04-16 03:25:21] he's the favourite non-user [2016-04-16 03:25:26] a non user from like [2016-04-16 03:25:28] 2007-2008 [2016-04-16 03:25:29] 4next up then is [2016-04-16 03:25:31] 4U9 Favorite Community Game: This entire award will be removed in favor of a TBD Wiki award. [2016-04-16 03:25:32] 4turb [2016-04-16 03:25:36] hi [2016-04-16 03:25:38] turb [2016-04-16 03:25:39] 4or any wiki staff member really but turb [2016-04-16 03:25:41] things are happening on that front [2016-04-16 03:25:42] 4how goes it [2016-04-16 03:25:46] happy birthday turb [2016-04-16 03:25:46] uh [2016-04-16 03:25:52] we have a few posts [2016-04-16 03:25:53] 9,1it goes okay [2016-04-16 03:25:56] 4are there any huge concerns that the AC should answer [2016-04-16 03:25:56] 9,1we need more posts [2016-04-16 03:25:59] They are but we still are some nominees short [2016-04-16 03:25:59] 9,1no [2016-04-16 03:26:04] Not really no [2016-04-16 03:26:04] 4or do you think it will be complete by next meeting [2016-04-16 03:26:06] nothing has blown up [2016-04-16 03:26:07] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:26:09] 4gr8 [2016-04-16 03:26:12] we can probably fnish it by then yeah [2016-04-16 03:26:13] 9,1it will be complete by next meeting [2016-04-16 03:26:17] Definitely [2016-04-16 03:26:37] will we allow write-ins for this [2016-04-16 03:26:40] 9,1no [2016-04-16 03:26:42] 4yes [2016-04-16 03:26:43] 3Well [2016-04-16 03:26:44] 9,1i don't think so? [2016-04-16 03:26:44] 4oh [2016-04-16 03:26:46] We could [2016-04-16 03:26:52] bc that could lead to people writing themselves in [2016-04-16 03:26:53] 9,1this is a thing we should discuss [2016-04-16 03:26:55] 4I'd prefer it if we did [2016-04-16 03:27:00] 9,1in the thread [2016-04-16 03:27:03] Yeah but then they'd only get a vote [2016-04-16 03:27:05] 4people can write themselves in for any award [2016-04-16 03:27:08] is this something i should have known what it is if i had actually been paying attention or ar eyou being vague because im nto suppose to know yet [2016-04-16 03:27:09] 4and they have in the past [2016-04-16 03:27:12] 4favorite artist, etc. [2016-04-16 03:27:13] 12that would apply to every user award [2016-04-16 03:27:17] 3you havent actually added that many admins to the nominees yet, so those might be able to fill out the list a bit [2016-04-16 03:27:19] 12that's not a good reason to leave it out [2016-04-16 03:27:20] 9,1good point [2016-04-16 03:27:31] 12a write-in box should be included [2016-04-16 03:27:35] 9,1add the write-in box [2016-04-16 03:27:36] i'm fine with write-ins [2016-04-16 03:27:38] like [2016-04-16 03:27:38] 4last year I got voted in for every Fail Award [2016-04-16 03:27:43] 4I should get an honorary award [2016-04-16 03:27:46] if we have like some random dude who's made 2 edits [2016-04-16 03:27:49] who writes himself in [2016-04-16 03:27:52] just remove him from the tally [2016-04-16 03:27:55] its not really a big deal [2016-04-16 03:27:59] 4yeah we tend to scrap joke votes [2016-04-16 03:28:00] it's happened in previous years [2016-04-16 03:28:06] 12worst game mechanic [2016-04-16 03:28:07] 12anton [2016-04-16 03:28:12] 4i'm so proud [2016-04-16 03:28:24] 4so yeah we'll readdress this in full next week [2016-04-16 03:28:37] 4if there's any other concerns the staff board can always be used to discuss it between now and then [2016-04-16 03:28:57] worst character [2016-04-16 03:28:59] anton [2016-04-16 03:29:03] 4i'm so proud [2016-04-16 03:29:08] 4that brings us to: [2016-04-16 03:29:08] 12worst game [2016-04-16 03:29:10] 12anton [2016-04-16 03:29:11] 4U10 Outstanding Community Achievement Award [2016-04-16 03:29:18] 4 -Additions: *Stooben *RandomYoshi [2016-04-16 03:29:22] 4stoob and pidgey both did stuff [2016-04-16 03:29:22] y [2016-04-16 03:29:26] 4does anyone think that they haven't [2016-04-16 03:29:33] <_2257> 7lol [2016-04-16 03:29:34] jk pi sucks [2016-04-16 03:29:38] hi [2016-04-16 03:29:39] 9,1;_; [2016-04-16 03:29:42] stuff is specific stuff is good [2016-04-16 03:29:46] y [2016-04-16 03:29:48] i'm in favor of both [2016-04-16 03:29:49] no to stooben because he's a terrible user >:( [2016-04-16 03:29:50] 9,1y [2016-04-16 03:29:52] y [2016-04-16 03:29:53] (jk stoob ily) [2016-04-16 03:29:54] y tho rly [2016-04-16 03:29:55] i dont like stooben because he is a bassist [2016-04-16 03:29:55] 4if specifics are needed [2016-04-16 03:29:56] 12i've never heard of either of them in my life who are these people i've never heard of either of them get rid of them who are these people [2016-04-16 03:29:58] Tucayo should at least be considered for inclusion [2016-04-16 03:29:59] 4a short list includes [2016-04-16 03:29:59] 12(add both) [2016-04-16 03:30:11] i dont know who stooben and randomyoshi is but fuck that guy [2016-04-16 03:30:16] not sure how he's not on there [2016-04-16 03:30:21] 4stoob created a new shroom section and has been quite a trooper with hosting shroom mafia and has been involved in other community goings and is a generally cool dude [2016-04-16 03:30:37] 4pidgey ever since he came back reattained chat op status and is now shroom sub-director [2016-04-16 03:30:39] 4things were done [2016-04-16 03:30:45] 9,1and wiki patroller [2016-04-16 03:30:48] 4yeah that too [2016-04-16 03:30:48] 9,1don't forget that [2016-04-16 03:30:51] 12pidgeys a patro-- [2016-04-16 03:30:54] i'd support adding them [2016-04-16 03:30:56] 4i'm gonna so remind me again later [2016-04-16 03:31:01] and inofficial meme president [2016-04-16 03:31:12] 9,1hey [2016-04-16 03:31:13] meme king [2016-04-16 03:31:18] 9,1i'm the meme prime minister [2016-04-16 03:31:20] 4as for the next bit [2016-04-16 03:31:21] and us presidential candidate 2016 [2016-04-16 03:31:23] 4 -Removals: *Mario4Ever [2016-04-16 03:31:34] 12yeah he hasn't done anything recently [2016-04-16 03:31:35] 9,1per [2016-04-16 03:31:35] 4he's disappeared, failed to act on his shroom duties, and received no votes last year [2016-04-16 03:31:37] i thought that was you already mcd [2016-04-16 03:31:47] 4the latter 2 probably a consequence of the first [2016-04-16 03:31:51] another point against m4e: terrible taste in anime [2016-04-16 03:31:57] 9,1was demoted on the wiki [2016-04-16 03:31:59] 12i'm running for president [2016-04-16 03:32:02] 9,1he liked sticker star [2016-04-16 03:32:05] i'm running for prime smasher [2016-04-16 03:32:08] i support stooben and pi [2016-04-16 03:32:09] oh rihght [2016-04-16 03:32:10] 9,1more than ttyd [2016-04-16 03:32:11] that guy [2016-04-16 03:32:14] 4was he demoted for liking sticker star [2016-04-16 03:32:19] lol [2016-04-16 03:32:20] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:32:21] probablhy [2016-04-16 03:32:22] i remember him hanging out in my chat [2016-04-16 03:32:26] 12prime smasher is not accepting applications at this time i'm sorry [2016-04-16 03:32:26] pretty much inactive now [2016-04-16 03:32:31] like while i was playing sticker star [2016-04-16 03:32:32] 4gr8 so these decisions are solid [2016-04-16 03:32:38] 12yep [2016-04-16 03:32:40] 9,1wait [2016-04-16 03:32:41] yeah [2016-04-16 03:32:42] 4are there any other concerns, ideas, comments, etc. regarding U10 [2016-04-16 03:32:52] tucayo? [2016-04-16 03:33:05] <_2257> 7someone existed who liked sticker star more than ttyd? [2016-04-16 03:33:07] <_2257> 7how horrific [2016-04-16 03:33:30] i was covinced tucayo already was in that award [2016-04-16 03:33:32] huh [2016-04-16 03:33:32] 12i have still never played sticker star [2016-04-16 03:33:34] i have no problems removing m4e for his depature from the community [2016-04-16 03:33:57] 12tucayo used to be but then he became inactive but now he's active again and i'm fine with re-adding him i think [2016-04-16 03:34:06] 9,1yeah [2016-04-16 03:34:11] 9,1i'm fine with re-adding him [2016-04-16 03:34:12] 4yeah tucky was removed last year in our purge of old people [2016-04-16 03:34:19] i'm also fine with this [2016-04-16 03:34:26] 4but he's clearly back [2016-04-16 03:34:29] 4so ________ [2016-04-16 03:34:35] #bringbacktucky [2016-04-16 03:34:41] 4I'm ok with readding him [2016-04-16 03:35:09] 4so yeah let's do that [2016-04-16 03:35:10] im fine with adding him again yeah [2016-04-16 03:35:13] 4confirmed [2016-04-16 03:35:13] he's come back and had big impact on the wiki and shroom [2016-04-16 03:35:22] 4are there any other concerns, ideas, comments, etc. regarding U10 [2016-04-16 03:35:29] not here [2016-04-16 03:35:30] Nope [2016-04-16 03:35:49] non [2016-04-16 03:36:11] 4ok so things 2 do then still for next week include: [2016-04-16 03:36:12] -->| Mariofan169 (Mibbit@798-861-844-90.lightspeed.iplsin.sbcglobal.net) has joined #mwikiawards [2016-04-16 03:36:17] 4figuring out what the hell to do with U7 [2016-04-16 03:36:21] 4and finishing up U9 [2016-04-16 03:36:24] 12brb [2016-04-16 03:36:25] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Mariofan169 by ChanServ [2016-04-16 03:36:29] recreate u7 aggressively [2016-04-16 03:36:34] which one is u7? [2016-04-16 03:36:41] favorite community event [2016-04-16 03:36:42] 4Favorite Community Event [2016-04-16 03:36:43] Favorite Community Event [2016-04-16 03:36:46] 4Favorite Community Event [2016-04-16 03:36:50] favourite [2016-04-16 03:36:54] 4the rest of the list seems gr8 though [2016-04-16 03:36:55] no u [2016-04-16 03:37:14] 4are there any concerns with User Awards in general before we end that [2016-04-16 03:37:20] no [2016-04-16 03:37:27] no [2016-04-16 03:37:30] maybe scrap it and replace it with a new award? [2016-04-16 03:37:33] 9,1I have no concerns about User Awards [2016-04-16 03:37:40] 9,1that is the current plan, mariofan [2016-04-16 03:37:41] 4all of users awards? [2016-04-16 03:37:48] 9,1about U7 [2016-04-16 03:37:55] 4scrap all of user awards for favorite community meme [2016-04-16 03:37:56] 9,1I think he means about U7 [2016-04-16 03:37:57] user awards did noting wrong [2016-04-16 03:38:04] replace user awards with miitomo awards [2016-04-16 03:38:05] 9,1y [2016-04-16 03:38:08] y [2016-04-16 03:38:10] 9,1y [2016-04-16 03:38:10] 4anyways with that [2016-04-16 03:38:12] we need meme awards [2016-04-16 03:38:18] 4Shroom Awards has a cool 20 minutes to do things [2016-04-16 03:38:21] not just one [2016-04-16 03:38:22] 9,1I suppose this is where I take over the meeting to discuss 'Shroom Awards related awards and such, which is what I'll do. http://www.mariowiki.com/images/e/eb/ShroomPoochy.png [2016-04-16 03:38:23] best mii: [2016-04-16 03:38:32] but an entire section [2016-04-16 03:38:36] did you prepare that pi [2016-04-16 03:38:39] oh man how do you balance a mushroom on your nose [2016-04-16 03:38:39] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:38:43] :poochy: [2016-04-16 03:38:45] that's so talented [2016-04-16 03:38:45] ok [2016-04-16 03:38:46] 9,1This is out contemporary list of awards: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uQLSDyh7car-oNh7v1aRWAwoM-BEjFD83axcI8khRCU/edit [2016-04-16 03:39:05] 9,1It has been in the general discussion thread for like [2016-04-16 03:39:07] 9,11 week [2016-04-16 03:39:17] 9,1but I suggest people take a look at it now [2016-04-16 03:39:29] 9,1and I'll just start with S1 immediately because wasting time is for losers [2016-04-16 03:39:30] im going to sit out these awards [2016-04-16 03:39:37] tbh i cant say anything at all about any of this since i dont read the shroom [2016-04-16 03:39:45] 9,1S1 — Favorite Directing Staff (Sadaharu, Stooben Rooben, Tucayo, Super Mario Bros., Superchao, 2257, Mr. Edo, Turboo, RandomYoshi) [2016-04-16 03:39:47] since i dont contribute to the shroom in any way [2016-04-16 03:40:00] 9,1Are there any concerns about S1? [2016-04-16 03:40:06] 4https://docs.google.com/document/d/12BW7jQGifsXU5kEqJRS1dXYqFSWlV46WIbuQV6nPcsE/edit [2016-04-16 03:40:11] 4last year's detailed shroom results btw [2016-04-16 03:40:17] locked [2016-04-16 03:40:21] 4fuk [2016-04-16 03:40:22] skip [2016-04-16 03:40:42] 4ok reclick [2016-04-16 03:40:45] i think this award is fine [2016-04-16 03:40:46] 4also pidgey if you could [2016-04-16 03:40:51] 9,1yes? [2016-04-16 03:40:53] 4can you detail any changes that the shroom made [2016-04-16 03:40:57] 9,1oh, right [2016-04-16 03:40:58] 4instead of just listing the final product [2016-04-16 03:41:03] 4so we have knowledge of what was even done [2016-04-16 03:41:18] 9,1that'll be done on Monday [2016-04-16 03:41:25] 4but we're in the meeting now [2016-04-16 03:41:35] for S1 RandomYoshi was added [2016-04-16 03:41:36] 9,1oh right [2016-04-16 03:41:42] 9,1yes, I was added for this [2016-04-16 03:41:47] 9,1and no other changes were made [2016-04-16 03:41:56] 4ok [2016-04-16 03:42:30] 4looks good to me [2016-04-16 03:42:54] 9,1gr8 [2016-04-16 03:43:10] 12this is fine [2016-04-16 03:43:58] 9,1if there's anything super wrong about this that needs to be changed then just speak out but [2016-04-16 03:44:07] 9,1I'll just accept this and move on to S2 [2016-04-16 03:44:19] 9,1which is Favorite Team (Fake News, Fun Stuff, Palette Swap, Pipe Plaza, Critic Corner, Strategy Wing) [2016-04-16 03:44:24] 9,1+Strategy Wing [2016-04-16 03:44:28] y [2016-04-16 03:44:30] 4simple enough for me [2016-04-16 03:44:35] yeah this one's fine [2016-04-16 03:44:36] 4no other viable changes [2016-04-16 03:44:45] 9,1i think we removed main team [2016-04-16 03:45:02] 9,1yeah [2016-04-16 03:45:17] 9,1we removed Main Team in favour for Strategy Wing and also because The 'Shroom no longer works that way [2016-04-16 03:46:35] 12this is fine [2] [2016-04-16 03:46:38] rip main team [2016-04-16 03:46:42] fun while it lasted [2016-04-16 03:46:52] rip [2016-04-16 03:47:01] 9,1I mean [2016-04-16 03:47:07] 9,1what would that include [2016-04-16 03:47:17] 9,1spotlight, opening statement and closing statement [2016-04-16 03:47:19] 9,1no [2016-04-16 03:47:20] 9,1not good enough [2016-04-16 03:47:33] 9,1(soz yoshi876) [2016-04-16 03:47:47] 9,1anyway [2016-04-16 03:48:02] 12rip main team [2016-04-16 03:48:08] 9,1you've all had ample time by now to complain which is why I'll continue with S3 [2016-04-16 03:48:22] 9,1Favorite Core Staff (MCD, Dippy, Yoshi876, FunkyK38, Shoey, Palkia47, GBAToad, Superchao, Mr. Edo, 2257, Andymii, Tucayo, Stooben, Turboo, RandomYoshi) [2016-04-16 03:48:47] 9,1-M4E [2016-04-16 03:49:07] 12rip m4e [2016-04-16 03:49:08] 9,1+Stooben, me, Tucayo [2016-04-16 03:49:13] Added: Superchao, Mr. Edo, 2257, Andymii, Tucayo, Stooben, Turboo, RandomYoshi [2016-04-16 03:49:13] Removed: M4E, P_Y, SMB [2016-04-16 03:49:31] 9,1what [2016-04-16 03:49:36] that what i see [2016-04-16 03:49:37] 9,1SMB should definitely be on the list [2016-04-16 03:49:41] 9,1wow we fucked up [2016-04-16 03:49:50] 12you know i was [2016-04-16 03:49:57] 12wondering why smb wasn't there [2016-04-16 03:49:59] 12gg [2016-04-16 03:49:59] nobody liked smb as core staff >:( [2016-04-16 03:50:00] 4he was on the list prior [2016-04-16 03:50:05] 4could just be an oversight [2016-04-16 03:50:08] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:50:12] 9,1re-adding SMB [2016-04-16 03:50:14] but yeah i don't remember why [2016-04-16 03:50:19] 9,1we just [2016-04-16 03:50:21] 9,1god [2016-04-16 03:50:27] 9,1no clue how that was done [2016-04-16 03:50:31] yeah that kind of boggles me too [2016-04-16 03:50:31] 12we're good at this [2016-04-16 03:50:38] 9,1+SMB [2016-04-16 03:50:42] 4it happens [2016-04-16 03:50:45] 9,1this does not need a vote but [2016-04-16 03:50:49] 9,1y/n/a [2016-04-16 03:50:50] 9,1on this [2016-04-16 03:50:52] 9,1y [2016-04-16 03:51:10] 9,1or something [2016-04-16 03:51:17] 12y do we need a vote [2016-04-16 03:51:21] 12just add him [2016-04-16 03:51:24] y [2016-04-16 03:51:25] just add it yeah [2016-04-16 03:51:25] 12who would oppose [2016-04-16 03:51:27] him [2016-04-16 03:51:32] theres no one who would actually [2016-04-16 03:51:33] y [2016-04-16 03:51:33] be opposed to this [2016-04-16 03:51:42] 9,1ok [2016-04-16 03:51:46] 9,1he's going to be added [2016-04-16 03:51:47] y [2016-04-16 03:51:47] 3people who hate alphabet soup [2016-04-16 03:51:49] 9,1now [2016-04-16 03:52:00] 9,1anything else that is super wrong about the award? [2016-04-16 03:52:13] i could have answered "a!" to that vote but i didn't [2016-04-16 03:52:30] 4I'm not seeing anyone on the current Core Staff list who's missing [2016-04-16 03:52:32] 4so I think it's good [2016-04-16 03:52:34] 9,1ok [2016-04-16 03:52:38] 9,1S4 now [2016-04-16 03:52:47] 9,1Favorite Retired Writer (Superchao, General Bob-omb, Gamefreak75, Chivi-chivik, Coincollector, Timmy, Anton, Marshal Dan Troop, Palkia47, Walkazo) [2016-04-16 03:52:51] Added: Anton, Marshal Dan Troop, Palkia47, Walkazo [2016-04-16 03:52:51] Removed: Stooben, Tucayo, MST3K [2016-04-16 03:53:04] 9,1Anton's inclusion is due to definitions [2016-04-16 03:53:23] 9,1Superchao is actually writing something for The 'Shroom now so we're removing him from this [2016-04-16 03:53:35] 4I do plan a return but it's after polls are done and everything [2016-04-16 03:53:40] 4so I agree that it's an ok fit [2016-04-16 03:53:42] 9,1oh [2016-04-16 03:53:59] 4my other section that I'm planning seems to be a one-shot if done at all so [2016-04-16 03:54:01] anton wins by a landslide thanks to hyp-i mean votes from his loving fans [2016-04-16 03:54:04] 9,1well then [2016-04-16 03:54:05] 4I think it's fine as it's written [2016-04-16 03:54:16] 9,1only change is removing Superchao [2016-04-16 03:54:27] 4and ok [2016-04-16 03:55:15] I was away but thanks for bringing me back :') [2016-04-16 03:55:24] 9,1np [2016-04-16 03:55:45] 9,1any other comments on S4? [2016-04-16 03:55:57] i've got nothing [2016-04-16 03:56:01] 3nope [2016-04-16 03:56:06] good day NEXandGBX [2016-04-16 03:56:09] you lose [2016-04-16 03:56:15] 9,1ok [2016-04-16 03:56:21] 9,1S5 time [2016-04-16 03:56:37] 9,1Favorite Veteran Writer (FunkyK38, MrConcreteDonkey, Toadbert101, Paper_Yoshi, Yoshi876, Crocodile Dippy, Mr. Edo, Andymii, Stooben Rooben, Tucayo) [2016-04-16 03:56:40] Added: Andymii, Stooben Rooben, Tucayo [2016-04-16 03:56:40] Removed: Marshal Dan Troop, Pyro, Palkia47, Driftmaster130 [2016-04-16 03:56:49] 9,1fun fact [2016-04-16 03:56:59] what'd we decide regarding me again [2016-04-16 03:57:03] which one [2016-04-16 03:57:04] We're directors in favorite core staff last years [2016-04-16 03:57:04] 9,1remove from retired [2016-04-16 03:57:06] Eere [2016-04-16 03:57:09] i mean [2016-04-16 03:57:11] vet/new [2016-04-16 03:57:22] 9,1good question [2016-04-16 03:57:36] 9,1I would want to say new but [2016-04-16 03:57:44] 9,1you're also not [2016-04-16 03:57:54] maybe get the AC thoughts? [2016-04-16 03:57:54] 9,1it depends entirely how we want to define the award, really [2016-04-16 03:57:59] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 03:58:04] 4what's the question exactly? [2016-04-16 03:58:10] didnt we have something we did about this in previous years [2016-04-16 03:58:13] 9,1there's also S6 [2016-04-16 03:58:19] writers who wrote for a significant amount of time beforehand and then came back [2016-04-16 03:58:20] 9,1favourite new writer [2016-04-16 03:58:24] i thought we just stuffed them in new [2016-04-16 03:58:29] lol [2016-04-16 03:58:44] 4https://docs.google.com/document/d/1DIuBdzVDXg75fA8_PQoKi7xKvYm5VDJQMSPgytGSSuQ/edit [2016-04-16 03:58:45] 9,1i [2016-04-16 03:58:47] 4that's last year's list [2016-04-16 03:58:47] 9,1can agree with this [2016-04-16 03:58:55] 12if he wrote a significant amount before i personally say vet because he's not new at allbut that's just me [2016-04-16 03:58:57] 4whatever precedent that sets [2016-04-16 03:59:10] i wrote a little in 2007 [2016-04-16 03:59:13] a lot in 2013-2014 [2016-04-16 03:59:15] and nothing else [2016-04-16 03:59:17] i fthat helps [2016-04-16 03:59:22] 4my personal opinion is that if someone has been writing, took a leave, and then returned [2016-04-16 03:59:24] 4it goes to vet [2016-04-16 03:59:30] 4instead of continuously going into new [2016-04-16 03:59:31] per anton [2016-04-16 03:59:43] 4when I return would I be put back into new writer [2016-04-16 03:59:45] i'd be new every year [2016-04-16 03:59:51] 4despite me picking up the same section [2016-04-16 03:59:57] that doesnt make sense [2016-04-16 04:00:08] isnt the award supposed to be to promote new writers? [2016-04-16 04:00:11] 12pet anton [2016-04-16 04:00:12] 12per [2016-04-16 04:00:13] not just let people vote in old favourites again [2016-04-16 04:00:16] 9,1pet anton [2016-04-16 04:00:16] pet [2016-04-16 04:00:17] im not going to pet anton [2016-04-16 04:00:20] 9,1'pet anton' ~ smasher [2016-04-16 04:00:20] 4:3c [2016-04-16 04:00:21] oh ok [2016-04-16 04:00:26] yeah that explanation of it makes sense [2016-04-16 04:00:28] per anton then [2016-04-16 04:00:32] 9,1per anton, too [2016-04-16 04:00:35] 12ｆｕｃｋ [2016-04-16 04:00:38] per me [2016-04-16 04:00:43] im not going to do that either [2016-04-16 04:00:44] 9,1so, superchao and packy get to join the award [2016-04-16 04:00:53] 9,1because packy's writing for us now, too [2016-04-16 04:00:55] 9,1so [2016-04-16 04:00:59] daily reminder that i should read the shroom so i can contribute to this [2016-04-16 04:01:10] 9,1new issue's out tomorrow [2016-04-16 04:01:14] 4 22:00 Chiaki_Nanami so, superchao and packy get to join the award [2016-04-16 04:01:15] 4for vet? [2016-04-16 04:01:18] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 04:01:24] 12if packy's writing again [2016-04-16 04:01:26] 9,1he is [2016-04-16 04:01:33] 4ok I'll consider packy not removed then with blocky an addition [2016-04-16 04:01:34] 12 Chiaki_Nanami Favorite Retired Writer (Superchao, General Bob-omb, Gamefreak75, Chivi-chivik, Coincollector, Timmy, Anton, Marshal Dan Troop, Palkia47, Walkazo) [2016-04-16 04:01:45] 9,1right, remove him from that [2016-04-16 04:01:46] 12un-add him from this [2016-04-16 04:01:50] ok [2016-04-16 04:02:08] 4makes sense [2016-04-16 04:02:53] 4((it's time to end the meeting btw if there's any final thoughts on S5 or if you, pidgey, want to introduce any huge ideas that need to be thought about this upcoming week)) [2016-04-16 04:03:04] 9,1not really, no [2016-04-16 04:03:10] 4gr8 ! [2016-04-16 04:03:15] 9,1except there actually is one thing I want the AC to discuss [2016-04-16 04:03:18] gg [2016-04-16 04:03:31] 9,1this thing concerns S8 [2016-04-16 04:03:32] 9,1Favorite Written Section of the Past Year (Crocodile Style Reviews (Crocodile Dippy), Mario's Boombox (Walkazo), 8-bit Amphitheater (Stooben), DragonFreak's Review Quest (DragonFreak), Guess Who! (Andymii), Location, Location (Time Turner), The 'Shroom Report (Tucayo), Tip of the Month (FunkyK38), Anniversary Announcements (Lakituthequick), Obituaries (Yoshi876), The Stoob Tube... [2016-04-16 04:03:34] ...(Stooben), Pocket Handbook (Crocodile Dippy), Dear Anton (Anton), Fightin' Footwear (Anton & Shoey)) [2016-04-16 04:03:57] 9,1I want as much comments about this as possible [2016-04-16 04:04:05] its a list [2016-04-16 04:04:13] 3its green [2016-04-16 04:04:15] 9,1find stuff you think isn't on that list and ask if it's noteworthy to include [2016-04-16 04:04:20] [s]my section[/s] [2016-04-16 04:04:21] 4it's a new award idea to pair up with the Best Use of Images [2016-04-16 04:04:23] 12it has a black blackground [2016-04-16 04:04:27] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 04:04:29] some doesn't [2016-04-16 04:04:32] 4so I agree with pidgey on having commentary [2016-04-16 04:04:58] 9,1we need this to be a good award [2016-04-16 04:05:00] 9,1so [2016-04-16 04:05:04] 9,1read the old issues [2016-04-16 04:05:08] 9,1find good stuff [2016-04-16 04:05:10] 3[04:04] Chiaki_Nanami find stuff you think isn't on that list and ask if it's noteworthy to include [2016-04-16 04:05:11] 9,1suggest them [2016-04-16 04:05:14] 3so essentially [2016-04-16 04:05:25] 3"suggest more nominees"? [2016-04-16 04:05:27] 9,1yes [2016-04-16 04:05:30] 3ok [2016-04-16 04:05:51] 9,1S8 was previously 'favourite section of the past year' by the way [2016-04-16 04:05:56] 4any final things before I close up? [2016-04-16 04:05:57] 9,1so yeah [2016-04-16 04:06:04] 9,1comments/concerns/more nominees [2016-04-16 04:06:06] 9,1would be good [2016-04-16 04:06:09] 9,1no [2016-04-16 04:06:12] 4ok ! [2016-04-16 04:06:18] 4so with that, winding the meeting to a close [2016-04-16 04:06:19] did we do it [2016-04-16 04:06:29] 3second meeting hype! [2016-04-16 04:06:32] 4I will be posting a thread in a few minutes to discuss what to do with U7 [2016-04-16 04:06:35] second? [2016-04-16 04:06:44] 9,1and I will be posting a thread about S8 [2016-04-16 04:06:46] but we haven't even had the first yet [2016-04-16 04:06:53] i am biased towards favorite lper so [2016-04-16 04:06:57] 4U9 will be finished by next meeting; both awards we will readdressed next meeting [2016-04-16 04:07:04] 4we'll finished up Shroom Awards then and then ?????????? [2016-04-16 04:07:09] 4we'll figure it out [2016-04-16 04:07:18] 4finish* [2016-04-16 04:07:18] ono are we ahead [2016-04-16 04:07:21] awards committee rave party [2016-04-16 04:07:24] 4no we're right on time [2016-04-16 04:07:28] hooray [2016-04-16 04:07:28] woo [2016-04-16 04:07:30] rave party [2016-04-16 04:07:31] okay [2016-04-16 04:07:32] |<-- mcd has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Quit: z) [2016-04-16 04:07:33] 4meeting is adjourned