F8 Worst Mario Kart Course (Choco Mountain, Sky Garden, Shy Guy Beach, Rainbow Road (SNES), Yoshi Falls, Grumble Volcano, Sherbet Land (N64), Koopa Beach 2, Banshee Boardwalk, Maple Treeway, Maka Wuhu, Rosalina’s Ice World, Rainbow Road (Wii), Dolphin Shoals, Bone-Dry Dunes)
<Anton{Politoed}>
13) Dolphin Shoals — 79 — 3.37% 14) Sky Garden — 50 — 2.13% 15) Maple Treeway — 33 — 1.41% 16) O. Rainbow Road (N64) — 20 — 0.85% 17) O. Baby Park — 17 — 0.72% 18) O. Figure-8 Circuit — 16 — 0.68% 19) O. Rainbow Road (Wii U) — 13 — 0.55%
<Anton{Politoed}>
as much as I hate Maple Treeway personally, I think we can chop it for Rainbow Road N64
<Anton{Politoed}>
but are there any others to consider
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i agree with that chopping
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
hmmmm
<Anton{Politoed}>
I don't think any new ones were made
<Anton{Politoed}>
is deluxe doing anything
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
maaaaybe sky garden vs. baby park would be worth considering?
<Lord_Bowser>
no
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
beyond that no
<GBAToad>
no deluxe is just battle courses
<Lord_Bowser>
mk8dx is only doing battle stuff
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah
<Lakituthequick>
Deluxe does battles courses but not races courses
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok
<Anton{Politoed}>
so, !
<DragonFreak>
i personally like maple treeway and baby park but i wouldn't really care if either are chopped or added
<shoutmon>
man
<shoutmon>
have we ever had a mario kart battle mode themed award
<DragonFreak>
i dont remember we ever had
<Anton{Politoed}>
I don't think so, and maybe it can be shoehorned into this one
<shoutmon>
we should totally do that this year
<Gabumon>
favorite balloon color
<shoutmon>
to coincide with mk8dx
<GBAToad>
i was actually gonna bring that up as a suggestion since deluxe will be out
<Anton{Politoed}>
do what
<GBAToad>
gdi 22
<Anton{Politoed}>
new award or just add them in
<shoutmon>
had a favorite battle track award or sth
<Lord_Bowser>
oh that actually wouldn't be a bad idea
<Blue_Bowser>
new award
<GBAToad>
If we add them in then like
<Anton{Politoed}>
if there's a new award we need to remove one
<Blue_Bowser>
combining might make things to bloated
<GBAToad>
The award will need a huge overhaul
<Anton{Politoed}>
and also this is Fail right now so keep that in mind
<shoutmon>
yeah i only said it now because it just occured to me
<Gabumon>
we could save this idea for when we go through all the awards again
<shoutmon>
its not really somethign to discuss now
<Lord_Bowser>
per edo
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok
<Gabumon>
and use the time to brainstorm shit on the forum
<Anton{Politoed}>
what we could do then is tidy up this award into a finished state if to be left as its current definition
<Anton{Politoed}>
and with that
<Meta_Knight>
i wouldnt mind either way if maple treeway was replaced with n64 rr or if it wasnt
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Remove "Maple Treeway" from F8? (y/n/a)
<Gabumon>
a
<DragonFreak>
y
<Blue_Bowser>
y
<GBAToad>
a
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<Lakituthequick>
y
<DragonFreak>
the wigglers are too cute tbh
<GBAToad>
ayyayy
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<Meta_Knight>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<Lord_Bowser>
6-0-2
<Lord_Bowser>
7-0-2
<Anton{Politoed}>
wigglers are the worst, assuming ukikis have been eradicated and are no longer an issue
Mariofan169 has joined #mwikiawards
<Lord_Bowser>
what,
turb has joined #mwikiawards
<shoutmon>
i dont like wiggler either
<Lord_Bowser>
ukikis are adorable
<GBAToad>
wigglers are Bad
<meowth>
hi i'm here sorry
<Mariofan169>
to make up for being late I brought bacon-wrapped shrimp
<Gabumon>
I wont stand for this discrimination against caterpillars
<GBAToad>
ukikia are Worse
<Anton{Politoed}>
they're both disgusting
<turb>
i waited for like 30 minutes before I realized
<shoutmon>
its not caterpillars
<Anton{Politoed}>
anyways Maple Treeway is removed
<shoutmon>
its wigglers specifically
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Add "Rainbow Road (N64)" to F8? (y/n/a)
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<Gabumon>
born anew, we live again
<GBAToad>
y
<Lakituthequick>
y
<turb>
"maybe someone dislodged the cords"
<Meta_Knight>
y
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<Blue_Bowser>
a
<Gabumon>
hold on
<turb>
the cords were dislodged
<DragonFreak>
i'll stand up for you edo since you are a caterpillar in another life/game
<Mariofan169>
which award is this
<turb>
anyway
<turb>
what did i miss
<turb>
y
<DragonFreak>
worst mario kart track
<Gabumon>
y
<Mariofan169>
a
<meowth>
y, and a retroactive y to maple treeway
<Lord_Bowser>
we voted to ban you from the ac turb
<shoutmon>
listen i liked genji
<Anton{Politoed}>
you didn't miss much
<turb>
damn
<Nyrie>
hello i'm here now
<meowth>
10-0-2
<shoutmon>
i jsut think wiggler has an ugly design
<GBAToad>
who doesnt like genji
<GBAToad>
best robot ninja
<turb>
i need to splice in the beginning part of the logs
<DragonFreak>
no gbatoad the better genji
<GBAToad>
who needs healing
<turb>
so
<Nyrie>
healing meme xD
<Mariofan169>
but raiden
<Lakituthequick>
tfw you type raisin road on your notes
<Anton{Politoed}>
I hate that wiggler gets angry when it's the asshole being an obstruction
<Anton{Politoed}>
like it's not your place to get angry so go fuck off tbh
<shoutmon>
the other genji
<Blue_Bowser>
anton you're the one going through their forest
<Anton{Politoed}>
they built their forest on my racetrack
<Mariofan169>
it's time like these where I ponder
<Anton{Politoed}>
anyways rainbow road n64 is added
<Mariofan169>
would I be the bad guy
<GBAToad>
i need art of a genji ow wiggler for the horror of it
<Anton{Politoed}>
how up to swapping sky garden and baby park is anyone
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm not exactly too enthuse about it and won't hold a vote unless someone really wants me to
<Blue_Bowser>
baby park is a good couse
<GBAToad>
idk sky garden is worse imo
<Blue_Bowser>
course
<DragonFreak>
yeah
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i was throwing it out to see what peple thought
<shoutmon>
i also like baby park
<DragonFreak>
i mean yeah to shoey
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i'm fine teither way
<Mariofan169>
it's the best they could do with the gba tbf
<Nyrie>
why do people like baby park,,,,,
<shoutmon>
idk if that matters thoguh
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah i like baby park
<shoutmon>
what really matters is what the public thinks
<Lord_Bowser>
nyrie the chaos
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok so are there any other changes to be made, barring the thing I'll make a topic for later
<Gabumon>
I "like" baby park because its a unique experience
<Blue_Bowser>
so i'm in favor of any option that changes baby park
<Gabumon>
total item mayhem
<Lord_Bowser>
not that i can think of
<Mariofan169>
how did it do last year
<turb>
yeah baby park is at least unique
<DragonFreak>
17 writins
<shoutmon>
i kind of wish it had more laps though
<Mariofan169>
if it had a high place then it's up for elimination
<DragonFreak>
*write-ins
<Lord_Bowser>
me too 22
<shoutmon>
even with 7, its still over in like
<Lord_Bowser>
just make it like
<shoutmon>
2 minutes
<Mariofan169>
o h b o t h e r
<Lord_Bowser>
50 laps
<Nyrie>
22 its more like 1 minute
<DragonFreak>
that's like nascar level
<Nyrie>
each lap is about 9 seconds
<shoutmon>
i havent played mario kart in 10 years
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok gonna move on then
<Mariofan169>
I still need to replay mk8
<Anton{Politoed}>
F9 Worst Direction of Series (Mario vs. Donkey Kong, Paper Mario, amiibo-centric/Focused Games, Mario Party, Mario Tennis, New Super Mario Bros., Mario 3D Games, WarioWare, Yoshi)
<Mariofan169>
and stop neglecting the wii u in general
<GBAToad>
still mad warioware came 3rd
<turb>
is there anything else that nintendo drove into the shitter
<Lord_Bowser>
mario and luigi
<DragonFreak>
really how does ww come 3rd
<Anton{Politoed}>
7) New Super Mario Bros. — 169 — 6.83% 8) Yoshi — 51 — 2.06% 9) Mario 3D Games — 31 — 1.25% 10) O. CD-i Games — 17 — 0.69% 11) O. Edutainment Games — 10 — 0.40% 12) O. Mario & Sonic at the Olympics Franchise — 3 — 0.12%
<Lord_Bowser>
paper jam was pretty _
<GBAToad>
cdi games LOL
<Lord_Bowser>
lol
<Blue_Bowser>
what does mario 3d games mean
<DragonFreak>
yeah lb that's what i feel like every game in that series after superstar
<Lord_Bowser>
sm3dl and sm3dw
<Mariofan169>
I think we could get rid of yoshi with how well woolly world did
<shoutmon>
were the mario edutainment games EVER good
<Blue_Bowser>
those games are good
<Anton{Politoed}>
it's amazing how the 3D games all placed super low in Mario Awards, if not last in every single one with every nominee
<Anton{Politoed}>
then places last in the Fail award
<Blue_Bowser>
a lot of people really like 3d world
<turb>
im not sure cdi or edutainment were ever good
<Lakituthequick>
i know i do
<turb>
this might just be a skip honestly
<Anton{Politoed}>
not enough to make them not literally all 3 last places in every award that had them nominated
<turb>
i dont know whether yoshi is worth removing but most people like woolly world so
<Lord_Bowser>
idk i kinda want to add m&l
<Anton{Politoed}>
Yoshi and 3D Games have considerably lower amounts than NSMB
<Blue_Bowser>
why cause they had one mediocre game
<Anton{Politoed}>
but I don't exactly think they should be removed
<Blue_Bowser>
like Paper Jam was alright from what i've heard
<Anton{Politoed}>
there's no need to, there's <10 nominees
<Blue_Bowser>
the sky isn't falling
<Mariofan169>
what about dream team
<meowth>
i havent played the last two m&l games so i can comment on them
<meowth>
cant*
<Lord_Bowser>
paper jam is pretty divisive
<Blue_Bowser>
I heard that one was good
<Anton{Politoed}>
Mario & Luigi did not get a single vote
Pack_Attack has joined #mwikiawards
<Lord_Bowser>
i played a bit of dream team and i got bored early on
<shoutmon>
i would just skip this
<meowth>
i dont think anything should be removed
<Lord_Bowser>
but that's just me tbf
<Gabumon>
skip
<Anton{Politoed}>
if literally anyone voted for them I would consider it but they didn't
<Anton{Politoed}>
maybe next year
<meowth>
i think id be in favor of skipping it
<Lord_Bowser>
i guess skip then
<Nyrie>
i think skip
<turb>
skip
<meowth>
given that m&l didnt get any writeins at all
<Lord_Bowser>
it's not like a major thing anyway
<Mariofan169>
skip
<Anton{Politoed}>
F10 Worst Game Mechanic (Dimensional Flipping (SPM), Star Bits (SMG & SMG2), Camera (3D Games), Vibes (SPP), Joystick Twirling (MP), Limited Inventory (PM & PM:TTYD), Stickers (PM:SS), Button Mashing (MP), Gyroscope Controls (3DS Games), Vehicles (MP9 & MP10), Extra Life System)
Packy has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Killed (NickServ (GHOST command used by Pack_Attack)))
Pack_Attack is now known as Packy
<Anton{Politoed}>
9) Dimensional Flipping (SPM) — 54 — 2.18% 10) Star Bits (SMG & SMG2) — 31 — 1.25% 11) Extra Life System — 21 — 0.85% 12) O. Motion Controls (SMG & SMG2) — 5 — 0.20% 13) O. Chance Minigames (Mario Party series) — 2 — 0.08% 13) O. Coin Item (SMK & MK8) — 2 — 0.08% 13) O. Level Timer — 2 — 0.08%
<Anton{Politoed}>
write-ins are nothing, but
<Mariofan169>
did super mario run have any features that caused backlash
<Lord_Bowser>
did pmcs do anything stupid
<Anton{Politoed}>
this is from last meeting
<Anton{Politoed}>
[2017-03-31 18:38:25] <Anton{Politoed}> the Autorunning part of it, if anything, would fall under Worst Game Mechanic [2017-03-31 18:38:29] <Anton{Politoed}> so let's remember that for later
<Gabumon>
I would add motion controls due to personal bias
<Anton{Politoed}>
autorunning being from super mario run
<Nyrie>
^^^^
<GBAToad>
how well received was the colour mechanic in colour splash
<shoutmon>
color splash repeated the sticker mechanic but now as "cards"
<turb>
i also share that personal bias
<Blue_Bowser>
I liked it personally
<Meta_Knight>
but motion controls isnt always bad
<Meta_Knight>
spinning in galaxy is super helpful
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
could we combine it as stickers/cards?
<shoutmon>
also it had a pretty shitty cutout mechanic, but that wasnt used so much that it became overwhelming
<Anton{Politoed}>
but the autorunning isn't something I heard people complain about
<Meta_Knight>
as well as nsmbw
<Anton{Politoed}>
the $10 price tag was
<shoutmon>
probably perch
<Blue_Bowser>
I'd be in favor of motion controls
<Gabumon>
spinning could have been a button and it would have been better
<dia>
motion control is always bad because the technology isnt up to the task
<shoutmon>
there's very little difference
<Lord_Bowser>
are they similar enough though perch
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i don't know
<Lord_Bowser>
stickers and cards
<Anton{Politoed}>
and paying for a game isn't exactly something I'd consider a game mechanic or even bad
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
that's why i'm asking someone who played it
<GBAToad>
we should remember the 10$ price tag for missed opportunity
<Lord_Bowser>
shoey nyrie
<Lord_Bowser>
how similar are cards to stickers
<Nyrie>
add "Having to spend money on games"
<Blue_Bowser>
cards are better
<Blue_Bowser>
I think?
<Blue_Bowser>
I never played sticker star
<Nyrie>
i prefer the cards
<Nyrie>
i played both
<Lord_Bowser>
but like mechanic wise
<Nyrie>
they're pretty similar
<Lord_Bowser>
are they pretty much the same
<shoutmon>
is there any difference beyond coloring the cards in
<Nyrie>
nope
<GBAToad>
anyway i have to go for a bit but if missed opportunity rolls around while im gone then id like to suggest no mystery mushrooms in smm3ds
<turb>
cant they be merged
<turb>
stickers/cards
<Nyrie>
yeah what turb said
<turb>
pmss/pmcs
<Nyrie>
they're basically the same
<Lord_Bowser>
ok i guess they could be merged then
<Nyrie>
just a different name
<Lord_Bowser>
just wanted to confirm how similar they were
<Anton{Politoed}>
so before I get to votes
<Anton{Politoed}>
is there anything anyone wants removed
<Lakituthequick>
if they're the sane
<Lakituthequick>
why are cards better
<Lakituthequick>
also @anton
<shoutmon>
coloring mechanic adds a little strategy
<Nyrie>
paint thing adds a little more strategy
<Lakituthequick>
gyroscope stuffs
<shoutmon>
i dont consider it a very big or significant change
<Lakituthequick>
how relevant is that still
<shoutmon>
but someone else might
<Nyrie>
in certain battles it is
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
did paper jam use it?
<Lord_Bowser>
paper jam did i think
<Anton{Politoed}>
what's relevancy got to do with this, though
<Lord_Bowser>
for special attacks
<Lakituthequick>
well ive seen old stuff getting removed in the past
<Lakituthequick>
then again joystick is also on
<Anton{Politoed}>
we also have Button Mashing from Mario Party 1 yeah
<Lakituthequick>
so nvm
<Nyrie>
in some battles you can only use certain colors to paint things so you have to plan around that
<meowth>
i dont think anything needs to be removed
<Anton{Politoed}>
I think this award is one that can permit old things, unlike others
<turb>
^
<Lakituthequick>
yeah lol
<Anton{Politoed}>
for ones to add, what were they
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Motion Controls (SMG & SMG2)
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Cards ??
<Anton{Politoed}>
*???
<Gabumon>
id say just motion controls period
<Lord_Bowser>
merge cards with stickers
<Nyrie>
motion controls
<Nyrie>
and change "Stickers" into "Stickers/Cards"
<Lord_Bowser>
also yeah just motion controls in general
<Gabumon>
motion controls are a blight that permeates the entire wii era of games
<dia>
per nyrie
<Nyrie>
they aren't different enough to warrant seperation
<shoutmon>
yeah, smg was actually not the worst eaample of motion controls
<Nyrie>
and motion controls isn't just a problem for smg
<shoutmon>
nsmbw had a way worse mechanic
<Anton{Politoed}>
should it be "Motion Controls (Wii games)" then?
<Gabumon>
just motion controls
<shoutmon>
wii u also i think
<Nyrie>
wii u has shit motion controls too
<Nyrie>
as does 3ds
<meowth>
Stickers/Cards (PM:SS & PM:CS) ?
<Nyrie>
i'd just leave it as "Motion Controls"
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm a little _ on making it a blanket thing for it but
<DragonFreak>
3ds has motion controls?
<dia>
i think its fine ti just use motion controls as a blanket term
<Anton{Politoed}>
if they're universally bad then lol
<Gabumon>
nobody's going to accidentally think "Motion Controls (N64)
<Gabumon>
"
<shoutmon>
did you not know that df
<dia>
i dont know about the switch
<Mariofan169>
I'd say just put in motion controls with smg/2
<shoutmon>
switch has motion controls too
<dia>
but thats the only other nintendo thing i can think of with motion controls
<dia>
and the others are all bad
<Lakituthequick>
isn't gyro constrols literally all of those things wii and u also have though
<Lord_Bowser>
i thought the 3ds just had a gyroscope
<DragonFreak>
i mean i knew there was a gyroscope but is that motion controls?
<shoutmon>
yes df
<turb>
gyroscope is different isnt it
<Mariofan169>
I don't think there's that many other mario games on the wii that had bad motion controls
<turb>
i mean
<shoutmon>
no
<turb>
in like
<DragonFreak>
oh ok
<Gabumon>
super paper mario also had motion controls
<turb>
the sense of what edo is talking about
<Nyrie>
why would that not count as motion controls
<Mariofan169>
or motion control at all
<Nyrie>
you're moving the console to control the game
<turb>
not different in general
<dia>
i dont play many mario games with motion controls, so i'll sit out of this
<shoutmon>
3ds actually has the worst motion controls imo
<Lord_Bowser>
well
<Mariofan169>
examples?
<Anton{Politoed}>
we could just rename Gyroscope to "Gyroscope/Motion Control"
<Lord_Bowser>
maybe do something like
<turb>
i thought he was talking specifically about wii motion controls even if the nominee would just be Motion Controls
<Nyrie>
dream team boss battles
<Gabumon>
the MM remake had the only instance of motion controls I ever liked
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah
<turb>
that could work anton
<Lord_Bowser>
like waht anton said
<Mariofan169>
oh
<DragonFreak>
per edo
<Nyrie>
also per anton thats what i was thinking
<dia>
per anton
<meowth>
i agree with anton
<Gabumon>
gyroscope aiming for arrows was pretty neat
<Lakituthequick>
i mentioned something like that earlier
<Nyrie>
i liked the motion controls in splatoon
<Nyrie>
it made aiming a lot more precise surprisingly
<shoutmon>
yes, aiming is the only good use of motion controls
<shoutmon>
or at least the only one i can think of
<Nyrie>
same for arrows in botw
<Mariofan169>
getting a bit off topic here
<dia>
mini games
<dia>
driving is the worst use of motion controls
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Rename "Gyroscope Controls (3DS Games)" to "Gyroscope/Motion Controls"? (y/n/a)
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<dia>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<turb>
y
<Mariofan169>
y
<meowth>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<meowth>
8-0-0
<Lakituthequick>
wouldnt gyroscope fall under motion
<meowth>
i think it fails
<Meta_Knight>
y
<Gabumon>
its just for clarification
<meowth>
9-0-0
<Anton{Politoed}>
yeah what edo said
<Nyrie>
y
<Lakituthequick>
k
<Lakituthequick>
y
<dia>
yeah, so people cant vruet
<meowth>
11-0-0
<Lakituthequick>
what is 'vruet'ing
<Lord_Bowser>
you forgot ltq's vote for k /s
<Gabumon>
excuse me, I believe you mean so people can't crust
<Anton{Politoed}>
lol
<Lord_Bowser>
lol
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<dia>
k
<meowth>
12-0-0
<Anton{Politoed}>
what's this about cards, though
<Lord_Bowser>
merge them with stickers
<dia>
per
<Lord_Bowser>
according to nyrie and shoey they're basically the same
<Lakituthequick>
..what is 'crust'ing
<dia>
they are the same mechanic
<turb>
its a long story
<Anton{Politoed}>
how would that be worded
<dia>
cards/stickers?
<dia>
something like that?
<turb>
Stickers/Cards (PM:SS/PM:CS)
<Anton{Politoed}>
"Stickers (PM:SS)" is the current title
<Nyrie>
Stickers/Cards (PM:SS/PM
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok
<Nyrie>
yeah
<Nyrie>
turb
<Lord_Bowser>
per turb
<dia>
per turb
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Rename "Stickers (PM:SS)" to "Stickers/Cards (PM:SS/PM:CS)"? (y/n/a)
<Lord_Bowser>
perturbed
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<Nyrie>
y
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<Blue_Bowser>
y
<DragonFreak>
but do the titles have to be writen out in full?
<turb>
y
<GBAToad>
Y
<Mariofan169>
a
<DragonFreak>
y
<Anton{Politoed}>
df do you mean the game titles?
<DragonFreak>
yeah
<Lakituthequick>
y
<Lord_Bowser>
9-0-1
<dia>
y
<Anton{Politoed}>
not unless they're the actual thing being nominated
<Lord_Bowser>
11-0-1
<meowth>
y
<DragonFreak>
ok just making sure
<meowth>
12-0-1
<Anton{Politoed}>
gr8 so i did that
<GBAToad>
wow thats like 13/15 members voting good job team
<Anton{Politoed}>
final thing from me for this one
<Anton{Politoed}>
it would be 14 but I didn't vote
<Anton{Politoed}>
I tend not to if the decision is clear
<Anton{Politoed}>
which I guess is an "abstain" but it's also not
<Anton{Politoed}>
but anyways final idea from me for this is
<Anton{Politoed}>
"Chance Minigames (Mario Party series)" only got 2 votes, but
<Blue_Bowser>
oh we should add chance minigames
<Anton{Politoed}>
it's also the thing that people overwhelmingly bitch about re: mario party minigames
<Blue_Bowser>
day at the races is bullshit
<meowth>
actually should uh
<Gabumon>
I support due to more personal bias
<Blue_Bowser>
I'm totally in favor of adding chance minigames
<DragonFreak>
it may get more votes if it's an actual nominee
<meowth>
it be Stickers/Cards (PM:SS & PM:CS) since everything else is an & for consistency
<DragonFreak>
because people usually probably dont think of doing write-ins
<Lord_Bowser>
i wouldn't have anything against adding chance minigames
<meowth>
i wouldn't oppose adding this
<Anton{Politoed}>
the & to me implies part of a unified title, but
<Lakituthequick>
isn't chance minigames noted somewhere already
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'll take a look at it soon to see if there's a standard I should've followed
<Lakituthequick>
i vuagly remember something liek that
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
hmmm
<Anton{Politoed}>
no
<Lakituthequick>
(i cant spell tonight)
<Anton{Politoed}>
we have an entire award for shitty minigames, but not a nominee within this one
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
not entirely sure if chance minigames should be added; we've seen it bitched about a lot
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i suppose though we could add it for now
<Lakituthequick>
that might be it
<Blue_Bowser>
Anton is day at the races on worst minigame
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
and see how much traction it gain
<Blue_Bowser>
I think it's worth a nomination
<Anton{Politoed}>
not as a formal nominee
<Anton{Politoed}>
also
<Anton{Politoed}>
even though I'm the one suggesting to add it, I also thing it's good to note that
<Anton{Politoed}>
the dice in Mario Party are also complete chance
<Anton{Politoed}>
the game itself doesn't provide much choice for the player to begin with
<Gabumon>
I mean
<shoutmon>
add mario party in its entirety
<Anton{Politoed}>
think*
<Gabumon>
you have SOME influence over your rolls with items
<Lakituthequick>
yeah the common thing among all party games (inncluding mario party) is the randomness in dice
<Gabumon>
or you can choose which paths to take
<Blue_Bowser>
I think it's different
<Blue_Bowser>
there's still skill and strategy
<Anton{Politoed}>
also I'm just gonna put this vote up now because my phone is getting blasted with like I think 8 texts I've counted now and I need to see if someone's dying
<Anton{Politoed}>
so
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Add "Chance Minigames (Mario Party series)" to F10? (y/n/a)
<Gabumon>
y
<Anton{Politoed}>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<Meta_Knight>
y
<Blue_Bowser>
y
<Lakituthequick>
a
<Gabumon>
yyyyyya
<GBAToad>
a
<turb>
y
<Lakituthequick>
six yes-votes and an abstain in one message
<Lakituthequick>
a new record
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<Mariofan169>
a
<Lord_Bowser>
8-0-3
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<Nyrie>
y
<Lord_Bowser>
10-0-3
<Anton{Politoed}>
no one's dying
<Anton{Politoed}>
anyways i'll add it now
<Anton{Politoed}>
anything else for this award?
<Lord_Bowser>
not that i can think of
<meowth>
y
<Lakituthequick>
add 'button controls'
<Lakituthequick>
(continue)
<turb>
add video games
<Anton{Politoed}>
F11 Biggest Missed Opportunity (Super Mario Advance 4, Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards, Sony Partnership Failure, Properly Representing Trans Issues, Underproducing amiibo, Super Mario Spikers Cancellation, Mario Takes America Cancellation, Donkey Kong Coconut Crackers Cancellation, Failure of the Mario Artist Series, Mario & Wario not being localized,
<turb>
but no just move on
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
add jumping
<Anton{Politoed}>
Wrecking Crew '98 not being localized, Paper Mario: Sticker Star Early Build, Donkey Kong Racing Cancellation, Super Mario's Wacky Worlds Cancellation)
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'll post results in a second
<Anton{Politoed}>
but
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
what did they fuck up on this year
<turb>
this is the award where i have an aneurysm over wording every year
<Lord_Bowser>
fangames
<Anton{Politoed}>
last year we tried to make these nominees clear but for some reason I still feel they're a bit off
<Anton{Politoed}>
idk if I'm just hallucinating
<shoutmon>
hey guys
<Lord_Bowser>
idk if many of them were mario fangames though
<Anton{Politoed}>
but I think we should take a super extra good look at it
<shoutmon>
lets rephrase the trans nominee like 15 more times
<Lakituthequick>
super extra
<Lakituthequick>
thats dense
<Lord_Bowser>
but i know nintendo has been super anal about fangames
<Anton{Politoed}>
13) Wrecking Crew '98 not being localized — 31 — 1.26% 14) Donkey Kong Coconut Crackers Cancellation — 17 — 0.69% 15) O. Super Mario 64 2 — 8 — 0.33% 16) O. N64DD — 4 — 0.16% 16) O. Super Mario Galaxy 3 — 4 — 0.16%
<Blue_Bowser>
What if we changed coconut crackers to Donkey Kong Racing
<Lakituthequick>
SMG3 is a thing
<GBAToad>
no course sharing in smm3ds is one id like to see added but first lets review whats there
<Lakituthequick>
?
<DragonFreak>
no
<Anton{Politoed}>
welcome back
<turb>
i WANT TO 22
<DragonFreak>
that's a good idea gbatoad cause i was Genuinely Upset at that
<turb>
but i know i cant
<turb>
theres nothing wrong with it
<Anton{Politoed}>
yeah as I'm reading this there's a few opposite tenses or whatever the word is
<Packy>
would underproducing amiibo be worth removing considering a lot of amiibo are (seemingly, anyway) kind of common nowadays?
<turb>
im just having an aneurysm over wordings
<Anton{Politoed}>
at least
<meowth>
spend the rest of the meetings rephrasing the trans nominee
<GBAToad>
we should start by making the tense consistent
<Anton{Politoed}>
"Underproducing amiibo" sounds like it should be negated
<turb>
per gba
<Anton{Politoed}>
and the rest seem fine I think
<Anton{Politoed}>
because the nominees are supposed to be Failed Opportunities
<Mariofan169>
most of the amiibo that had a rarity problem weren't mario amiibo
<Anton{Politoed}>
time to google synonyms a word for the opposite of underproducing that doesn't sound like shit
<Anton{Politoed}>
antonyms i mean
<meowth>
Super Mario Advance 4, Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards > Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards or something
<meowth>
right now it looks like two separate nominees
<shoutmon>
e-cards might be legitimately one to remove
<meowth>
o
<shoutmon>
since the wii u version included the bulk of the e-card content in every region
<shoutmon>
i'm not sure though
<GBAToad>
Actually yeah because the virtual console releases include them now gdi 22
<Lord_Bowser>
it did
<GBAToad>
sniped
<meowth>
good point
<DragonFreak>
gbatoad got dragoninja'd
<Anton{Politoed}>
20:45 meowth Super Mario Advance 4, Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards > Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards or something 20:46 meowth right now it looks like two separate nominees
<Anton{Politoed}>
I have no fucking clue what those are, but
<Mariofan169>
oh wow, second card discussion this hour
<Anton{Politoed}>
if they were supposed to be one nominee we totally didn't do that
<GBAToad>
Id say remove them since theyre irrelevant now
<Lord_Bowser>
remove it yeah
<Anton{Politoed}>
what's "it"
<meowth>
sma4 the missed opportunity
<Lord_Bowser>
it's not very applicable anymore
<Anton{Politoed}>
are they supposed to be one nominee
<Mariofan169>
per gba, I'll be damned if anyone used those
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah
<meowth>
super mario advance 4: super mario bros. 3
<meowth>
:
<shoutmon>
yeah the comma is probably a typo
<meowth>
but i think were probably killing the whole thing off so lol
<Anton{Politoed}>
we totally had them as 2 separate nominees last year
<shoutmon>
the thing smasher just said is the title of a game
<Anton{Politoed}>
and it wasn't caught
<shoutmon>
the e-cards are a feature that was poorly implemented in that game
<Anton{Politoed}>
6) Super Mario Bros. 3 e-Cards — 117 — 4.77%
<Anton{Politoed}>
11) Super Mario Advance 4 — 59 — 2.41%
<meowth>
Oops
<shoutmon>
thats kind of funny though
<Lord_Bowser>
welp
<Lakituthequick>
lol
<GBAToad>
honestly thats hilarious
<Mariofan169>
super mario advance 4 was a mistake
<shoutmon>
59 people thought super mario advance 4 in itself was a missed opportunity
<GBAToad>
Did the person who presented them catch on
<Anton{Politoed}>
this is an example of why we have the AC do this every year instead of just once and calling it complete
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
oooooops
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
lemme see
<Anton{Politoed}>
but yeah
<turb>
oh my god
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Remove "[whatever the title should be]" from F11? (y/n/a)
<turb>
im really glda that 59 people thought sma4 was that shit
<GBAToad>
y
<turb>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<Nyrie>
y
<Mariofan169>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<Lakituthequick>
y
<Anton{Politoed}>
gr8
<Lakituthequick>
F11 was presented by Chibiki Daisy and she only covered the top 3 in it
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<GBAToad>
oh rip
<GBAToad>
still wouldve been funny had they made a whole paragraph dedicated to the failings of sma4
in the past 6 months there was no mario's sky and like a fanmade super mario maker
<Mariofan169>
with no mario's sky it makes sense
<DragonFreak>
those are the two i know of at least
<Mariofan169>
why would nintendo associate with no man's buy
<Anton{Politoed}>
that's enough for me to consider it a valid concern so
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Add "[fangame nominee, name tbd because positive/negative phrasing]" to F11? (y/n/a)
<Lord_Bowser>
name it "Fangame takedowns" maybe?
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<Blue_Bowser>
n
<shoutmon>
a
<DragonFreak>
y
<Mariofan169>
n
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<Lakituthequick>
a
<Nyrie>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<Gamefreak75>
a
<Anton{Politoed}>
y
<turb>
a
<Lord_Bowser>
6-2-4
<Gabumon>
I'm willing to give it a shot to see how it performs
<Anton{Politoed}>
i've added it
<Anton{Politoed}>
anything else for F11?
<Lord_Bowser>
not that i can think of
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
nope
<GBAToad>
"No online course sharing in Super Mario Maker 3DS" or soemthing
<GBAToad>
Unless people dont care
<DragonFreak>
i cared
<DragonFreak>
because i was going to buy it until i learned that
<DragonFreak>
but idk how many other people cared
<Mariofan169>
people caring isn't an issue if mario vs wario is a nominee
<Anton{Politoed}>
oh yeah you also said "no mystery mushrooms in smm3ds"
<Lakituthequick>
it was /the/ thing that made the wii u version good
<Lakituthequick>
right
<shoutmon>
im sure people cared
<Lord_Bowser>
how about just
MK has joined #mwikiawards
Mode #mwikiawards +o MK by ChanServ
<GBAToad>
nah thats a minor thing compared to the bigger issue
<shoutmon>
it basically fucked the game
<MK>
Hi I'm on mobile
<Lord_Bowser>
general lack of key features in smm3ds
<Lord_Bowser>
hi mk
<shoutmon>
like honestly what can you even do with smm3ds
<shoutmon>
-play your own levels
<Lord_Bowser>
you can only share via streetpass
<GBAToad>
-cry
<DragonFreak>
make your own levels and nintendo's levels and that's it
<shoutmon>
-pray you live near someone who can make good levels
<Mariofan169>
but it just sounds like a criticism of the game rather than a missed opportunity
<GBAToad>
but isnt that what some of these are
<shoutmon>
-buy the wii u version
<Gabumon>
it fits in thematically with the other nominees
<Mariofan169>
true
<Lakituthequick>
add streetpass to f10
<Anton{Politoed}>
we could theoretically slap the entire game up there, yeah
<DragonFreak>
-realize you can't afford a wii u so you cry
<Anton{Politoed}>
and also include it in F15
<Lakituthequick>
(or dont idc)
<Gabumon>
realize you dont want a wii u in your house
<GBAToad>
And include in f15
<GBAToad>
gdi anton
<GBAToad>
too fast
<Mariofan169>
that gives me an idea
<DragonFreak>
i'll take your wii u if you want to donated it to the DFoundation
<Mariofan169>
would "lack of support for the wii u" be a nominee
<Lakituthequick>
> DFoundation
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
<Lakituthequick>
how do you even pronounce that
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i think it might just be better to put SMM3DS as its own F15 nominee
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
<DragonFreak>
just "DF Foundation" but having it share the F makes it look cool
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
<Anton{Politoed}>
yeah i'm kinda feeling what blocky's saying here
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'd like to avoid the redundancy
<shoutmon>
shuold i ban him
<shoutmon>
his client appears to be misconfigured
<shoutmon>
or somethign
<Anton{Politoed}>
i think it stopped
<Anton{Politoed}>
but if not then yeah
<turb>
oh i was going to make a joke
<shoutmon>
ok
<turb>
but i had to get up
Mode #mwikiawards +o Gamefreak75 by ChanServ
<shoutmon>
we should add "not making metroid prime 4 instead of donkey kong cold" to annoy borp
<Anton{Politoed}>
before we can vote on smm3ds though we need to settle on what aspect of it we want nominated
<turb>
"if 59 people can consider sma4 a mistake when we accidentally put it on there people will probably consider smm3ds a mistake all on its own when we intentionally put it on there"
<turb>
maybe that wasnt a very funny joke though
<Lakituthequick>
i laughed
<Anton{Politoed}>
the complaint seems to be more that it's a diluted version of the wii u game
<turb>
thanks
<shoutmon>
i mean its true but
<Lakituthequick>
yw
<shoutmon>
im really feeling like when the whole game is a mistake it should just be on 15
<Anton{Politoed}>
it being worded in that manner could set it apart from being a redundancy with F15, at least in title
<Anton{Politoed}>
but that's also twisting things just to get it on
Mobile_Knight has joined #mwikiawards
Mobile_Knight has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Excess Flood)
<Anton{Politoed}>
which I'm not exactly feeling for if we can just do F15 yeah
<Gabumon>
cant we just go with the original suggestion
<Gabumon>
of no level sharing
<Anton{Politoed}>
yeah, since that's the major killer of it
<Gabumon>
that's specific enough
<Gamefreak75>
yeah just go ith no level sharing
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah per edo
Mode #mwikiawards +b Mobile_Knight!*@* by shoutmon
<meowth>
yeah can we just do that
<Gamefreak75>
then slap it on f15 too
<Lord_Bowser>
no need to muddy it up too much
<shoutmon>
just the name so he can still get in on his computer
MK has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Ping timeout: 246 seconds)
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Add "[lack of online level sharing in smm3ds, name tbd]" to F11? (y/n/a)
<turb>
y
<shoutmon>
a
<Blue_Bowser>
y
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<meowth>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<GBAToad>
Y
<Gamefreak75>
y
<Lakituthequick>
y
<meowth>
9-0-1
<Lakituthequick>
it failed i think
<Mariofan169>
y
<Lakituthequick>
(wow that joke is old)
<Anton{Politoed}>
wii did it
<Anton{Politoed}>
next up
<GBAToad>
Yayyyyyyyyy
<meowth>
is that it weve been on this award a long time
<meowth>
10-0-1
<GBAToad>
yeah we need to move on
<turb>
let it go
<Lord_Bowser>
move on
<turb>
and move on
<Anton{Politoed}>
F12 Worst Game Objective (Boshi Race (SMRPG), Yoshi Eggs (SMA), Blue Coins (SMS), Rabbits (SM64DS), Flopside Pit of 100 Trials (SPM), Piccolo (SPM), Duel of 100 (SPM), World 9 (NSMBW), Letters (PM), One Million Coins (NSMB2), Green Stars (SMG2), Completing Every Level with Every Character (SM3DW), Star/Moon Coin Challenges (MG:WT),
nothing to remove and no writeins so whatever new things
<Gabumon>
personally I'd like to put "Rescuing Peach" on there just to see how many people agree, lol
<GBAToad>
same lol
<Lakituthequick>
does se-mode imply only levels with 0,0001% completion
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah super low %
<shoutmon>
"hurting poor sweet innocent cute bowser ;~;"
<Lord_Bowser>
^^^^^
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm taking director discretion and adding 22's suggestion
<turb>
i know i hate super expert
<GBAToad>
*posts mario as bowser gif*
<Lakituthequick>
should play New Super Bowser Bros. Wii
<GBAToad>
im ok with adding super expert as well
<GBAToad>
because like
<meowth>
super expert seems fine
<GBAToad>
u cant unlock all the costumes in the game without clearing it
<meowth>
thats horrific
<Lakituthequick>
is it required for "100%" for as far as that works in that game
<shoutmon>
we should have an award for all our great nominees like that and smasher's dialup kong
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
rip
<GBAToad>
yes basically
<Lord_Bowser>
yeah ltq
<Lakituthequick>
ai
<Lakituthequick>
[Sun 03:20:38] shoutmon we should have an award for all our great nominees like that and smasher's dialup kong
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Add "Super Expert Mode (SMR)" to F12? (y/n/a)
<Lakituthequick>
C16 best writeins
<GBAToad>
y
<shoutmon>
y
<shoutmon>
not smr though
<turb>
y
<shoutmon>
smm
<Blue_Bowser>
a
<Lord_Bowser>
(SMM)*
<Lord_Bowser>
y
<turb>
guys
<turb>
i found the u2/u3 merger replacement
<Lakituthequick>
y
<Gabumon>
y
<turb>
Favorite Joke Nominee
<Gamefreak75>
y
<DragonFreak>
y
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
y
<Mariofan169>
y
<GBAToad>
yynotsmrthoughysmma(smm)*yguysyyyyy
<Nyrie>
y
<Anton{Politoed}>
oh i must've misread but ok yeah that
<Gamefreak75>
Waluigi's Taco Stand Turbo Hd Remix
<Lakituthequick>
Turb & Smasher
<Anton{Politoed}>
any other nominees to add
<Anton{Politoed}>
or remove
<GBAToad>
nop
<meowth>
y to super expert mode
<GBAToad>
korok seeds /s
<shoutmon>
we need freakworld hes the only one who actually played smr
<meowth>
12-0-1
<Gamefreak75>
ya ha ha
<Lakituthequick>
i played it
<Nyrie>
i have 56 korok seeds
<Lakituthequick>
you need bad things about smr right
<Lakituthequick>
maybe the purple and black coins
<Lakituthequick>
but i dont know what you get from getting all of those yet
<Anton{Politoed}>
we don't need it because we're at 15 nominees
<Anton{Politoed}>
unless they're actually really bad
<Lakituthequick>
not that bad no
<turb>
i dont know what purple and black coins even are
<DragonFreak>
from what i played of the first 3 levels
<Nyrie>
there wasnt anything that bad about smr,,,,,,,,,
<DragonFreak>
they're just really tricky
<Lakituthequick>
i bought the entire game
<DragonFreak>
not really bad
<Lakituthequick>
(fight me)
<Nyrie>
it was just mediocre
<Anton{Politoed}>
gonna move on then
<Lakituthequick>
they get trickier
<Anton{Politoed}>
F13 Worst Mario Party Minigame (Tug o' War, Bash 'n' Cash, Flip the Chimp, Crane Game, Day at the Races, BOWSER's Big Blast, M.P.I.Q., The Beat Goes On, Game Guy Room, Pipe Maze, Right Oar Left?, Hot Rope Jump, Cheep Cheep Chance, Piranha’s Pursuit, Skateboard Scamper, Cast Aways, Bob-omb Combo, Cheep Cheep Check)
<GBAToad>
did anyone play mp10
<Lord_Bowser>
i like how BOWSER is all caps
<Nyrie>
i did
<Anton{Politoed}>
16) Piranha’s Pursuit — 40 — 1.97% 17) Cast Aways — 38 — 1.87% 18) Bash 'n' Cash — 37 — 1.82% 19) O. Bumper Balls — 8 — 0.39% 20) O. Cut from the Team — 7 — 0.34% 20) O. Pedal Power — 7 — 0.34% 20) O. Vicious Vending — 7 — 0.34% 23) O. Cointagious — 5 — 0.25%
<GBAToad>
did anyone like mp10
<Nyrie>
i dont know
<Anton{Politoed}>
there's 18 nominees now so we absolutely have to remove something to add anything
<turb>
i know i didnt play mp10
<shoutmon>
(pink, purple, and black coins are basically like the dragon coins from super mario world)
<Nyrie>
why do we have more than one luck minigame
<shoutmon>
(each time you collect one color, you unlock a new color)
<Mariofan169>
everyone left the party
<Mariofan169>
and took all the punch with them
<Nyrie>
how can someone like one luck minigame more than another one
<Anton{Politoed}>
because theme is important
<shoutmon>
(the new colors are in more difficult positions)
<Anton{Politoed}>
but we also don't have 18 luck games
<Anton{Politoed}>
so I think it's a good balance
<Nyrie>
well alright
<Nyrie>
fair enough
<GBAToad>
man fuck cheep cheeps with their luck fishing games
<Lakituthequick>
(do the dragon coins need to be collected all at once every time too)
<Nyrie>
FUCK flip the chimp
<meowth>
i have mp10 but i havent actually played any of the minigames on it
<Anton{Politoed}>
it's like playing slots at a casino
<meowth>
i've failed
<Blue_Bowser>
WHO DOESN'T BOWSER
<shoutmon>
(in sma4 they do)
<Blue_Bowser>
S BIG BLAST
<Anton{Politoed}>
they're all the same luck bullshit
<Anton{Politoed}>
but you always look for a machine that has a theme you like so you forget that you're losing money
<shoutmon>
(sma2*)
<Gabumon>
that moment when you regret that the mariowiki community doesn't care about mario most of the time, so it's harder to gauge fan opinions
<GBAToad>
should we add luigi minigames from sm64ds :^)
<shoutmon>
(in original smw it doesn't really matter, but you get a 1up if you do)
<GBAToad>
gambling aside
<Lakituthequick>
(ah okay)
<Lakituthequick>
(smr is the later version then)
<GBAToad>
edo we care but only about daisys appearance in smash bros
<turb>
new plan
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm perfectly fine with leaving this award as-is
<Mariofan169>
that roulette minigame is easy as hell to manipulate
<turb>
just replace the AC with marioverse posters
<Lakituthequick>
luigi minigames are nice though
<Lord_Bowser>
make the twins the directors
<turb>
also yeah
<turb>
im fine with leaving this as is
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
same
<Lakituthequick>
!skip
<GBAToad>
ltq i know
<Lord_Bowser>
per moving on
<Anton{Politoed}>
if we see an uptick of mp10 games come in this year then we'll have a better basis
<GBAToad>
skip
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
if there's any really shitty mp10 minigames they'll probably - yeah
<Mariofan169>
just put two tokens on the red and black spaces
<Mariofan169>
impossible to lose
<GBAToad>
cant wait for mario party mobile if that ever becomes a thing and i also cant wait for it not to have online multiplayer
<Anton{Politoed}>
F14 Worst Setting (Subcon (SMB2), Starship Mario & Galaxies (SMG2), Mushroom Kingdom (SM3DL), Sprixie Kingdom (SM3DW), Flip-/Flopside & Dimensions (SPM), Mushroom Kingdom (M&L:PiT), Pi'illo Island (M&L:DT), Party Cube (MP4), Star Carnival (MP8), Shroom City (MPA), Party Islands (MP:IT), Egg Island (YNI), Transformed Wario Castle (WW),
<Anton{Politoed}>
DK Isles/Crocodile Isle (DK64), The Fun Fair & Surrounding Areas (MPL))
add the ss kingdom thats a pretty good amount of writeins
<shoutmon>
what did people have against isle delfino
<shoutmon>
that was a great setting
<Mariofan169>
they had a missed opportunity by not putting shadow mario in color splash
<GBAToad>
they have black bowser tho
<Anton{Politoed}>
beyond that, though, any other changes
<turb>
not imo
<Mariofan169>
oh
<Anton{Politoed}>
did color splash do anything
<Mariofan169>
oh dear
<Nyrie>
no
<Nyrie>
color splash had good settings
<GBAToad>
nah colour splash had prism island and we added that to best aesthetic so i dont see why we should add it here
<GBAToad>
skip
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
yeah if it's good enough for best setting it definitely doesn't fit here imo
<Anton{Politoed}>
gr8
<shoutmon>
well, there's always the possibility that somethign will be super divisive
<shoutmon>
i dont think this was, thoguh
<Nyrie>
i dont know anyone who hated prism island
<Anton{Politoed}>
F15 Most Disappointing Game (New Super Mario Bros. 2, Paper Mario: Sticker Star, Yoshi’s New Island, Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games, Mario Party 10, Yoshi’s Island DS, Super Paper Mario, Mario Party 9, Diddy Kong Racing DS, Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash, Super Mario All-Stars Limited Edition, Super Mario 64 DS, Super Mario 3D Land,
<Anton{Politoed}>
Mario Party: Island Tour, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Mario Party 8, Super Mario Sunshine, New Super Mario Bros. U/New Super Luigi U)
<Blue_Bowser>
it was a good place
<Anton{Politoed}>
this is already at 18
<Anton{Politoed}>
to add smm3ds we need to remove something
<Lakituthequick>
18 disappointments
<Lakituthequick>
wow
<GBAToad>
Super mario maker 3ds needs to be there so id opt for removal of all stars
<Anton{Politoed}>
16) Super Mario 3D Land — 38 — 1.48% 17) Yoshi's Island DS — 34 — 1.32% 18) Super Mario Galaxy 2 — 32 — 1.25% 19) O. Hotel Mario — 13 — 0.51% 20) O. Paper Mario: Color Splash — 8 — 0.31% 21) O. Super Mario 3D World — 7 — 0.27% 22) O. Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam — 5 — 0.19%
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm not going to allow Hotel Mario to be added
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
ofc
<Mariofan169>
remove 64ds
<GBAToad>
or actually smg2
<Lord_Bowser>
remove smg2
<GBAToad>
since that was low
<Mariofan169>
it wasn't that disappointing
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
yeah we'd replace smg2
<Anton{Politoed}>
if we're to remove anything it should be yids
<Anton{Politoed}>
:bowser:
<DragonFreak>
i like how there was votes for color splash
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
why's that?
<DragonFreak>
was that game even out?
<Anton{Politoed}>
to make 22 mad
<turb>
as salty as i get over all stars still being on this award
<turb>
we should probably replace smg2
<meowth>
the lowest vote should be removed so
<Blue_Bowser>
why is all stars on here again
<Blue_Bowser>
why is galaxy 2 on here again?
<Anton{Politoed}>
the votes are tight enough, though, to not consider 18th place to be booted by default
<meowth>
kill smg2 for smm3ds
<Anton{Politoed}>
so if people wanna debate which one to remove then I'm up for that
<DragonFreak>
galaxy 2 is just a clone of galaxy 1
<shoutmon>
is this the wii version of all stars
<Anton{Politoed}>
we've got 25 minutes to do it
<Lakituthequick>
smg2 probs because its smg + more levels or something
<shoutmon>
you literally could not be disappointed by that
<Mariofan169>
64 ds was aimed to be an example of the capabilities of the ds
<meowth>
thats a good point but of those three i think its the one most viable to be remove anyway
<Mariofan169>
and it succeeded overall
<shoutmon>
because it was impossible to not know exactly what to expect going into it
<Anton{Politoed}>
ltq that sounds like a reason for it to be on the award
<meowth>
yeah and a lot of people thought it wasn't a very good port
<Lakituthequick>
well thats what i explained pretty much
<shoutmon>
???smas?
<shoutmon>
it was exactly like the snes version
<shoutmon>
what exactly did they expect
<Mariofan169>
the version with smw, maybe
<Anton{Politoed}>
15) Super Mario 64 DS — 40 — 1.56% 16) Super Mario 3D Land — 38 — 1.48% 17) Yoshi's Island DS — 34 — 1.32% 18) Super Mario Galaxy 2 — 32 — 1.25%
<Anton{Politoed}>
there's the 4 we can consider
<Mariofan169>
64 ds
<Lakituthequick>
sm64ds isnt bad
<Gabumon>
lol
<shoutmon>
sm64ds is universally agreed to be the worst thing in human history actually
<Gabumon>
we literally had a conversation about that the other day
<GBAToad>
it has luigi gambling
<Blue_Bowser>
I really like sm64 ds
<turb>
per 22
<meowth>
i liked sm64ds but plenty of people didnt
<Lord_Bowser>
was sm3dl genuinely disappointing to many people
<Mariofan169>
it's a tech demo through and through
<Mariofan169>
did people not like it because of the d pad?
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i liked 64 DS
<Blue_Bowser>
Lord_Bowser I thought sm3dl was on of the best mario games in years
<DragonFreak>
i will be ok with removing either smas or smg2
<Packy>
i don't know because i don't have the results in front of me, but
<shoutmon>
sm3dl was boring
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
but i am okay with leaving it on
<Blue_Bowser>
why not both
<Lakituthequick>
how is ds a tech demo when its larger than sm64 itself
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
because i know that people dislike it for good reasons
<Packy>
what's the vote differential between 15th and 14th place??
<DragonFreak>
but 22 KITSUNE LUIGI
<shoutmon>
boring
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok so idk how to hold this vote exactly
<DragonFreak>
wa
<Anton{Politoed}>
since it's hard to allow multiple options in a quick vote like these
<shoutmon>
kumiho waluigi
<DragonFreak>
what's a kumiho
<Mariofan169>
it was there to examplify how well the ds' 3d graphics were
<Lakituthequick>
ask vote for 15/16/17/18/a ?
<Lord_Bowser>
maybe make this a topic instead
<shoutmon>
look it up
<DragonFreak>
oh ok
<Lord_Bowser>
it seems too complex to be a vote here
<DragonFreak>
it's a ninetails
<Anton{Politoed}>
so I guess what I'll do to see how it works is kinda what ltq just said
<Anton{Politoed}>
starting after I post a line break just shout which one of those 4 you want to be removed from F15
<Anton{Politoed}>
-------------
<Gabumon>
what we really need is centaur luigi
<GBAToad>
super mario galaxy 2
<Mariofan169>
64 ds
<meowth>
the one i most want to remove is smas but thats not an option so lol
<Lakituthequick>
15
<Gamefreak75>
smg2
<meowth>
galaxy 2
<DragonFreak>
18
<shoutmon>
why gabumon
<Lakituthequick>
=sm64ds
<Lord_Bowser>
smg2
<shoutmon>
why would you say taht
<Gamefreak75>
lynel luigi
<Lord_Bowser>
boytaur luigi
<meowth>
2-0-0-4-0
<turb>
galaxy 2 i guess
<shoutmon>
18
<meowth>
2-0-0-6-0
<DragonFreak>
lb,,,,,,
<shoutmon>
you guys are the worst
<DragonFreak>
why do you even know about boytaurs
<shoutmon>
seriously
Packy has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Read error: Connection reset by peer)
<shoutmon>
thats a good question
<Lord_Bowser>
you and 22 told me about them
<Mariofan169>
reverse centaur bowser
<Gabumon>
yeah I actually cant decide
<Anton{Politoed}>
here now I can do this now that it's down to 2 solid directions
<Anton{Politoed}>
Vote: Remove which nominee from F15? (SM64DS / SMG2 / a)
<meowth>
smg2
<DragonFreak>
smg2
<Gamefreak75>
smg2
<shoutmon>
smg2
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
smg2
<Lord_Bowser>
smg2
<Blue_Bowser>
smg2
<Mariofan169>
64 ds
<Gabumon>
smg2
<meowth>
1-8-0
<turb>
smg2
<meowth>
1-9-0
<Lakituthequick>
sm64ds
<GBAToad>
smg20
<DragonFreak>
woah
<meowth>
2--10-0
<Mariofan169>
well dang
<Gabumon>
someone here is from the future
<Lord_Bowser>
oh my god imagine 20 super mario galaxies
<meowth>
my nominee stays
<meowth>
eat shit
<DragonFreak>
i cant even imagine 1
<Gabumon>
thats why he has technology strapped to his head
<Mariofan169>
nintendo chugs out those games fas
<Mariofan169>
t
<Anton{Politoed}>
the assumption of this was to add "Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS"
<shoutmon>
whats your nominee
<Anton{Politoed}>
so I'll be doing that too
mcd has left irc.darkmyst.org:6697 (Quit: z)
<Anton{Politoed}>
anything else to do to F15?
<Lord_Bowser>
nope
<Lakituthequick>
well
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
not that i can think of
<Lakituthequick>
since nothing can be added unless we remove a thing
<Lakituthequick>
nope
<meowth>
sm64ds was my suggestion last year
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
color splash wasn't really disappointing imo
<shoutmon>
oh ok
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
people had low expectations after sticker star
<Blue_Bowser>
Color Splash was fucking great
<GBAToad>
yay 15 minutes what do
<shoutmon>
yeah color splash was the opposite of a disappointment
<Anton{Politoed}>
well with that we're kinda-done with Fail Awards, except for the few threads I gotta make
<shoutmon>
i expected nothing and was pleasantly surprised
<DragonFreak>
i'm still disappointed by color splash :)
<Anton{Politoed}>
up next is going to be Community Awards
<Anton{Politoed}>
we're scheduled to start this next week so :clap: to being ahead
i probably should have done this earlier before i was dying and then came back to life
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'm going to compile those into a poll to select 15-18
<DragonFreak>
favorite joke nomination is a good idea
<Mariofan169>
gamefreak is that a serious proposal or
<Anton{Politoed}>
when I set that poll up isn't an exact time so basically
<Anton{Politoed}>
don't diddle your dick waiting to do this
Raiko_Chaorikawa nominates Cheese
<shoutmon>
if it is im proposing favorite ban of gamefreak
<Anton{Politoed}>
and do it immediately after this meeting closes
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
anton i already did this
<meowth>
we cut a while ago because it was a bad award
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
can i diddle my dick instead
<Anton{Politoed}>
yes blocky
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
thx
<meowth>
cut fad*
<Mariofan169>
because it sounds like a very bad idea
<Anton{Politoed}>
aside from C4
<GBAToad>
ok but like anton and blocky have already covered my nominees
<shoutmon>
boos dont have dicks, this isnt canon
<GBAToad>
Do toads have dicks
<DragonFreak>
i already did it too
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
how do you think they reproduce then
<DragonFreak>
granted i only nominated one
<Anton{Politoed}>
another big thing is a potential vacant spot
<shoutmon>
toads' whole bodies are dicks
<DragonFreak>
but it was the only one i wanted to nominate
<Mariofan169>
they're ghosts, they can't reproduce
<Anton{Politoed}>
the former U2 and U3 were mostly-decided to be cut
<Anton{Politoed}>
Favorite Written Fiction cut entirely because there's literally 0-1 nominees from within the last couple years
<shoutmon>
toads actually physically explode to reproduce
<meowth>
rip
<Anton{Politoed}>
and Favorite Comic because it scrapes by at 5 but is kind of a package deal
<Gabumon>
ideas for SMG20?
<Blue_Bowser>
everyone knows toads reproduce via spores
<Mariofan169>
crossover with star wars
<GBAToad>
Mario fucking dies
<Anton{Politoed}>
U4 Favorite User Design was also decided to be cut
<Gabumon>
peach gets sucked into a black hole and turns into a literal spaghetti
<Blue_Bowser>
haven't you played mario tennis for the n64
<shoutmon>
yeah they explode into clouds of spores
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
speaking of favorite comic
<Anton{Politoed}>
there's still meeting time left so plz focus
<Gabumon>
mario accidentally eats her and realizes his mistake
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
it turns out that the tonight show was actually saved after all
<Anton{Politoed}>
but U4
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
the miracle happen
<Gabumon>
so he induces vomiting
<DragonFreak>
rip favorite user design :(
<Gabumon>
but it turns out when you launch something into space, it just keeps going
<Anton{Politoed}>
while decided to be cut, could also be resurrected if a new award idea isn't suggested
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
(i mean it's four years done so no need to add it anyway)
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
mmmm
<Anton{Politoed}>
I'd prefer new ideas to be pondered so that's another thing to do
<Gabumon>
so the objective of the game is to just chase your own vomit forever
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
i'd rather come up with something new so i'll try my best
<Lord_Bowser>
favorite user project
<Lord_Bowser>
or sth like that
<GBAToad>
favourite oregon trial part
<Anton{Politoed}>
lb that was a topic of debate in the shroom meeting
<Anton{Politoed}>
that being a defacto merging of U2/U3
<Mariofan169>
favorite sippin time thread
<turb>
i had shit in a favorite fan creation idea in another chat earlier
<Anton{Politoed}>
it wasn't well-received
<turb>
but idk what it would be
<turb>
unless it had stuff from lper too mayeb
<shoutmon>
add d&d to favorite community event
<turb>
but even then bbbbbbbbbbbbb
<Anton{Politoed}>
that's not to say the AC won't think it's a gr8 idea but
<turb>
good idea
<turb>
i want to vote for dnd
<Mariofan169>
weeeeell
<Anton{Politoed}>
that's what the shroom staff thought of it
<GBAToad>
why
<GBAToad>
what was their reasoning
<Anton{Politoed}>
Comics and Written Fiction can't exactly be judged on the same level
<shoutmon>
i cant wait for d&d to get exactly 6 votes
<Mariofan169>
it's something that only has a few members participating
<Lakituthequick>
i see both pros and cons for a merge so
<Anton{Politoed}>
comics pretty much objectively are viewed more favorably
<Mariofan169>
unless people can spectate
<turb>
not if i use my weekly votes to give it more
<Anton{Politoed}>
due to being visual media
<Gabumon>
I gave a whole rhethoric on why I was against the merge in the shroom meeting
<Anton{Politoed}>
there's logs somewhere
<Anton{Politoed}>
I literally can't remember if they're visible to the entire AC
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
nope
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
the logs are in the hroom staff board
<Mariofan169>
favorite incarnation of tabuu's 132
<Anton{Politoed}>
I guess we can make those available along with the next shroom meeting after that one closes
<DragonFreak>
lol
<Mariofan169>
I expect at least 9 nominees for that one
<Anton{Politoed}>
otherwise it's just nominee updates for the rest
<Anton{Politoed}>
while there's still time for shroom staff to ruminate on last bits
<GBAToad>
The fantastic user ass appreciation award
<Anton{Politoed}>
is there anything people here in the AC want to be done to Community Awards that could maybe be better worked on in a focused group during the shroom meeting on sunday?
<shoutmon>
mcd wins
<GBAToad>
idk im ok with the shroom awards for the most part
<GBAToad>
just so long as we change the names to make the distinction that theyre shroom awards
<Anton{Politoed}>
yeah we'll be doing that
<meowth>
favorite part about smasher
<turb>
i dont really feel like theres anything that would be significantly better handled in that meeting
<turb>
aside from maybe working a bit more on that replacement thing
<turb>
but _
<turb>
probably already planned
<DragonFreak>
[20:53] GBAToad The fantastic user ass appreciation award
<GBAToad>
im drawing a bbbbbbbb at new awards atm
<DragonFreak>
nominate me
<Mariofan169>
favorite april fools prank?
<Mariofan169>
probably not that strong but
<shoutmon>
im not sure how many people are goign to remember previous years tbh
<meowth>
the problem with that would be that no one would remember the old ones
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
[s]favorite user fetish[/s]
<Anton{Politoed}>
Favorite Community Event was a User Award that we removed I think last year
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
but yeah in a serious note
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
-it was
<Raiko_Chaorikawa>
mostly because it ran low
<Anton{Politoed}>
it included the April Fools things
<meowth>
oh i forgot we removed that
<Mariofan169>
ah
<Anton{Politoed}>
ok well if that's that I'll get to closing the meeting, but
<Anton{Politoed}>
things to work on between now and next meeting:
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Topic for adding battle courses to F8 Worst Mario Kart Course?
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Topic for negative/positive phrasing in F11
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Finish C4
<Anton{Politoed}>
*Brainstorm a new Community Award idea
<Anton{Politoed}>
I think that's it for those things
<GBAToad>
woop http://i.imgur.com/goB0uqH.gif <=to be continued|\|/
<Lakituthequick>
(if we're adding battle courses to f8 we sohuld also add to a4)
<Anton{Politoed}>
good idea ltq
<Lakituthequick>
*M4
<shoutmon>
i was actually thinking abuot making it a separate award
<shoutmon>
idk if anything is weak this year
<Blue_Bowser>
it's gonna be to much of a cluster if it's not
<Anton{Politoed}>
out of Fail Awards, not really
<Anton{Politoed}>
but that's what the thread will be for
<shoutmon>
no, in the main awards
<Anton{Politoed}>
to decide if it's a new award or just shoehorning
<GBAToad>
mario maker element is probably the weakest but we decided to keep that because smm3ds